What to Do If Your Teen Says They’re Not Smart Enough to Finish High School: Practical Tips from a Parent
Last Tuesday, I was folding clean socks at the kitchen table while my 16-year-old Jax worked through his homework, half a peanut butter sandwich gone stale beside his workbook. The dishwasher hummed in the background, and I barely looked up when he pushed the crumpled math sheet across the table toward me. The eraser end of his pencil was chewed down to the wood, and he said, plain as anything, “I’m not smart enough to do this. I’m never gonna graduate.”
I’d heard this before, but it still stung. Back in middle school, Jax got diagnosed with dyslexia, and even with extra time on tests, reading anything longer than a text message takes him twice as long as it does his friends. I spent all of 10th grade nagging him to stay up after dinner to study, taking away his toolbox when he skipped study hall to work on old dirt bikes in the garage. By the end of that year, he’d failed Algebra 1 twice, and his guidance counselor called me in for a meeting that changed how I thought about all this.
Ms. Lopez, the counselor, didn’t sit there and tell me Jax needed to try harder or that I needed to hire a fancy tutor. She leaned back in her chair and said most schools are built for one type of kid— the kid that can memorize dates, write 5-page essays, and pass standardized tests. If your brain works better with your hands, or you process information slower than average, you get labeled “not smart” even if you can do things most of those academic kids can’t. That was a lightbulb for me. I’d been buying into the same label Jax had given himself.
The first thing I learned, that most parents don’t know, is that there are concrete adjustments you can make if your kid wants to stay in school and graduate. The first step is to call your guidance counselor and ask about a modified course plan. Most states let kids swap out the advanced math and science requirements that are meant for kids going to four-year college for career-focused classes that count toward graduation. Jax gets to take automotive tech at the county technical center every afternoon, and that counts for his science and elective credits. We worked out a 5-year graduation plan instead of 4, so he only takes two core academic classes a semester instead of four. That cut his stress in half immediately.
Another small shift that made a big difference: we ask every teacher if Jax can do assignments that tie to his interest, instead of generic work. His English teacher let him write his research paper on how four-stroke engine technology has changed over the last 50 years, instead of writing about a novel he couldn’t get through. He still had to cite sources, write an introduction and conclusion, and hit all the grading requirements— he just got to write about something he cared about. His grade was a B, and he didn’t even complain about doing it. We also cut out anything that wasn’t helping. Jax was required to do two hours of after-school tutoring a week that he hated; he’d just sit there and scroll on his phone the whole time because he was too embarrassed to ask for help in a room full of kids. We got the school to let him do 20 minutes of one-on-one help during his lunch period instead, and now he actually gets the support he needs, and still has afternoons free for work and the shop.
If your kid is already too far behind, or hates school so much it’s dragging down their whole mood, there are good options outside of traditional high school too. I used to think a GED was a bad mark on your record, but that’s just outdated stigma. Most trade programs, community colleges, even entry-level skilled jobs accept a GED these days. If your kid struggles with long, multi-hour standardized tests, look into the HiSET instead— it’s broken into smaller sections, and most states offer it for free through local adult education programs. A lot of technical programs even let you work on your GED and get your trade certification at the same time, so you’re not wasting a year just on core classes. I have a cousin who dropped out of high school when he was 17, got his GED, did a two-year electrician program, and now he owns his own contracting company. He makes more a year than I do with my four-year college degree, and no one asks him about his high school diploma anymore.
Jax still has bad days. Last month he missed three days of school with the flu, and he had to make up a bunch of work, and he said he wanted to quit again. We sat on the porch with iced tea, and I didn’t tell him to suck it up or that he could be anything he wanted if he just tried. I just reminded him he doesn’t have to graduate at 18, he doesn’t have to go to college, he just has to do what works for him. He ended up going back, and turned all the work in a week late.
Last weekend he changed the oil in my minivan, tightened a loose belt, and charged me 10 bucks, which I paid even though I know he got the oil for free from the shop he works at. He’s already got a list of small engines he’s rebuilding to sell next summer. We don’t know if he’ll actually open his own shop one day, or if he’ll even stick to the five-year graduation plan we worked out. Some days his grades are still barely passing, and I still catch myself worrying what other parents will think when we talk about school at backyard barbecues. But I don’t push him to cram for tests he’ll never use, or force him to chase a version of success that was never going to fit him.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do If Your Teen Says They’re Not Smart Enough to Finish High School: Practical Tips from a Parent