What Is a Day in the Life of a College Counselor? A Real Look Beyond Application Editing
7:42 a.m., and the first knock comes before Maria, our suburban public high school’s only full-time college counselor, has even plugged her laptop in. A senior named Lila is in the doorway, hood up, twisting a ripped UChicago sticker on her scuffed water bottle. She got her early action decision overnight: deferred. Maria pulls out the wobbly folding chair she keeps wedged by her bookshelf for unplanned walk-ins, pushes her half-drunk cold oat milk coffee out of the way, and says, “Okay, let’s talk about what that actually means, first. It’s not a no.”
I was shadowing Maria that day as part of our PTA’s “day in the life” series, meant to help parents of underclassmen understand what support is actually available for college planning. I’d gone in with my own assumptions: I thought her days were mostly made of editing personal statements and writing recommendation letters for kids gunning for top schools. I was wrong.
Ten minutes after Lila left (she left with a draft of a brief deferral update and a reminder that she already had an acceptance to the in-state honors program she’d loved since sophomore year), a 15-year-old sophomore named Javi slipped in. He shut the door behind him and blurted that his dad was mad he wouldn’t start planning for a four-year engineering degree. Javi works 10 hours a week doing oil changes for his uncle, and he wants to fix cars for a living. “He says I’ll be poor forever if I don’t go to a four-year,” Javi said, staring at his shoes.
Maria didn’t pull out a list of engineering programs. She pulled a printed brochure from the drawer under her desk, for the local community college’s automotive technology certification program. She showed Javi the page that outlined how the two-year associate’s degree leads directly to Ford factory certification, with a starting salary average listed that’s higher than many entry-level four-year grad jobs in the area. She also pointed out that all the credits transfer to the state college’s bachelor’s in automotive management if he changes his mind in a couple years. “Your job isn’t to fit what your dad thinks success is,” she said. “It’s just to find something that fits you, and we can make that work on paper no matter what it is.”
By 10 a.m., Maria had answered 17 emails, processed 23 transcript requests, and walked a freshman through how to register for the right college prep classes for next year. Then it was time for the scheduled junior parent information session, where three dozen parents crammed into the small meeting room off the counseling office. Most of the questions weren’t about applications—they were about what admissions officers “really want.” One mom asked if her daughter should quit the piano she’s played since she was 7 to add more volunteer hours, because TikTok told her top colleges want a “spike” instead of random activities.
Maria’s answer stuck with me. “Admissions officers don’t count how many lines you have on your activities list,” she said. “If your daughter likes piano, and she plays at the nursing home every month, that’s way more interesting than a week of volunteering at a food bank she doesn’t care about that you signed her up for just to check a box. Keep the thing she actually loves.” That’s the kind of practical pushback most parents don’t get from all the social media noise around college apps.
Most of the rest of the day unfolded in small, urgent chunks. Maria ate a peanut butter granola bar at her desk during lunch while answering a parent’s panicked email about a missing SAT score, and turned down a colleague’s invitation to the teacher’s lounge because she had a last-minute request for a recommendation letter from a senior who’d forgotten the early decision deadline was that Friday. In the afternoon, she led a 90-minute FAFSA workshop for first-generation students, most of whom had never filled out a federal form before, and stayed an hour after to walk individual students through the income section on their phones, since most didn’t have computers at home.
By the time the final bell rang, Maria had seen 27 students and answered 42 emails. She stacked three more recommendation letters to write in her tote bag, because she doesn’t have time to finish them during the regular school day. She told me she has 380 students on her caseload this year—far more than the 100-to-1 ratio the National Association for College Admission Counseling recommends. There’s no time for fancy check-ins with every kid, so she prioritizes the ones who show up at her door first.
Shadowing her that day changed how I think about college planning as a parent. The biggest takeaway isn’t just that counselors are overworked—it’s what you can do as a parent to make the process easier for everyone, and better for your kid. The small concrete things make a big difference: always put your student’s full name and ID number in the email subject line, so she doesn’t have to spend 10 minutes digging through records to find who you’re talking about. Email at least two weeks in advance if you need a meeting or a recommendation letter, don’t ask the day before the deadline. Most importantly, let your kid lead the conversation. If they don’t want to talk about college in front of you, let them meet with the counselor alone—counselors can only help if they’re hearing your kid’s actual goals, not yours.
As I walked out to the parking lot, I saw Lila leaning against the street sign, laughing as she texted a friend. Her deferred dream wasn’t dead, and she already had a great option waiting for her if it didn’t work out. Maria still stays late most nights writing letters, she still can’t get to every request as fast as she wants, and she still has to turn away some walk-ins to get through her scheduled meetings. That’s the real day in the life: it’s not all fancy college acceptances. It’s showing up, one kid at a time, and helping them sort through all the noise to find something that fits.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is a Day in the Life of a College Counselor