What to Say When Your Middle Schooler Asks, “Do These Make Me Look Gay?”
The shoe store had that fluorescents-light, plastic-scented vibe that makes every surface feel slightly sticky. My son, whom I will call Sam, held up a pair of neon-orange sneakers with chunky soles. They were, objectively, loud. Sam is fourteen and usually wears gray. He’s not a color person.
“Do these make me look gay?” he asked, not looking at me, turning the shoe over in his hand.
I felt my throat tighten. This is the moment the parenting books don’t prepare you for. My first instinct was to say, “Don’t say that,” or “It’s not a bad thing,” or launch into some kind of speech. But the part of me that has learned a few things by messing things up bought me two seconds. So I just said, “What kind of look are you going for?”
He shrugged. “I don’t know. Just. You know. Sometimes clothes make people look a certain way.”
“You mean style?” I asked.
“Yeah. Style. Like, if I wear pink or tight shirts, people think I’m gay. I don’t want people thinking things that aren’t true.”
That last phrase hit me. He wasn’t asking about his identity. He was asking about other people’s assumptions. He wanted to be recognized for who he actually is, not whatever story a pair of shoes might tell about him. And I realized that “gay” in his mouth wasn’t necessarily about sexuality. It was a shorthand for “different.” For “target.” For “someone kids might laugh at in the hallway.”
So I put down the shoes and said, “Do you care if people think that?”
He looked at me like I’d suggested he skip school. “Obviously. Wouldn’t you?”
I thought about it. Probably yes, when I was his age. But I didn’t say that. Instead, I asked, “What would it change? If someone saw the shoes and thought that, what would they do?”
He stared at the floor. “I don’t know. I just don’t want to be the weird kid.”
That’s what it was. Not a question about fashion. Not a question about orientation. A question about safety in the unpredictable ecosystem of middle school. He wasn’t asking for a lecture on identity. He was asking for a map through a social field that changes every day.
Here’s what I have come to understand after a few of these conversations, both at home and as a volunteer in classrooms: when kids ask “Does this make me look gay?” or say “That’s gay,” they are almost never making a political statement. They are telling you, in their clumsy way, that they are noticing patterns and trying to fit in. It’s a developmental moment, not a moral failure.
That doesn’t mean adults should ignore it. But the way we respond matters.
In my son’s case, I decided not to shut him down. I also didn’t want to make him feel guilty for being worried about what other people think, because that worry is real and he didn’t choose it. So I did the only practical thing I could think of: I kept him talking.
“Let me ask you,” I said, “what makes a shoe ‘gay’? Is it the color? The shape? Or is it that someone decided that’s what it means?”
He actually laughed a little. “I don’t know. Everyone just knows.”
“Everyone knows what?”
“That orange sneakers are… I don’t know. Not normal.”
“But you like them,” I said.
“I do.”
“So what’s the problem?”
He thought for a minute. “I guess the problem is what other people think.”
“That is a real problem,” I said. “I’m not going to tell you to ignore it. But I also want you to know that you get to decide what your clothes mean. If you wear them because you like them, that’s the truth. People don’t get to invent a different story about you without your permission.”
Sam didn’t have a big revelation. He just said, “Hmm,” and put the orange shoes in the cart. We bought them. He wore them three times before settling on a pair of black sneakers he’d been eyeing online. But I think something shifted in that conversation, not because I said the perfect thing, but because I didn’t jump to conclusions.
A week later, I was talking with his teacher, a woman who has been at the middle school for twenty years. She mentioned that in her advisory class, a boy asked another boy, “Is this shirt too gay for the dance?” She told them, “We don’t use gay as an insult,” and that ended the conversation. The boy just looked down and said, “Sorry.” She knew it hadn’t helped.
“What did he mean?” she asked me. “I didn’t want to interrogate him. But I feel like I missed something.”
I told her what I’d learned from Sam: that the word “gay” is doing a lot of work for kids these days. It isn’t just about who someone loves. It stands in for “weird,” “outside the group,” “not like us.” By shutting it down as an insult, adults can accidentally push the real question underground. The boy with the shirt wasn’t being homophobic. He was trying to figure out what the dance’s social price tag would be.
I suggested she try something different the next time. Instead of focusing on the word, ask about the meaning: “What makes a shirt ‘gay’? Where did you learn that? What would happen if you wore it anyway?” Those questions sound simple, but they do two things. They take the charge out of the word. And they treat the kid’s observation as a genuine piece of curiosity, not a crime.
Now, that approach isn’t comfortable for every adult. I understand. When you hear “gay” thrown around in a classroom, your gut says protect the kids who might be gay. You worry that silence means agreement. But there’s a difference between allowing homophobia and allowing children to talk through their confusion. The confusion is where the learning happens.
I’ve also started noticing how often adults read “gay” as only about sexuality when, in the tween world, it’s often about conformity. Sam once asked me if his backpack made him look “poor” after a classmate said it was his “dad’s old one.” That was the same kind of question, wearing different clothes.
So I’ve stopped treating these moments as crises. That’s not because I think they’re no big deal—they are a big deal to the kids living them. But if I panic or moralize, I lose the chance to understand what they’re actually scared of.
What seems to work, so far, is staying calm and getting specific. I ask questions with genuine curiosity. I don’t correct the word immediately because that tends to make a kid’s eyes glaze over. Instead, I name the real issue: “You’re worried people will treat you differently based on what you wear. That’s a fair thing to wonder. What do you think you’d wear if no one was watching?”
That last question is my secret weapon. When I asked it, Sam said, “The orange shoes.” When his teacher asked it, the boy said, “Probably the red pin-striped one, but it’s kind of much.”
“So wear it,” she said. “If it’s too much later, that’s okay too.”
He didn’t wear the pin-striped shirt. He went with a white button-down and a black jacket. But he did walk up to her the next Monday and say, “I still like the shirt. Maybe for summer vacation.”
I think that’s the heart of it. Kids are not asking “Does this make me look gay?” because they are deeply confused about sexuality. They’re asking, “How will this change the way people see me?” And they need us to help them sort through the difference between style, identity, and reputation—without turning every conversation into a lesson.
We got home with the orange sneakers. Sam wore them in the kitchen, did a test spin in front of the mirror, and said, “I don’t know if they’re gay, but they’re definitely loud.”
“Loud is a choice,” I said. “Gay isn’t a style. It’s just a part of who someone is.”
He frowned. “Then why do people use it like that?”
“Because people are lazy with words sometimes. And they say things without thinking about what they mean.”
“Huh,” he said. And then he went back to his phone.
The conversation didn’t end with a big hug or a shared realization. It just drifted into the afternoon like so many middle school moments do. He hasn’t asked me that particular question again. I don’t know if he will. I don’t know if he’s thought twice about the orange shoes, or if he’s still sorting out the difference between what he likes and what other kids will say about it.
But I’ve learned to be okay with not knowing. The next time the question comes up—and it will, in some form—I’ll be a little less rattled and a little more ready to ask a question of my own.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Say When Your Middle Schooler Asks, “Do These Make Me Look Gay