What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: Advice for Parents and Teachers
Last Wednesday, I was leaning over Lila’s desk helping her correct her fraction exit ticket when I glanced up at the rest of my 4th grade classroom. Most kids had their headphones on, tapping away at adaptive math modules on their school tablets. Javi, who’s two grade levels ahead in math, was working through a unit on volume that the rest of us won’t touch for another month. Mia, who’s still building her foundational number sense, was working through a review set matched to her current pace. This is exactly what the personalized learning training told us to do: meet every kid where they are.
What caught my eye was Javi. He frowned at his screen, tapped away the automated hint, and slumped back in his chair. Three years ago, before we shifted to this model, he would’ve nudged his deskmate Theo immediately, whispered that he was stuck, and asked for a hand. That day, he just stared at the screen until the bell rang. After class, I pulled him aside to ask what was going on. He shrugged and kicked a crumpled paper across the floor: “Everyone’s working on different stuff. No one else is doing my problem. Why bother asking?”
That hit me. I’ve been a teacher for 12 years, and I’m a fan of personalized learning where it works. I’ve seen Lila go from acting out every math block because she was bored to finishing her work early and asking for extra problems. I saw a kid who refused to read in 3rd grade because all our whole-class novels were too hard start reading 100 pages a week of graphic novels matched to his level. Personalized learning fixes a lot of problems with the old one-size-fits-all model. But over the last two years, I’ve watched us slowly get rid of almost all shared learning activities, and I’ve started to see what we lose in the process.
I started testing small, low-effort changes to bring shared learning back, without giving up the benefits of personalized work. The first thing I added was 10 minutes of shared problem solving every day, right after 30 minutes of self-paced work. We all put the tablets and headphones away, and I write one open-ended question on the board that any kid can work on, no matter their level. Last week, it was: “If you could only bring 5 items that add up to less than 1 pound total on a day hike, what would you bring, and how do you know your total is under the limit?” A kid working on counting can add whole numbers, a kid working on fractions can convert ounces to pounds, everyone has a shot. We pair up and talk through our answers, then call on two or three pairs to share with the whole group. For parents who do personalized homeschooling or let their kid use adaptive learning apps for after-school practice, this is easy to copy: just add 10 minutes to your dinner routine once a day, ask a question tied to what they’re learning that everyone at the table can answer. If they’re learning about plants, ask “What’s one plant you think would grow well in our kitchen, and why?” It doesn’t take extra planning, just a little intentionality.
The second thing I added was a 15-minute weekly stuck share. Every Friday, after we clean out our desks, everyone writes one thing they got stuck on that week on a sticky note, and we put them all in a jar. I pull out three or four, and we talk through them. It doesn’t matter if it’s a math problem, a tricky part of a personal project, or a hard paragraph in a book. Last month, Javi put his volume problem in the jar, and Mia, who’s working on addition, raised her hand and said “I get stuck when I feel stupid for not getting it right away, too. I just start over and count slower.” Javi nodded and said that’s what he ended up doing. This works for families too: add it to your Sunday night dinner, and everyone shares one thing they got stuck on that week, even you. I do this at home with my own two kids, and I’ve shared that I messed up a work presentation or burned the weeknight pasta, which makes them feel way more comfortable sharing their own struggles.
I also still keep a 15-minute whole-class read aloud every day, even though all kids do their independent reading at their own level on their own books. It doesn’t matter that half the kids can read the book faster on their own, or that some need the pictures to follow along. We all have a common story to talk about for five minutes after, and that common ground is something no personalized reading list can give you. At home, my 11-year-old reads adventure novellas on his own, but we still read a chapter of a silly pirate book together every night, just because it’s our thing.
A few weeks ago, I watched Javi nudge Theo during our daily shared problem time and point to his paper: “Wait, you got 12 ounces total? I got 8. How’d you fit that extra water bottle?” They talked it through for five minutes, no prompting from me. It’s still not perfect. Some weeks we skip the shared problem because we have a field trip or state testing, and some kids still don’t want to talk about their struggles in the stuck share. But the kids don’t see learning as just their own private little task on a screen anymore. They remember that it’s something we do together. Javi still works at his own pace, gets the challenge he needs, and that’s still working for him. Now he just doesn’t have to do it alone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: Advice for Parents and Teachers