When a Kid Asks, “Is Life Even Worth It?” A Teacher’s Perspective
It was a Tuesday, which is probably why I wasn’t prepared. We were doing a morning check-in, the kind where students share one word for how they’re feeling before we start class. Maya said “tired.” Jamal said “hungry.” Then Leo, who usually sits in the back and says nothing at all, shrugged and said, “I don’t get why people keep going, honestly.”
The room got quiet in that way classrooms rarely are. A few kids looked at me. I had a split second to decide whether to brush past it or sit with it. I remember the half-eaten granola bar on my desk and the half-finished attendance sheet. Every instinct said “let’s move on” so we could get to the lesson on time. But I put the attendance sheet down.
“That’s a really honest thing to say,” I told him. “What’s making it feel that way today?”
Leo looked surprised, like he’d expected to be scolded. He muttered something about homework, about how none of it mattered, about how everyone always says things will get better but nobody actually knows. I didn’t have a neat answer. So I said, “You’re right. I don’t know for sure that it gets better. I just know that some days are really hard and some days are less hard, and I try to pay attention to the less hard ones.”
The conversation lasted maybe two minutes. Then we moved on to fractions. But I couldn’t stop thinking about it.
The way Leo asked the question wasn’t dramatic. There was no tears, no sign of crisis. It was flat, almost bored, like he was reporting a weather fact. That’s what unsettled me. I’ve learned that when kids ask if life is worth living, they’re not always in despair. Sometimes they’re just trying out a big thought that has been floating around in their heads. But sometimes they are telling you something real, and you have to be awake enough to know the difference.
The truth is, this question is more common than most adults realize. I started asking around the school, and other teachers had heard versions of it too. “What’s the point of school?” “Why bother with a career if the world is falling apart?” “I didn’t ask to be born.” They don’t usually phrase it as “life is worthless.” They phrase it as apathy, as “so what,” as a shrug during a lesson on the quadratic formula.
It’s easy to react with reassurance: “But you have so much to live for!” or “Your future is bright!” I’ve seen teachers do that, and I’ve done it too. But that kind of response often shuts kids down because it doesn’t take them seriously. They know when you’re saying something you’re supposed to say rather than something you actually believe.
What has worked better is to ask a small follow-up question and then be quiet. Not “Are you okay?” because that puts the pressure on them to reassure you. Something like, “What’s been making you think about that?” or “Tell me more about what that feeling is like.” You’re not trying to fix it. You’re just making space for it. That sounds simple, but it’s hard to do when your heart is pounding and your mind is racing to “what do I say next.”
I also learned not to take the bait and start arguing. When a kid says “life isn’t worth it,” your first instinct is to list reasons why it definitely is: your family, your friends, your favorite meal, the feeling of sunlight. But in that moment, you’re not being helpful. You’re just showing them how uncomfortable you are with their honesty. The most useful thing I’ve said a few times is, “I’m glad you told me. It takes courage to say that out loud.” And I mean it. Because the kids who keep it quiet are the ones I worry about more.
After Leo’s comment, I made some changes in how I run my classroom. Nothing huge. I started adding “one okay thing” to our morning check-in every now and then. Not a gratitude list, not “say something positive.” Just: “What was one okay thing from yesterday, from the last hour, from this morning?” Small and concrete. It gave kids a way to notice that not every single moment was terrible without forcing a false positive.
I also changed how I talk about my own hard days. Teachers tend to present themselves as steady, patient, above the chaos. But that’s not real, and kids can smell fake from across the room. So now, if I’m tired or anxious or sad, I sometimes say so out loud. “I had a hard time sleeping last night and it’s taking me a while to get going.” I don’t overdo it, and I don’t use them as my emotional support. But I want them to know that adults don’t have all the answers either. We just have more practice at waking up and trying again.
One afternoon, Leo stayed after class. He didn’t have a question about the worksheet. He just stood by my desk and sort of shuffled his feet. I asked if he wanted to talk. He shrugged. So I said, “I’ve been thinking about what you said. Are you having thoughts about hurting yourself?” I asked directly because I needed to know. He shook his head. “No, it’s more like… what’s the point of trying if everything’s messy anyway?”
We talked for a few minutes. I didn’t solve anything. I told him I thought “messy” was an accurate way to describe things. I told him that I wasn’t going to give him a quote about hope because he’d probably find it annoying. He laughed a little at that. I said, “I don’t know what your purpose is or whether there’s some big cosmic meaning. But I do know that you’re here, and I’m here, and sometimes that’s enough to keep going.”
He nodded and left with his backpack half open. I wasn’t sure if anything I said landed. I still don’t know.
Parents and caregivers face similar moments, often at dinner or in the car, where a child asks something huge out of nowhere. The instinct to rush in with certainty is strong. But you don’t have to have the perfect answer. You just have to be willing to stay in the conversation. That might mean saying, “I don’t know why we’re here, but I’m glad you are.” Or “That’s a question I’ve had too, and I still live with it every day.” Or “You don’t have to figure out the whole meaning of life tonight. We can just get through dinner and see how tomorrow feels.”
It’s also okay to be honest about your own uncertainty. A lot of adults want to project confidence because they think kids need it. But the kids I work with don’t need confidence. They need company. They need to know that they aren’t the only one who lies awake sometimes. They need to see that you can feel lost and still eat breakfast, go to work, laugh at a silly video, and find something okay about the afternoon.
What I’ve learned from Leo and students like him is that the question “is life worth living” isn’t usually a question at all. It’s a feeling dressed up as a question. And you can’t reason someone out of a feeling. You have to walk beside them in it for a while.
Leo still has hard days. He still rolls his eyes when I ask him to show his work. But last week, he stayed after to tell me about a video game he’d been playing, something about an open world and a character who starts with nothing. He seemed almost excited. I didn’t say “see, things are getting better.” I just listened. Because that would have been too neat, and real life isn’t neat.
I don’t know if Leo walked away from that conversation thinking life is definitely worth it. I don’t even know if I can answer that question for myself all the time. But he keeps coming to class, and I keep coming to class, and sometimes that’s enough. Maybe that’s the most honest thing we can offer: not a reason to live, but a place where you’re welcome to keep asking.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When a Kid Asks, “Is Life Even Worth It