What I’ve Seen As A 4th Grade Teacher: The Biggest Problem In The Current Education System
Last Friday, I was kneeling by the supply bin picking up dried-up glue sticks when I noticed Milo hadn’t moved from his desk in 20 minutes. Our class was building solar ovens for our energy unit, and everyone else was cutting foil and arguing over who got the extra marshmallows for the test melt. Milo just sat staring at his blank cardboard box, pencil tapping the edge. I walked over and asked if he needed help cutting the top flap. He pushed a crumpled, typed step-by-step sheet across the desk toward me and said, “Did I do step one right? I don’t want to mess the whole thing up.”
I flipped the sheet over, a list his mom had printed the night before with checkboxes next to each step. Step 1: Glue black construction paper to inner base. Milo had glued his on, slightly crooked, a half-inch overlap at the edge. I told him it was fine, it would still absorb heat just fine. He shook his head and said, “If it’s wrong, my grade will go down.”
After class, I had a scheduled conference with Milo’s mom. She sighed and said this is how he is with everything now. He won’t try new soccer drills at practice because he doesn’t want to miss the goal in front of the team. He erased his entire book report last month because he misspelled the main character’s name on the first line, and ended up turning it in late. She said, “I don’t know when he got so scared of doing something wrong.”
I’ve been teaching 4th grade for 12 years, and if you ask me what the biggest problem in the current education system is, it’s not underfunded classrooms or outdated textbooks, though those are real issues. It’s that we’ve taught kids that the point of school is to avoid mistakes, not to learn. Every year, I see more kids who’d rather not try something new than try it and get a less-than-perfect grade. Three years ago, I had a group of straight-A girls redo an entire poster project the night before it was due because the sticker letters they used for the title were slightly uneven. They skipped their movie night to reprint and re-stick everything, just so it would look “right.” Last semester, a boy turned in a blank extra credit page because he said he didn’t know how to solve any of the problems, and didn’t want a wrong answer to hurt his overall average. The extra credit was worth 2 points. It wouldn’t have dropped his A to an A- even if he got all of it wrong.
A few years ago, I started changing small things in my room to push back against this. When we go over quizzes, I don’t just put the right answers on the board. I pull up 2 or 3 wrong answers that have good thinking behind them, and we talk about that. Last week, one kid wrote that 1/2 is bigger than 3/4 because 2 is smaller than 4, so half must be bigger. I pointed out that his reasoning made total sense—if you have a bigger bottom number, you’re cutting the whole into more pieces, so that logic works for a lot of fractions. The only mistake he made was forgetting to compare how many pieces you have. We all walked away remembering that rule better than if we’d just marked it wrong and moved on.
When I talk to parents about this trend at conferences, I don’t give vague advice about being more supportive. I give them two small, specific things to try at home. First, when your kid brings home a test or assignment, don’t lead with “why did you get this wrong?” First, ask them to show you one thing they got right that they’re proud of, or one thing they learned from the mistake they did make. That shifts the conversation from fixing errors to learning from them. Second, stop correcting every tiny mistake before they turn an assignment in. If your kid misspells three words on their history poster, or draws the water cycle with the arrow pointing the wrong way, let them turn it in that way. The teacher will mark it, they’ll fix it for next time, and they’ll remember it way better than if you’d fixed it for them. Most of the time, tiny mistakes don’t even drop their grade enough to matter, but the lesson that a mistake isn’t a disaster is worth way more than an extra half-point.
A couple months ago, I assigned a low-stakes “mistake project” for our morning work. Kids had to try one thing they’d never done before, and intentionally make at least three mistakes, then write down what they learned from each. Milo chose to learn how to do a cartwheel. His write-up said, “First I fell on my shoulder, so I learned my hands need to be wider. Second I landed on my neck, so I learned I need to tuck my chin. Third I kicked too hard and fell into our rose bush, so I learned to do it in the middle of the yard, not by the flowers. I still can’t do a whole cartwheel all the way, but no one gave me a bad grade for messing up.” I taped that write-up to my classroom wall.
Last week, after that awkward solar oven start, Milo ended up cutting his flap wrong anyway, it was too small and wouldn’t stay propped open. Instead of asking me to give him a new box, he rummaged in my junk drawer and pulled out a bent paper clip and a piece of tape, and rigged a prop for the flap. His oven didn’t melt his chocolate as fast as the kids with perfectly cut flaps, but when I asked the class what they’d change next time, he was the first one to raise his hand. He said he’d cut a bigger flap next time, and use two paper clips instead of one. That’s the whole point of school, right? Learning how to adjust when something goes wrong, not how to make everything right on the first try.
I still have kids cry when they get a B. I still get emails from parents asking how to bump a grade up a notch before report cards go out. This isn’t a problem that one teacher or one small shift at home can fix overnight. It’s built into all the pressure we put on kids starting way earlier than elementary school, to get perfect scores, get into the right colleges, have a polished track record. But every time we talk about mistakes like they’re part of learning, not something to be ashamed of, that’s a little win. For now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I’ve Seen As A 4th Grade Teacher: The Biggest Problem In The Current Education System