What to Do When Your Kid Writes a Letter to the Tooth Fairy: Parenting Tips for Small Rituals
It was 8:47 pm, Lila’s unicorn pajamas were dotted with toothpaste foam, and she was scribbling furiously on the back of a drawing she’d brought home from first grade that day. I was leaning against the kitchen counter loading the dishwasher, already half counting the minutes until I could sit down with my cold tea. “What are you working on?” I asked, wiping a splash of water off my sleeve.
“Duh,” she said, not looking up. “A letter to the Tooth Fairy. My tooth fell out at snack time today, remember?”
I did remember. I’d put the tiny, chipped baby tooth in a baggie in my purse that afternoon, and forgot to take it out until we were brushing teeth. I’d already stashed a one-dollar bill in my nightstand to swap for it in an hour, the same thing I’d done for her first two lost teeth. I’d never thought about a letter.
She pushed the finished paper across the table toward me, crumbs from her after-dinner cookie stuck to the bottom edge. The first request was straightforward: she’d lost her favorite sparkly eraser at recess three days before, and could the Tooth Fairy please bring a new one instead of extra dollars? The second line made my chest feel tight: Do you miss your old baby teeth too? I liked mine even when it was wiggly.
I shut the dishwasher and tried to think. The nearest drugstore was 10 minutes away, it was almost bedtime, and I had a 7 am meeting I still needed to prep slides for. I dug through my junk drawer and found a sparkly blue eraser I’d gotten for free at a teacher conference back in September, still in its wrapper. I grabbed a sticky note from my grocery list pad and scribbled a quick reply: Of course you can have an eraser. Every one of your teeth is special, and I save all the memories of them, just like you do. I stuck it next to the dollar and the eraser, and after Lila fell asleep, swapped it for the tooth under her pillow like normal.
I didn’t expect her to call me out before I even finished pouring coffee the next morning. She came barrelling into the kitchen holding both letters, her hair sticking up on one side. “Mom,” she said, stopping right in front of my chair. “This handwriting looks just like yours.”
I froze. All the things I’d read online about keeping the magic of childhood alive flashed through my head: Never break the spell, it builds their imagination, don’t ruin it for them too soon. I opened my mouth to say it was a coincidence, that the Tooth Fairy just writes like me, but then Lila added, “Ms. Henderson says we always tell the truth even when it’s a game. So is it you?”
I set down my coffee mug and nodded. “Yeah, bug. It’s me. I’ve been the Tooth Fairy this whole time.”
I braced for tears, or disappointment, or that confused look kids get when they find out one of their favorite stories isn’t “real.” Instead she tilted her head and thought for a second. “So do I still get the eraser?” I laughed and said of course she did. Then she said, “Can we still do letters? I like writing them. It’s more fun than just leaving a tooth. Will you still write me back even if I know it’s you?”
That was three months ago, and it’s changed how I think about all these little childhood rituals we stress so much about. I used to think the point of the Tooth Fairy was to keep a myth alive, that if my kid figured it out too early I’d failed at giving her a magical childhood. What I’ve learned is that the point of the letter isn’t the magic of a mystery visitor—it’s the space it creates for a kid to say the small things they don’t say over dinner. When we’re asking “how was school?” we get “fine” as an answer, but when she’s writing to the Tooth Fairy, she’ll bring up the eraser she lost, the recess game she wants to win, the spelling test she’s nervous about. It’s low-stakes, it’s fun, and it meets her exactly where she is developmentally as she starts testing out what it means to share small wants and worries.
If you’re a parent staring at a letter your kid just wrote to the Tooth Fairy tonight, panicking a little like I did, here’s what I’ve found that works, no fancy prep required. First, keep a small bin of cheap, kid-favorite small items in a closet shelf: sparkly erasers, mini stickers, fruit snacks, colorful hair ties. That way you don’t have to run to the store at 9 pm when they ask for something random instead of cash. Second, if your kid calls out the ruse, don’t double down or shut the whole thing down. You can just say, “I’ve loved being your Tooth Fairy, because I get to make this little special thing just for you. Do you want to keep doing letters anyway?” That’s the exact line I used, and it worked way better than lying would have. Third, don’t stress about the reply being perfect. Lila doesn’t care if it’s on fancy stationery or a grocery list sticky note—she just cares that I answer whatever she asks.
Last month she lost her fourth tooth, and her letter asked the Tooth Fairy (me) for three tips to beat her best friend at four square at recess. I wrote back: Hit low so she can’t reach it, keep your eye on the ball, and don’t pout if you lose first round, you get another turn. She taped that note to the side of her bathroom mirror, and it’s still there.
I still get the side-eye from other parents sometimes when I say I came clean about the Tooth Fairy when Lila asked. They say I should have waited another year, that I ruined the magic. I don’t think I did. We still do the ritual, it just grew up with her. It’s not the neat, storybook magic I expected when I first became a parent, but it works for us. Last week she lost another tooth, and her letter just said “Can we have extra popcorn for movie night after school tomorrow?” I left the popcorn on the counter that morning with a little note that said “Yes. Extra butter. Love, the Tooth Fairy.” It’s not perfect, but it’s ours, and that’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When Your Kid Writes a Letter to the Tooth Fairy: Parenting Tips for Small Rituals