What To Do When Your Son Wants Boots People Call ‘Girly’: A Parent’s Real Experience
It was 7 p.m. on the last Saturday of August, and my 10-year-old son Jax had already convinced me to stop for lemonade three times during our back-to-school shoe run. We’d crossed off the required sturdy hiking boots for his outdoor ed class, and I was herding him toward the exit when he dug his heels in by the seasonal display near the door. He pointed, his eyes wide: “Mom. Those. I want those.” They were 12-inch cowboy boots, hot pink, coated in fine silver glitter that shed a little even through the box plastic.
My first thought was to scan the store for other people, which is stupid, I know. A group of middle school girls by the jewelry counter glanced over, and I felt that hot little flash of awkwardness. “Jax, those aren’t practical for school,” I started, the automatic parent line falling out before I thought about it. He shook his head, already stepping toward the display to yank the box off the shelf. “I know. The hiking boots are for camp. These are for recess, and the fall dance. Listen—” He tapped the toe of my sneaker with the box, and I heard the solid clink of leather inside. “They’ll make the best sound on the gym floor. Mia from art class had a pair last year and everyone stopped to look when she walked.”
I thought back to second grade, when he scraped his knee at the park and picked a Rapunzel band-aid out of my purse. The cashier at the snack stand laughed and said, “Isn’t that one for your little sister?” Jax had peeled it off in the car and stuffed it in the trash, wouldn’t let me put another one on. I’d left that parking lot feeling sick, like I’d let someone shrink him just to make a dumb joke. I’d promised myself I wouldn’t do that again, would let him pick the small stuff that matters to him.
I checked the price tag: it was $45, less than the hiking boots we’d just bought. They had his size. I said, “Okay. Let’s try them on.”
First day of school, he pulled them on with his faded dinosaur hoodie and jeans, laced them up himself, and insisted on walking in instead of me dropping him at the curb. I sat in the parking lot for 10 minutes after he left, scrolling through parent forums on my phone like an idiot, half expecting to get a call from the nurse saying someone hurt his feelings.
It didn’t happen that way. When I picked him up that afternoon, he burst through the doors, stomping his feet on the concrete just to hear the clop. “Three people asked where I got them,” he said, climbing into the car. “Jake said my boots are way cooler than his new Nikes. One kid called me a name, but I told him his boots are boring and he left me alone.”
I’ve talked to a lot of other parents who say they’d say no to boots like these, and I get it. I’ve had the same thoughts: what if he gets bullied? What if he grows out of them in two months? What will other people think of me, letting him do that? What I didn’t expect is how much of that worry is about me, not about him. I’m the one who grew up hearing that boys can’t like pink, that glitter is for girls. Jax doesn’t carry that baggage. He just likes the way the boots sound, and the way the glitter catches the sun on the playground.
The first thing I do now when one of my kids asks for something that makes me hesitate is I ask them to tell me why they want it, before I say yes or no. I don’t lead with “that’s for girls” or “that’s not practical” — I just listen. Nine times out of 10, it’s a really simple reason, not some big complicated thing that I need to overanalyze. The second thing is, if it’s not dangerous, and it fits in the budget, I let them have it. Small low-stakes choices like this are how kids learn to trust their own judgment. If I say no just because other people might stare, I’m not protecting him. I’m teaching him that other people’s opinions matter more than what he wants.
Another small trick I picked up from Jax’s school counselor: when someone says something rude, don’t jump in automatically to fix it. Last month we were at the grocery store, and an older woman stopped us by the produce section and said, “Aren’t those boots a little girly for your boy?” I didn’t argue with her. I just looked at Jax, and let him answer. He said, “They’re my boots. I like them.” Then I just nodded and said, “He has great taste,” and we kept going. It taught him that he can stand up for himself, and it saved me from wasting 20 minutes in the lettuce aisle arguing with someone who didn’t really care anyway.
It’s been almost four months now. The glitter’s scuffed a little on the toes, and he wears them once or twice a week, usually when he knows he’ll get to stomp around the gym at recess. He asked for a sparkly pink backpack last week, and I added it to the cart without hesitating. I still have those moments, sometimes, when I feel that old awkward creep in when someone stares. Last week a dad at the soccer game snickered when Jax walked past in his boots, and I felt my jaw tighten before I reminded myself that Jax didn’t notice. He was too busy talking about his next goal to care what some random dad thinks.
I don’t have a neat little moral here, and I don’t think every parent has to buy their kid every silly thing they ask for. If the boots were $200 and we couldn’t afford them, I would have said no, plain and simple. But when we can say yes, when it’s just a pair of boots that doesn’t hurt anyone, I think we should. The question isn’t whether they’re the right boots for a boy. It’s whether they’re the right boots for your son. And that’s a question only he can answer.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Your Son Wants Boots People Call ‘Girly’: A Parent’s Real Experience