What I Tell My Kid About Bullying: A Parent’s Honest, Realistic Approach
It’s 8:17 the night before fourth grade, and Leo is sitting cross-legged on his bed folding the new NASA hoodie he got for his birthday. The sheets are dotted with goldfish cracker crumbs, his space-themed comforter is bunched up at the foot, and he pauses mid-fold to look up at me, quiet in a way that means he’s been working up to asking something. “What if someone bullies me this year?” he says.
I’ve had this conversation before, back when he started first grade and when he switched classes in second. I used to give the script all the parents know: Tell a teacher right away. Stand up tall and be confident. They’re just mean because they’re unhappy at home. But this time, the line that came out was nothing I planned. “No one is going to bully you, probably.”
He blinks, drops the hoodie in his lap. “Probably? That’s supposed to make me feel better?” I sit down on the edge of the bed, the crumbs digging a little into my thigh through my jeans, and I tell him the truth I’ve learned from three years of volunteering in his classroom, from carpool line chats, from watching my older daughter go through elementary school. I tell him that most kids are just as nervous as he is. Most kids aren’t walking around the playground looking for someone to pick on. They’re too busy worrying if someone will want to play four square with them, too busy thinking about if their lunch is cool enough, if their haircut looks stupid.
Last year, Leo came home sobbing from school because a boy in his class called his neon green sneakers “dorky.” I immediately texted his teacher, my chest tight with that mom-rage that bubbles up when your kid is hurt, and I was already mapping out what I’d say at the parent conference. Then the next morning at drop off, that same boy ran up to Leo and asked if he’d be his partner for the nature walk, because he remembered Leo knew every constellation by name. By the end of the week, they were sharing fruit snacks at recess. That rude comment wasn’t bullying. It was just a 9-year-old being thoughtless, the same way Leo once told his friend his dinosaur drawing was ugly because he was mad he lost at Mario Kart.
We’ve gotten so used to labeling every unkind kid interaction as bullying that we scare kids (and ourselves) for no reason. I’ve talked to three different elementary teachers in the last two years who all said the same thing: the kids who show up to school the most tense, the ones who are already expecting someone to be mean to them, are the ones who heard endless talks about bullying all summer at home. We’re passing our own social-media-fueled anxiety onto them, priming them to see conflict where there’s just messy, awkward kid behavior.
That doesn’t mean I stick my head in the sand. Bullying does happen, and when it does, it’s awful. I have a good friend whose daughter was relentlessly teased about her braces in sixth grade, so bad she started throwing up before school every day and eventually switched districts. That’s why it’s “probably,” not “definitely.” But for 9 out of 10 kids, most bad interactions at school are one-off rude comments, a friend who’s mad for a day, someone who doesn’t want to play your game. That’s not bullying, that’s growing up.
I don’t do the big scary bullying talks anymore. I do three small, concrete things that take almost no effort, and they’ve worked so far. First, I don’t ask “did anyone bully you?” when he gets in the car after school. I ask “what was the silliest thing that happened today?” or “who did you sit with at lunch?” If something bad happened, he’ll bring it up. Asking about bullying every day just puts the idea in his head that it’s something he should be waiting for.
Second, I gave him a simple rule to follow: if someone says something that hurts your feelings once, you can just say “That’s not okay, stop it” and walk away. You don’t have to fight, you don’t have to cry, you don’t have to turn it into a big deal. If it happens three times or more, that’s when we call it bullying, and we go to the teacher together, no questions asked. It’s easy for a 9-year-old to remember, and it keeps him from panicking over every little unkind comment.
Third, when he does come to me with a problem, the first thing I ask is “how many times has this happened?” before I do anything. If it’s once, we practice that one line he can say next time, and we move on. If it’s repeated, I send that email to the teacher that day, no waiting.
Back on the bed before fourth grade, Leo thinks this over for a minute, then says “but what if it does happen to me? What if I’m the one out of 10?” I tell him that if that happens, we’ll handle it. We’ll switch seats, we’ll meet with the principal, we’ll change classes, we’ll do whatever we need to do. I won’t tell you to just deal with it, and I won’t let anyone else tell you that either. He nods, picks his hoodie back up, and goes back to folding it, then pulls out his sketchbook to draw a rocket before bed. We don’t talk about bullying again the whole night.
It’s been six weeks into the school year now. A boy called his galaxy drawing dumb a couple of weeks ago. Leo told him it wasn’t nice, went and sat with his other friends at the art table, and didn’t mention it to me until we were talking about bad art takes over dinner last Sunday. I still don’t know if this approach is the “right” one. Some parents I know say I’m too casual, that I’m minimizing the risk of bullying. Others say I’m overthinking it. But so far, this is what works: Leo goes to school excited, he doesn’t walk down the hallway waiting for someone to be mean to him. He gets to be a kid, instead of a kid waiting for something bad to happen. That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Tell My Kid About Bullying: A Parent’s Honest, Realistic Approach