What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: A Fourth Grade Teacher’s Perspective
Last Tuesday, halfway through math block, I looked up from grading reading responses and noticed Mia hadn’t moved from her seat in 22 minutes. Her personalized learning path glowed on her tablet, her pencil hovered over her worksheet, and she wasn’t talking to anyone. I walked over, knelt down, and asked if she was stuck. She shrugged and said, “Everyone else is working on multiplication. I’m still on fractions. I didn’t want to bug anyone with my stuff.”
Our school rolled out full personalized learning this school year. The idea makes sense on paper: every kid gets a learning path tailored to their skill level, so no one is bored waiting for the class to catch up, and no one is left behind feeling rushed. Parents email me all the time saying how much they love it—their advanced kid finally has work that challenges them, their kid who needs extra time doesn’t come home crying every night anymore. I like a lot of it too. But what no one talked about during all the training was what we lose when every kid’s work is their own separate thing.
After Mia said that, I paused. I realized this wasn’t the first time I’d seen this lately. Two weeks earlier, Javi had finished his independent reading unit and told me he had no one to talk to about his book, because everyone else was on a different book for their path. A week after that, Lila told me she didn’t need to ask for help because “everyone’s work is different, no one knows what I’m doing.” We’d traded whole-class instruction for individual paths, and we’d accidentally traded connection for pace.
I started making small changes, nothing big, just tweaking our daily routine to keep the shared stuff in, even when the work itself is personalized. First, I added a 5-minute “struggle share” at the start of every work block. It’s simple: everyone turns to the person at their table, no matter what they’re working on that day, and says one thing they’re stuck on. Solutions aren’t required. Just sharing. The first day we did it, Mia said she was stuck on equivalent fractions, and Leo—who’s usually the first one done with his math work—said “I was stuck on that last week. I got three wrong in a row before I figured out I had to multiply the top and bottom by the same number.” Mia’s face just relaxed. She had no idea someone else had gone through the same hard part, even if they were at different spots.
I’ve shared this trick with parents who do personalized learning at home, too—whether that’s for kids with learning differences that need a tailored pace, or for homeschool families that follow their kid’s interests. One mom told me her 10-year-old with dyslexia does reading at his own level, while his younger sister does chapter books, and he’d started saying he was the “stupid one” with baby work. I told her to add a struggle and win round to the end of dinner every night, where every person shares one thing they struggled with that day and one small win, no matter what it is. She emailed me back three weeks later saying it worked. Dad shares that he struggled with a work presentation and his win was that he didn’t trip walking off stage. Mom shares that she struggled with baking cookies and her win was that they only burned a little. The kid now shares his reading struggles and his win of finishing a whole book without stopping, and he doesn’t feel like he’s the only one with different work anymore. It’s 10 minutes max, no prep, just conversation.
The second thing I keep shared, no matter how personalized the work gets, is the big idea. This month, our science theme is how living things change their environments. A kid working below grade level reads a 12-page picture book about beavers. A kid working ahead reads a 100-page chapter about invasive species in the Great Lakes. Their assignments are totally different, tailored to their reading level and pace. But every afternoon, we spend 10 minutes all together, and anyone can share one thing they learned that answers our big question. Last week, a kid who’d read the beaver book talked about how beavers build dams that create whole new ponds, and a kid who read the invasive species book talked about how zebra mussels change the whole lake’s food chain. They got to talk to each other about the same big idea, even though their work was totally different. It keeps everyone part of the same community, not just a bunch of individual learners working in the same room.
I also put up a small physical whiteboard by the door called our Win Board, and anyone can write a small win any time, no matter what it’s for. It doesn’t have to be a big test score. It can be “I finally remembered how to divide by two” or “I wrote three whole sentences for my story” or “I didn’t give up when my project broke.” It’s for everyone, any level, and at the end of every week we glance through it together. No fanfare, just a quick round of quiet claps if someone wants it.
We still do personalized learning here. I still see the benefits every day: the kid who used to act out because he was bored is now engaged, the kid who used to hide her wrong answers is now willing to take her time. It’s not perfect, some days the 5 minute share runs over and we get behind on schedule. Some weeks, no one writes anything on the Win Board for three days. But Mia now asks Leo for help when she’s stuck, and she brings her finished projects to show him, too. Last week, she brought a fraction pizza she made for homework, with pepperoni slices representing equivalent fractions, and they both laughed that they’d both put way too many pepperoni on theirs.
It’s still a work in progress. I’m still tweaking, still figuring out how to keep the good parts of personalized learning without losing the shared parts that help kids feel like they’re part of something bigger than their own individual path. So far, these small changes have worked better than any big training I sat through last summer.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: A Fourth Grade Teacher’s Perspective