What To Do When A Quiet Kid Acts Out: Lessons From Teaching Elementary School In Rural China
The chalk dust was still floating in the afternoon sunlight when Xiao Ming slammed his pencil down so hard the eraser bounced off his desk. It was mid-September, my 4th grade math class at a small rural public school in Sichuan, and we were copying 10 word problems off the blackboard for homework. The room still smelled like the steamed stuffed buns the kids ate for morning break, and most heads were bent over their worksheets. Then Xiao Ming crumpled his up, tore it in half, and threw it at the back of the girl sitting in front of him. The whole class went dead silent.
I’d been teaching Xiao Ming for a month by that point, and I’d written him off as just another quiet, unmotivated kid. He never turned in homework, never raised his hand, and spent most of class staring out the window at the rice paddies down the hill. The other teachers all told me he was a lost cause—parents working in a factory in Guangzhou, lives with his grandma who can’t read a single character, doesn’t care about school. I’d yelled at him once the week before for not turning in homework, and he just stared at his shoes the whole time. That day, after he threw the paper, I sent the class out for 10 minutes of extra break, and pulled a chair next to his desk. I didn’t say anything at first. I just picked up the torn paper, threw it away, got him a new worksheet, then went back to grading the other kids’ spelling tests. After about eight minutes, he mumbled something so quiet I could barely hear it. “My hand hurts.”
He held out his right hand, and his knuckles were white, his whole hand clenched tight. He said when he writes more than three lines, it starts to tingle, and the characters blur together, and he can’t get the strokes right no matter how hard he tries. I pulled out his old notebooks from the file cabinet, and that’s when I saw it. All the characters were slanted sideways, half the strokes were missing, and he mixed up “rice” and “fire” over and over again—two characters that look almost the same to an untrained eye. I’d seen this before in my teacher training, undiagnosed dysgraphia, a learning difference that makes writing physically painful and messy. But we don’t have any special ed screeners at our school, no one who can test him for it, and the nearest pediatric neurologist is two and a half hours away in Chengdu. His grandma can’t afford to take time off work to go, and his parents can’t get leave from the factory. So no one ever asked why he wouldn’t write. They just called him lazy.
I didn’t wait for a formal diagnosis to make small changes. The first thing I did was swap his regular pencil for one with a thick rubber grip I bought for 2 yuan apiece at the stationery shop in town. Thicker grips are easier for kids with weak hand muscles to hold, which cuts down on cramping. Then, I adjusted his homework: instead of copying all 10 word problems like the other kids, he only has to write down the answers. If his hand hurts too much even for that, he can come tell me the answers out loud after class, and I mark it complete. I also made a silent signal with him: if he feels frustrated or his hand starts hurting mid-class, he just puts his eraser on top of his desk, and he can go get a drink of water or stand in the back of the room for two minutes to stretch, no questions asked, no need to raise his hand and explain himself in front of everyone.
That’s the thing I wish more parents and teachers understood. You don’t need a fancy diagnosis or a ton of money to help a kid who’s struggling. The biggest mistake we make is assuming that bad behavior is a choice. Xiao Ming didn’t act out because he wanted to ruin class. He acted out because he was in pain, he was embarrassed that everyone could see his messy writing, and he had no other way to ask for help. Quiet kids especially get overlooked, because they don’t bug you every day, so you just assume they’re fine or they don’t care. I’ve started doing this with all my quiet kids now: if they haven’t turned in homework for a week, I pull them aside, give them a mint from my desk jar, sit with them, and don’t talk until they’re ready. Nine times out of ten, there’s something going on that no one bothered to ask about. Sometimes it’s that they can’t see the blackboard and can’t afford glasses. Sometimes it’s that their grandparents are sick and they have to cook dinner every night and don’t have time to do homework. It’s never just that they’re lazy.
It’s been three months since that day in September. Xiao Ming still doesn’t write as neatly as the other kids, and he still doesn’t turn in every assignment. But he hasn’t thrown anything or disrupted class since that first day. Last week, he raised his hand to answer a three-step multiplication problem, and he got it right in his head faster than any other kid in the class. He’s good at math, really good, he just never got a chance to show it because everyone was too focused on punishing him for bad writing. Last week I found a folded up sheet of paper in his desk after class, with a whole page of dinosaurs drawn on it, really detailed, with scales and claws and everything. He must have drawn it when he was done with his oral work. I put it back, didn’t say anything, but I saw him looking for it the next day, and when he found it, he smiled a little.
We still don’t have a formal diagnosis. His parents still text me once a month telling me to make him study harder, that they don’t want him to end up like them working in a factory. I explain the changes I’ve made, and they don’t really get it, but they don’t argue. It’s not a perfect solution. There’s only so much I can do as one teacher with 45 kids in my class. But it’s working, for now. Xiao Ming comes to school every day now, he doesn’t huddle in the back anymore. That’s more than he had before. Some days that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When A Quiet Kid Acts Out: Lessons From Teaching Elementary School In Rural China