What To Do When You’re At a Loss With Your Kid’s Behavior: Real, Low-Effort Tips That Worked For Me
Tuesday night, spaghetti sauce bubbling on the stove, I wiped my hands on my jeans and walked down the hall to check on my 8-year-old Leo’s homework. The door was cracked, I peeked in, and there he was, blue ballpoint pen in hand, drawing mustaches and googly eyes on every single cartoon dog on his multiplication worksheet. His math fact box at the top was completely blank. I stepped in, and he immediately slammed his arm over the page, jaw set. “I’m not doing it. It’s stupid.”
I’d been here a hundred times before that night. I’d tried the gentle reminders, the 10-minute countdowns, the sparkly sticker chart I’d made that’s now half-peeled off the fridge, the promise of 30 extra minutes of weekend screen time for a full week of done homework, the taking away of screen time when it wasn’t done, sitting with him the whole time, letting him do it after dinner, letting him do it first thing after school. Nothing worked. Every single night turned into a 45-minute standoff: I raised my voice, he cried, I felt awful, and half the time the homework still didn’t get done. That night, after I sent him to bed early and ate cold spaghetti off a paper plate because I’d forgotten to drain it mid-yell, I texted my sister, a 3rd grade teacher at Leo’s elementary school: I’m at a loss. What am I doing wrong here?
She came over the next Saturday, brought iced coffee, and sat on the back porch while Leo rode his bike up and down the driveway. I walked her through every fight from the past month, every trick I’d tried, and she nodded slowly, then asked a question I’d never considered: “When was the last time you asked him if it’s actually too hard, instead of just asking why he won’t do it?”
I blinked. I’d just assumed he was being stubborn, that he’d rather build Legos, that he was lazy like I’d been at that age. She told me 9 out of 10 times a kid digs in their heels this hard, it’s not defiance. It’s avoidance. They don’t want to say they don’t get it, because that feels embarrassing, especially if they’ve gotten it wrong a few times already. Instead of acting like they’re confused, they act out to get you to go away, so no one finds out they’re struggling.
She didn’t give me a 10-step plan or a new routine to build from scratch. She just gave me three small, low-effort changes to try: First, the next time he says no, say exactly this: “Is this too hard, or do you just not want to do it right now?” No extra stuff, just that question. Second, instead of making him do the whole worksheet all at once, start with one problem. One. You do it with him, work through it together, then leave him alone. If he stops after that, that’s okay. Third, before you even mention homework, let him spend 5 minutes doing something he’s good at, something he feels proud of. That’s it. No new charts, no big rewards.
I tried it on Monday. After school, Leo ate his goldfish snack, then I let him spend 5 minutes working on the Lego dragon he’s been building, the one he shows every person who walks through the door. I walked in and said, “Wanna do one math problem with me before you go back to building?” He sighed, but put his brick down and came to the table. I let him pick which problem he wanted to do, he pointed to the easiest one, and I told him it was okay if he didn’t know it right away, we could count it out together. He got it right. I said, “Great job. Wanna do another one, or go back to your dragon?” He thought for a second, and did another. Then he went back to his dragon. That was it. No fight.
A few nights later, he crossed his arms and flat-out said he wouldn’t do any math. I took a breath and said the line: “Is this too hard, or do you just not want to do it right now?” He stared at his feet for a second, then mumbled, “It’s too hard. The 7s don’t make sense. I always mix them up.” I’d been fighting with him for a month over homework, and I’d never asked that question. I just assumed he was being difficult. I sat down next to him and we practiced three 7s facts together, that was all he could handle that night, and that was okay.
I spent so much time before that reading all kinds of tips about how to fix bad behavior, how to get your kid to do homework without fighting, and most of them told me I needed to be more consistent, more firm, more positive. I was so focused on checking all those boxes that I missed the obvious: his behavior was a signal, not a personal attack on me as a parent.
It’s not perfect. We still have bad nights. Last week, we had a 20-minute standoff on Thursday, he ended up not doing any homework, I emailed his teacher, and she wrote back saying it was fine, they could do it at recess. No one got in trouble, the world didn’t end. I still raise my voice sometimes. I still forget to let him do his 5 minutes of fun before homework and end up with a half-fight anyway. Leo still mixes up his 7s more often than he gets them right.
But I don’t end the night sitting on the kitchen floor wondering what I’m doing wrong anymore. If you’re at a loss right now, it’s not that you’re missing some big secret trick that all the other parents know. Most of the time, the answer is just slowing down enough to ask what’s actually going on, instead of just fighting the behavior in front of you. We’re still figuring it out, day by day, and that’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When You’re At a Loss With Your Kid’s Behavior: Real, Low-Effort Tips That Worked For Me