What Is It Really Like to Attend an Independent School: A Parent’s On-the-Ground Perspective
I lean against the splintered wooden fence outside my 10-year-old daughter Mia’s independent elementary school, waiting for her to run back to the car for the water bottle she left on the seat this morning. It’s 8:17 a.m., and the headmaster is kneeling on the sidewalk, helping a six-year-old re-tie his scuffed rain boot before stopping to ask me how my mom’s knee replacement went – he heard me mention it at the fall bake sale. When Mia comes barrelling back out, she waves at the school custodian, who she tells me makes the best hot cocoa on cold indoor recess days, before darting to meet her friends by the rickety climbing frame.
We switched Mia to this school two years ago, after a brutal year in our local public school where her 4th grade class had 31 students. Back then, we didn’t know she had mild dyscalculia; we just knew she started faking stomach aches every Monday to stay home, and she’d cry at the kitchen table for 45 minutes over a half page of math homework. We’d always assumed independent school was for wealthy families with kids headed for Ivy League colleges, not us – we’re two working parents with a modest income, a old minivan, and a kid who just needed someone to notice she was struggling. But a friend told us about the needs-based scholarship program at this school, and we figured we had nothing to lose by applying.
Our first year here was a big adjustment, for all of us. Mia had to get used to being one of only 14 kids in her class, instead of 30. The first month, she told me she felt weird that the teacher called on her even when she didn’t raise her hand – but after a few weeks, she said it felt good that the teacher actually noticed when she knew the answer. At our first parent-teacher conference, the math teacher pulled out a small spiral notebook full of notes she’d taken on Mia: she freezes when asked to solve a problem out loud, she loves drawing graphs so we use that to practice multiplication, she gets embarrassed when she has to ask for extra help so I check in with her quietly after class. The conference ran 45 minutes, and she told me things about my daughter I hadn’t even connected the dots on myself. That’s when I started to get what the daily experience of this school is actually like, beyond the brochures.
It’s not all perfect, of course. Last year, Mia tried out for the travel soccer team and didn’t make it. Because there are only 12 girls in her entire grade, they could only take 8 players, so there were real cuts. At our old public school, there were three teams for different skill levels, so almost anyone who wanted to play could join. She sat in the car and cried after tryouts, and I couldn’t argue when she said it felt unfair that there were so few spots. There’s also a constant expectation of parent involvement that’s hard to meet when you work part time. I still feel guilty when I can’t stay to set up for the class Halloween party, or when I forget to send in a baked good for the bake sale. The tuition, even with our scholarship, is still a huge stretch for us – we cut back on family vacations, put off getting a new car, and skip eating out most weeks to cover the bill.
What I tell friends who ask me what it’s really like, what they should know if they’re considering it, comes from these small daily moments. First, don’t cross independent school off your list just because you think you can’t afford it. Pick up the phone, call admissions, and ask directly about needs-based aid or sliding scale tuition. Many small independent schools set aside a quarter of their budget for aid, and even a partial discount can make it work for families who don’t have six-figure incomes. Second, when you tour, stay 10 minutes after the official tour ends and stand by the playground or main entrance. Watch how staff interact with kids when they don’t think parents are paying attention. If they’re walking past kids who are upset or stopping to say hi instead of just hurrying to their next meeting, that tells you more than any fancy gym or new computer lab. Third, when you talk to admissions, don’t just ask if they support learning differences. Ask them to tell you about a specific time they adjusted a lesson or a rule for a student who needed something different. If they can’t give you a real example, that’s a red flag.
Last night, Mia sat at the kitchen table doing math homework, and she got three out of five problems wrong on the first try. Instead of slamming her notebook shut and crying like she would have three years ago, she laughed and said “Ms. Lee says wrong answers just tell her what I need to practice again.” That’s the biggest change I’ve seen: she doesn’t feel invisible anymore.
As I pull out of the school parking lot, I check my work calendar to see when I can fit in the upcoming volunteer shift I signed up for, and I mentally move a little extra money from our savings to cover this semester’s activity fee. I don’t know if we’ll be able to afford this school through middle school, or if it will continue to be the right fit as Mia gets older. It’s not a golden ticket, and it’s not the right choice for every kid – my neighbor’s son hated the small student body and missed playing big school football, so he switched back to public and is much happier now. But for us, right now, it works. Mia goes to school every day without faking a stomach ache, she knows the name of every person who works in the building from the office manager to the lunch lady, and she gets to be the kid she is, instead of just one of 31. It’s not perfect. It’s just ours.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is It Really Like to Attend an Independent School: A Parent’s On-the-Ground Perspective