What To Do When You Think Someone Posted About Your Kid On Facebook: Parenting Tips For Middle School Social Drama
I was folding laundry last Tuesday night, waiting for my 13-year-old daughter Lila to get out of the shower, scrolling through our local middle school parent Facebook group when a new post popped up. It was from a blurred profile, a name I didn’t recognize, and she was fuming about an unnamed girl who’d bullied her daughter at the recent fall dance. She said the girl tripped her kid in front of the whole gym, called her shoes ugly, and needed to be held accountable.
Then she described her: red hair, freckles, wears the faded vintage Star Wars hoodie every single day.
That’s Lila. The hoodie has a coffee stain on the cuff from when I spilled iced coffee on it back in August, and she refuses to throw it out or even wash it more than once a week. My hands went sweaty, and I locked my phone immediately before Lila could wander in and see it. When she did come in to grab her pajamas a minute later, she asked why I looked so tense. I lied and said I’d just seen a terrible chocolate chip cookie recipe that someone was recommending. She rolled her eyes and left, and I sat on the couch for 20 minutes debating what to do next.
My first impulses were all bad: comment right there on the post that that was my kid, you got the story wrong, what’s your side. Message the group admin to demand they take it down immediately. Hunt through the poster’s profile to find out who she was and call her out. I’d even typed out a draft comment before I stopped and remembered what happened when Lila was in third grade. A kid pushed her off the playground slide, and I marched over to the kid’s mom right after school before even asking Lila what had happened. Turned out Lila had pushed the kid first, and I was the one who looked like the crazy parent. Lila was embarrassed for months that I’d fought her battle for her.
So I did nothing that night, other than make a note to talk to Lila first thing the next morning. I got up 20 minutes early and made her favorite buttermilk pancakes, even though it was a school day, and brought them to the table when she sat down. I didn’t lead with “someone posted about you on Facebook” – I knew that would send her into a panic before I even finished the sentence. I said, “I saw something in the parent group that mentioned a girl with your description who had a conflict at the dance. I wanted to check in with you before I did anything, because it didn’t sound like anything you’ve told me about.”
She went red immediately and pushed her half-eaten pancake away. It wasn’t completely wrong, she said. The other girl, Mia, had been leaving mean notes about Lila’s best friend in her locker for two weeks. Lila confronted her by the snack bar after the dance. When Mia tried to walk away, Lila stepped in front of her to make her stop, and Mia tripped over Lila’s foot by accident. Lila did say Mia’s platform sneakers were ugly. She said she was mad, and it was a mean thing to say, but she never meant for her to fall.
“Is everyone talking about me?” she asked, and her voice cracked. “Do all the parents think I’m a bully now?”
I sat with her while she cried a little, and I didn’t jump in to fix it right away. I just said, “That sucks that you’re in this spot. What do you want to do about it?” That’s the thing I’ve learned the hard way: middle schoolers don’t want you to take over, they just want to be asked what they think. She said she didn’t want me fighting her battles online, but she didn’t want the post up there for everyone to see either. She wanted Mia’s mom to know the whole story, not just the part Mia told her when she got home crying.
We wrote the message to Mia’s mom together. Lila wrote the first line herself: “I think the girl you talked about in your post is me. It didn’t happen exactly the way your daughter said, and I wanted to tell you my side if you’re open to that.” I added my contact info, and said we were happy to meet for coffee, or have the school counselor mediate the conversation, whatever they were comfortable with. I then messaged the group admin separately, explained the situation, and asked them to take the post down since it identified a minor indirectly and was an ongoing conflict. They took it down within an hour.
A lot of people will tell you to just ignore it, or to blow up and defend your kid immediately, but neither of those work. The first concrete thing I can tell other parents from this experience is: don’t engage publicly first. Any comment you leave on a public post, even a defensive one, just turns a small conflict between two kids into a public drama where everyone picks sides. The post will be gone eventually, but everyone will remember the fight. Second, don’t keep it from your kid. I almost just got it taken down and said nothing, but if another kid at school had seen it and mentioned it to Lila, that would have been way worse than her hearing it from me first. Third, always talk to your kid before you talk to anyone else. You don’t know what actually happened until you ask them, and even if they messed up, they deserve to be part of fixing it.
Mia’s mom wrote back two days later. She said she was upset when Mia came home crying, and she posted it without stopping to think that the other kid had a side too. She agreed to meet with us and the school counselor next week. The post is gone, but some people definitely saw it before it came down. Some days Lila says no one’s said anything, and she’s fine. Other days she says she’s scared to walk into the cafeteria because she thinks people are whispering about her. We check in every Sunday morning over pancakes now, just a quick question: anything weird happen this week I should know about?
It’s not fixed. I don’t know how the meeting next week will go. Maybe they’ll work it out, maybe they’ll just agree to avoid each other for the rest of the year. Either way, right now the thing that’s working is we have a new rule: if either of us sees something online about someone we know, we talk about it offline first, before we comment or react. Lila still wears her stained Star Wars hoodie every day. It’s messy, it’s uncomfortable, and it’s far from over, but it’s ours to work through together, one pancake at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When You Think Someone Posted About Your Kid On Facebook: Parenting Tips For Middle School Social Drama