What I Wish I Knew Before Leaving High School: Practical Tips for Parents of Teens
My phone buzzed from the nightstand at 1:47 a.m. last Saturday. It was a text from my 19-year-old son, who moved into his first college apartment three weeks prior: “How do you get melted butter out of a carpet?” I rolled out of bed, typed back the baking soda trick I’d learned from my grandma, and sat back against the pillows, wide awake. A former colleague had posted a question in our old teacher group chat a few weeks earlier: What’s one thing you wish you knew before you left school? Most answers were the expected big-ticket items: how credit scores work, how to negotiate a starting salary, how to file your own taxes. My answer was smaller, and it’s been bouncing around my head ever since: almost nothing in adult life comes with a rubric.
I spent 12 years as a high school English teacher, so I know this system better than most. Every assignment has a clear point value, every deadline is non-negotiable, every standard is spelled out in the syllabus so students know exactly what earns an A and what earns a C. We build this structure to help kids learn, and it works—for school. But what I didn’t see, both as a teacher and as a mom raising my own son, is that we train kids to wait for someone else to tell them what matters. When every task is graded and ordered for you, you never get practice ordering it yourself.
We checked every box for my son: AP classes, volunteer hours, college tours, application deadlines. He got into his top-choice engineering program, packed up his old sedan, and drove three hours away. I thought we’d prepared him for everything. Then, two weeks into the semester, he called me, voice tight with panic. He had three things that all had to get done between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. that day: pick up his new desk before the rental office closed, attend a mandatory meeting for his senior design project, and get a flat tire fixed on his bike (his only way to get to class). “I don’t know which one to do first,” he said. “What if I mess it all up?” In that moment, I realized I’d never taught him how to answer that question. In 12 years of school, he’d never had to. If he had two tests the same day, the administration scheduled them around each other. If he had an essay due and a soccer game, I rearranged his study schedule to fit both, because both “mattered.”
I saw this play out with a student of mine five years ago, too. Lila was valedictorian, got into Princeton to study molecular biology, and came home after the first semester and never went back. Everyone whispered about imposter syndrome or homesickness, but I talked to her a year later, when she was working at a local coffee shop and starting at a community college. She told me the thing that broke her wasn’t the coursework—it was the first month of school. She had a 10-page paper due, her roommate’s mom died and she wanted to go to the funeral with her, and the sign-up for her dream research lab closed at 5 p.m. that same day. “In high school, all three would have been 100 points each, and I would have had to do all three,” she said. “No one told me I could skip the lab sign-up and get a spot the next semester. I didn’t know that a 5% penalty for turning the paper in late was okay. I thought if I didn’t do everything perfectly, I was failing.”
The good news is we don’t need to add another required class to high school to teach this. It’s small, daily stuff we can do right now, while our kids are still living with us, that builds this skill.
When your teen comes to you stressed out about a messy list of overlapping commitments, don’t sort their priorities for them. Instead of saying “skip the party and study,” ask them two simple questions: “What’s the actual consequence of skipping each thing? Which consequence can you live with?” That’s it. It doesn’t take long, and it forces them to practice the decision-making they’ll need when you’re not on the other end of the phone at 2 a.m.
Second, let them make small, low-stakes prioritization mistakes. When my son was 17, he got his first part-time job at a coffee shop, and his first paycheck went almost entirely to a new gaming console. He had no money left for groceries the week I was out of town for a conference. I almost transferred him $50, but I didn’t. He ate nothing but Cheerios and leftover ketchup for three days, and complained nonstop when I got home. I just nodded and said, “Yep, that’s what happens when buying the console comes before buying groceries.” He hasn’t made that mistake again. Small, annoying consequences teach far more than any lecture, and they’re way less risky than figuring it out when you’re 300 miles from home.
Third, stop automatically stepping in to fix small messes. If your teen forgets their soccer uniform and has to sit the first half on the bench, don’t drop everything to drive it to them. If they skip studying for a test to go to a concert and get a bad grade, don’t email the teacher begging for a retake. Let them deal with the small penalty, so they learn that a bad grade or a missed practice isn’t the end of the world, and that sometimes you have to choose between two good things.
After I sent my son the baking soda tip, he texted back an hour later that the stain was gone. Then he followed up: “Skipped my 8 a.m. lecture to clean this, do I need to email the prof?” I didn’t tell him what to do. I just sent him those two questions. Ten minutes later, he texted back: “It’s just participation. I’m going back to bed. Thanks.”
I still get these middle-of-the-night texts. He still gets stressed when he has three things to do and only time for two. He still gets the order wrong sometimes. But he’s starting to figure it out, one melted butter stain at a time. That’s the thing I wish someone had told me when I was sitting in my high school gym waiting for graduation: the point isn’t to check all the boxes. The point is learning to decide which boxes are worth checking in the first place.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Wish I Knew Before Leaving High School: Practical Tips for Parents of Teens