What Your Kid’s First Day of School Answer Really Means (Fun Real Responses From Real Kids)
The back door slammed at 3:15 yesterday, sending my two kids tumbling into the kitchen, backpacks slipping off their shoulders, sneakers scuffing the crumbs I missed sweeping this morning. I was pulling uncrustables and a bowl of Goldfish out of the fridge, and I asked the question every parent asks the second they walk in: “How was the first day of school?”
My 4th grader Javi shrugged, pulled a crumpled lollipop out of his pocket and said, “There was a fly in our classroom. Mr. Torres spent 10 minutes trying to catch it with a reusable shopping bag.” Then he turned and walked to the living room. That’s it.
My 2nd grader Lila leaned against the counter, pulled one sock off and tipped a small pool of water onto my tile. “The drinking fountain by the bathroom squirts too hard. I got both socks wet.”
I stood there holding the Goldfish bowl, and realized this is exactly what happened last year, and the year before that. I used to stand there confused, convinced I’d done something wrong, that they must hate school, that they hadn’t made any friends, why won’t they tell me anything? I texted my local parent group chat to ask what other people got for their first day answers, and the responses rolled in—all just as chaotic, funny, and totally off from what adults expect.
One mom with a kindergartener said her daughter’s full answer was “I ate three graham crackers. Can I have a cookie now?” A dad with a 7th grader said his son replied “It happened” when asked how it went, and refused to say anything else for two hours. Another first grade mom said her kid came home and announced “Worst day of my life. They got rid of the blue cookie cutters for art time.” A kindergarten teacher in the chat shared that her own 5-year-old came home and only talked about how the bus driver’s hair was neon blue. All of these responses had one thing in common: none of them answered the big “how was your entire day” question I’d been asking.
A few years ago, I’d have followed up with 20 more questions: “But what about your teacher? Did you meet any new friends? Did you learn anything cool?” I’d prod and poke until Javi got annoyed and locked himself in his room, and I’d spend the night worrying he was having a terrible time. Then I talked to Javi’s first grade teacher at back to school night, and she explained something that changed how I ask about school. By 3 pm on the first day, kids have been “on” for six, seven, even eight hours straight. They’ve had to remember new rules, sit still when they want to run, remember to raise their hand, remember where the bathroom is. Their working memory is completely full. They can’t pull back the entire day and sum it up for you the way an adult can. The only things that are front of mind are the tiny, unexpected things that stood out: the fly, the squirty fountain, the graham crackers. That’s not them being uncooperative. That’s their brain being tired.
That doesn’t mean you can’t learn more about their day, it just means you have to change how and when you ask. The first thing I started doing that works is waiting 20 minutes after they get home before I ask any questions about school. Let them eat, run around the yard, build a wobbly couch fort, burn off the stuck energy first. No interrogation right at the door. Second, I stopped asking big open questions like “how was your day” that are too big for a tired brain to answer. Instead I ask tiny, specific questions that don’t require a big summary: “What was the silliest thing that happened today?” “Did anyone do something that made you laugh?” “What’s one thing that was easier than you thought it would be?” Even that, if they only give one line, I don’t push.
If the answer is negative, like Lila’s wet socks, I don’t jump straight to problem solving. I used to immediately say “I’ll send a note to the teacher tomorrow, we’ll get that fixed!” But now I just say “That sounds so annoying. My socks got wet at school once and it was the worst all day.” Nine times out of 10, that’s all they wanted. They didn’t need me to fix the drinking fountain, they just needed to say the thing that bugged them out loud. Last year, Lila complained about wet socks on the first day, and by the end of the week she’d figured out how to stand far enough back to stay dry, and she never mentioned it again.
This year, after Javi and Lila gave their answers, I just said “That fly sounds like a total menace” and “Ugh, wet socks are the worst. Let me get you a dry pair.” I didn’t ask any follow up questions. They ate their Goldfish, dragged all the couch cushions into the living room to build a fort, and didn’t talk about school again until bedtime. When I was tucking Javi in, he was picking at the sticker on his water bottle, and randomly said “Oh, I sat next to a kid named Milo today. He’s got a Charizard binder, same as me. We’re trading cards on Friday.” Ten minutes later, after I turned the light off, Lila yelled from her room “My teacher let me draw a unicorn on my name tag! It has pink sparkles.” It all came out, when they were relaxed and ready to share, not when I was standing in the kitchen prodding for an answer two minutes after they walked in.
It’s easy to get caught up in wanting the perfect first day story. We see all the photos and big “it was the best day ever” posts online, so when our kid only wants to talk about a fly, it feels like something went wrong. But these tiny, funny, off-topic answers are actually the most honest ones you’ll get. They tell you what your kid cares about, what they notice, how they’re processing all the newness of the year. I still don’t get a big full recap right after school most days, and I still sometimes have to stop myself from prodding too hard. But so far, waiting and asking small questions has worked way better than any big interrogation ever did. I’m still waiting for this year’s first day fly to make another appearance, according to Javi. It’s only a matter of time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Your Kid’s First Day of School Answer Really Means (Fun Real Responses From Real Kids)