What It’s Really Like Having the “Nice” Boy: Common Struggles and Practical Parenting Tips
The pizza box was still steaming when Jake reached over Leo’s shoulder and grabbed the last pepperoni slice at last month’s soccer team party. Leo had been talking all week about how this place’s pepperoni slices have extra crispy edges, his favorite. I watched him freeze for half a second, then smile and shrug, turn back to the soda machine and say “no problem, I’ll just get garlic bread.” When the other mom next to me nudged me and said “you’re so lucky you have such a nice boy,” I smiled and agreed. But I also felt that little tug in my chest, the one I’ve gotten used to over the 10 years I’ve had Leo.
A month earlier, he’d given his extra raincoat to a kid who forgot his on our class camp trip, even though he had to walk back to the bus stop soaking wet and never said a word until he climbed in our car and I saw his jeans were dripping through. His teacher emails me every quarter to say he’s her easiest student—he always volunteers to erase the board, he lets other kids pick the activity for free time, he never talks back or disrupts. When Leo was 7, a relative told me “it’s so nice that you raised a boy who doesn’t think the world revolves around him.” I said thank you, but I started wondering back then: when does “doesn’t think the world revolves around him” turn into “thinks his needs don’t matter at all?”
For the first few years, I fell into the same trap everyone else does. I praised him for being nice, I was grateful he was easy when I was juggling a new job and my older daughter’s panic attacks before school. I assumed if he was upset, he’d tell me. But that pizza party day, when we got in the car to go home, I asked him straight out: “Did you want that last slice of pepperoni?” He stared at his shoes for a minute, then nodded. “Yeah, but Jake really wanted it too, and he would’ve been mad if I said something. It’s just easier this way.” “Easier for who?” I asked. He shrugged. “For everyone.”
I realized right then that I wasn’t doing him any favors by letting him be the easy, nice kid all the time. The first thing I changed was what I say when he does something kind. I used to say “that’s so nice of you” and leave it at that. Now, I name the feeling he’s probably having, right after I acknowledge the kindness. For example, that day I said “It was really kind of you to let Jake have the pizza. I also know you were really looking forward to that slice, and that must have felt pretty disappointing. That makes total sense to me if you’re mad about it.” At first he just stared at me, like he wasn’t used to anyone noticing that he gave something up. Now, he’ll usually nod and say “yeah, it sucked a little,” and that’s enough.
I also stopped pushing him to be nice at home, to give up things just to keep the peace. For years, if my niece came over and wanted Leo’s favorite video game controller, I’d say “can you let her use it, be a good host?” Now I ask him first: “Do you want to let her use that, or do you want to keep playing with it and we can get the other controller for her?” If he says he wants to keep it, I back him up, no questions. We practice saying no in low-stakes moments at home, so it feels less scary when he has to do it at school. Last semester, when his group project partners left all the work to him, I didn’t immediately email his teacher to fix it. I asked him what he wanted to do. He said he didn’t want to get them in trouble, but he didn’t want to do all the work next time. So we sat in the driveway after school and practiced what he could say to them. He ended up saying “I did the whole poster last time, so we need to split the work this time or I’m telling the teacher.” It worked. They split it.
The third small change I made is something any parent or teacher can do in 30 seconds a week. I make a point to ask him one specific question every Sunday night, no exceptions. It’s not “how was your week?” It’s “what’s one thing you gave up this week that you wish you hadn’t?” It reminds him that I’m looking for those moments he hides, the ones he thinks no one cares about. Last week he said he gave up his spot at the lunch table to a new kid, which was fine, but he had to sit by the garbage can and it smelled bad. I asked him why he did it, he said he didn’t want the new kid to have to sit there. I told him that was kind, and next time he could ask the new kid to sit in the empty spot next to him instead of giving up his whole seat. He thought that was a good idea.
Last weekend, we were at the ice cream shop, and a kid a little older than him cut right in front of Leo in line. For a split second I thought he’d step back and smile like he always did. Instead, he stood his ground and said, quiet but clear, “I was here before you. I’m going next.” The kid rolled his eyes but stepped back. Leo looked over at me, and I just gave him a tiny nod.
He still holds the door for every stranger we pass. He still brings extra granola bars to school for the kid who forgets his lunch. He’s still my nice boy. That’s not a bad thing. But now he’s learning that being kind doesn’t mean he has to erase his own wants to make everyone else comfortable. Some weeks he still gives up more than he should. Some weeks I forget to ask the question, or I’m too busy and I let him be the easy one again. We’re not perfect. We’re just figuring it out, one pizza slice at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What It’s Really Like Having the “Nice” Boy: Common Struggles and Practical Parenting Tips