What It’s Like Having the ‘Nice’ Boy: Parenting Tips for Supporting Your People-Pleasing Son
The inflatable trampoline at my 8-year-old son Jax’s birthday party was still deflating in the corner when I saw it. Jax had saved the last slice of chocolate sprinkle cake, the one he’d marked with a dinosaur-doodled napkin, for an hour after opening presents. A new boy from his class wandered over, grabbed the slice, and lifted a fork to take a bite before Jax could say anything. Jax just pulled his hand back, tugged on that tight little smile he gets when he’s trying not to look upset, and said, “No problem, man.”
I was wiping a juice spill off the picnic table, so I waited until Milo had wandered off to pull Jax aside. I told him we had a backup sheet of cake in the cooler, we could cut him a fresh one right now. He shook his head and said, “I’m not that hungry anyway.” But I knew he’d been talking about that chocolate cake for two weeks. That’s when it hit me again: this is what no one tells you about having the “nice” kid.
At parent-teacher conferences last fall, Jax’s teacher leaned back in her chair and smiled, and said what every adult says about him: “Jax is just such a nice boy. He always helps new kids find their seats, he never argues during clean-up, he lets everyone go first in line. You did a great job here.” I thanked her, but on the walk to the car I thought about how Jax had come home crying three weeks earlier: he’d let three kids cut him in line for the playground slide, and the bell rang before he got a turn. He didn’t say anything to any of them, just came home and cried into his mac and cheese.
I used to be proud of the “nice kid” label. When your son is the one who never gets sent to the principal’s office, never throws tantrums at the grocery store, gets along with every kid on the soccer team, you think that’s the win, right? What parent doesn’t want a nice kid? But over the last year, I’ve started to see the label can turn into something heavy. Jax started to think his job is to be nice, that his value depends on keeping everyone else happy, so he buries his own wants to keep the label intact.
I didn’t make a big, dramatic change to how we handle things, but I’ve tried small, concrete shifts that have made a difference. The first thing I did was stop praising him for being “nice.” I used to say “good job being so nice” every time he gave up something he wanted for someone else. Now, instead of praising the trait, I name the specific choice and ask him how he feels. When he gave up his front seat spot in the car to his little sister on a road trip last month, I didn’t say “what a nice boy.” I said, “I saw you let Lila take the front seat, that was a kind choice. I know you’ve been looking forward to sitting up front all week—was that disappointing for you?” It’s a tiny change in wording, but it gives him permission to say he was upset, instead of forcing him to pretend everything is fine to keep getting that praise.
The second thing we started doing is a “your turn first” rule for any plan we make. Any time we pick a restaurant, a movie, or a weekend activity, Jax gets to go first when sharing what he wants. No “whatever you want” allowed. At first he’d just mumble “I don’t know,” so we’d give him two clear options to pick from, to take the pressure off: “Do you want pancakes or pizza for dinner?” Now he can usually name his own pick without help. It’s a small habit, but it reminds him that his wants matter enough to say out loud before anyone compromises.
I also started letting him see me say no to people. I’m a people pleaser too, so I used to always say yes to favors even when I didn’t have the time or energy, right in front of him. A few months ago, a friend asked me to watch her dog for a long weekend when we already had our camping trip planned. I said, “I’m sorry, that doesn’t work for us this time. We already have plans.” Jax was sitting next to me on the couch when I took the call, and I could see him processing that. It’s one thing to tell him it’s okay to say no, it’s another thing to see your mom do it without the world falling apart.
Two weeks ago, I had a small win I didn’t make a big deal out of. Jax’s best friend came over for a playdate, and the friend wanted to play Minecraft inside. Jax had spent all week building a new bike ramp in the driveway, and he’d been talking about trying it out with his friend all afternoon. I was folding laundry in the living room, and I heard Jax pause, then say, “Actually, I want to ride bikes for an hour first, then we can play Minecraft. Is that okay?” His friend said sure, and they headed out. I just kept folding. I didn’t run out and praise him for being assertive or make a big thing out of it. That’s how it should be, right? Just a normal kid saying what he wants.
It’s not always smooth. Last weekend at the school harvest fair, a boy cut in front of Jax in line for the hayride, and Jax just stepped back like he always did. When I asked him if he wanted to say something, he shrugged and said “it’s okay, I can wait another turn.” That’s fine, honestly. I don’t want to turn my kind, empathetic boy into someone who demands his way every single time. The goal isn’t to get rid of the niceness, it’s just to make sure he knows his needs matter as much as anyone else’s. Everyone says how lucky I am to have a nice boy, and they’re right. But no one ever asks if the nice boy is getting what he needs too. We’re still figuring it out, one small yes to his own wants at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What It’s Like Having the ‘Nice’ Boy: Parenting Tips for Supporting Your People-Pleasing Son