What My 8th Grader’s Social Studies Teacher Gave Him Changed How I Think About “Disengaged” Kids
The last bell of 8th grade had barely rung, and Javi was already leaning against my car in the school parking lot, blue raspberry slushie dripping down his wrist and onto the white sneakers I’d bought for promotion that morning. He dragged his overstuffed backpack to the trunk, then paused, rummaging around in the crumpled mess of his social studies folder and pulling out a beat-up manila envelope. “Mr. Torres gave this to me,” he said, wiping slushie off his jeans. “Said it’s mine.”
I didn’t think much of it at first. I assumed it was a generic graduation card, or a copy of his final exam, something to toss in the junk drawer once we got home. When we got in the car, I opened it while Javi queued up a playlist, and it wasn’t any of those things. It was a full stack of small papers: every exit ticket Javi had written all semester, a half-drawn sketch of George Washington he’d doodled on the back of a quiz when he finished early, a copy of his research paper on housing segregation with notes scrawled in the margins, even the gum wrapper he’d left tucked in his folder back in September. Taped to the back was a one-page letter, written in Mr. Torres’ messy handwriting.
For context: I’d spent the entire school year stressed out about Javi. Every parent-teacher conference followed the same script: He’s so smart, but he’s disengaged. He doesn’t turn in his homework. He daydreams through class. He’s not going to be ready for the workload of high school. I’d bought him a fancy leather planner, emailed his guidance counselor twice to check in, and started a nightly routine of quizzing him on missing assignments before he could play video games. I was convinced I had a problem kid who was throwing away his potential before he even got to high school.
Mr. Torres’ letter didn’t say any of that. It said: “Javi spends half my class staring out the window. First month of school, I marked him down as bored and unmotivated, same as everyone else does. Then I started reading his exit tickets. When I ask ‘what’s one question you have about today’s lesson,’ most kids write something generic off the textbook. Javi wrote, after we talked about redlining, ‘If my grandma bought her house on the west side in 1978, does that mean she can’t sell it for as much as the houses on the east side now?’ He never turned in the required outline for his research paper, I almost failed him for it, but his final paper was three pages longer than the requirement, all about how the west side of town doesn’t have a full-service grocery store because of those old rules. Javi isn’t disengaged. He just doesn’t care about filling out worksheets or memorizing dates for a test he’ll forget next month. He cares about the stuff that touches his life.”
I sat in the parked car after we got home and flipped through all the exit tickets. He was right. Every single one had a question I’d never heard Javi ask me, because I never asked. I was too busy asking if he’d turned in his vocabulary worksheet.
That was three months ago, and I’ve changed a few small things since then, nothing dramatic. I stopped opening our after-school check-in with “Do you have any homework due tomorrow?” Now I start with “What’s the most interesting question you had in class this week?” It takes 10 seconds, and half the time he shrugs and says “nothing,” but once every couple weeks he’ll launch into a 15-minute rant about how unfair it is that the new high school football field got funded before the old middle school library got new books. I still check the parent portal, because old habits die hard, but now I don’t panic over one or two missing 10-point assignments. If he skipped the vocabulary worksheet but put 10 hours into a project he cares about, I just ask him if he’s okay with the 0 that comes with the missing assignment, instead of nagging him for an hour to get it done. For teachers who have even a little extra bandwidth, it doesn’t take much to notice this stuff: just save one quiet kid’s work a semester, write down what you actually see instead of checking the box that says “disengaged” on the report card. Mr. Torres wasn’t a miracle worker with endless free time; he just noticed something no one else had bothered to, and passed that observation on.
It’s not like this fixed everything. Javi still forgets to turn in assignments. Last week, he reminded me at 8 p.m. that his high school summer assignment was due at midnight, and we had to scramble to finish it. I still catch myself scrolling through the parent portal when I’m bored, feeling that old twist of worry that he’s falling behind. I still slip back into old habits sometimes, badgering him about missing work instead of asking what he’s actually thinking about.
But I have Mr. Torres’ letter taped to the front of my fridge, right next to Javi’s blurry promotion photo. When that worry hits, I read that line again: Javi isn’t disengaged. He’s just waiting for the work to matter to him. We’re starting high school in a month, and I don’t know how it’s going to go. There will be missed deadlines, bad grades, and plenty of days I’ll want to go back to nagging him about every missing worksheet. But I know I’m not looking at my kid the same way I did before that crumpled manila envelope showed up in my car.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What My 8th Grader’s Social Studies Teacher Gave Him Changed How I Think About “Disengaged” Kids