What I Learned When My Shy 5-Year-Old Agreed To Be A Flower Girl: Parenting Tips For Anxious Kids
The grass at the country club was still dewy from the morning sprinklers when Lila pressed her face into the back of my jeans, one sticky blue popsicle hand fisted in the fabric of my skirt. My sister’s wedding rehearsal had only just started, and the wedding coordinator was already leaning down, smiling too wide, asking my 5-year-old if she wanted to practice walking down the aisle for her big turn as flower girl. Lila mumbled something I couldn’t hear and squeezed tighter.
Three months earlier, when my sister first popped the question, Lila shook her head so hard her pigtails flew and said “no” before my sister even finished speaking. Lila’s always been this way: she hangs back at playdates, won’t order her own chicken nuggets at McDonald’s, sat on my lap through the entire preschool graduation last spring instead of walking across the stage to get her diploma. I’ve gotten a lot of well-meaning advice from other parents: push her out of your comfort zone, she’ll get over it if you don’t coddle her. For a while I believed that, until I tried it once, made her go to a birthday party with a clown, and she cried so hard she threw up in the bathroom. So this time, I did things differently.
I started by telling Lila the decision was 100% hers, no strings attached. If she said no, my sister would ask the 10-year-old cousin, no guilt, no hurt feelings. When she asked a week later if she could try, we started tiny. Two minutes every night after dinner, we’d practice walking down our hallway, scattering Cheerios (cheaper than rose petals, and she thought it was hilarious) from a basket. At first, it was just me watching. Then we added her stuffed rabbit, then her stuffed bear, then I recorded her on my phone so she could see what everyone else would see. No pressure to be perfect, no making her do it again if she got tired of it after one try. We also drew up a safety plan in crayon on a piece of construction paper and stuck it to the fridge: 1) If you get scared at the top of the aisle, you can stop. 2) You can run straight to mama anytime you want. 3) After you’re done, you get a green gummy bear, my treat.
I also adjusted the small things I knew would bug her before they became big problems. The tulle dress the bride picked was scratchy enough to make me itch just touching it, so I sewed a soft cotton tank top inside the lining so her skin never touched the tulle. She hated the heavy, fancy wicker basket the coordinator gave her, so we swapped it for her beat-up 2-year-old Easter basket that she carries everywhere. No one but me noticed the difference.
On wedding day, it was 82 degrees and humid, and she played with bubbles behind the tent until five minutes before it was time to walk. The music started, the bridesmaids glided down the aisle, then it was her turn. She stood at the top of the oak staircase that led into the garden, basket hanging from her arm, and froze. I could see the back of her neck turn pink, and her fingers started twisting the handle so hard her knuckles went white. The string quartet slowed down, every guest turned to look. I didn’t stand up and wave her on, didn’t mouth “you got this” like everyone was expecting. I just patted the empty spot on the pew next to me, and mouthed “I’m right here whenever you want me.”
For 10 whole seconds she just stood there, and I was ready for her to run down to me, and that would have been okay. Then she lifted one foot, took a tiny step, then another. She scattered all her petals on the left side of the aisle, none on the right, and then she broke into a run the last 10 feet, and launched herself into my arms. Everyone clapped, she buried her face in my shoulder, and I pulled the pre-portioned gummy bear out of my pocket and handed it to her, just like we promised.
This experience changed how I think about helping shy kids try new things. A lot of parents get stuck thinking we need to help our kids outgrow their discomfort, that if we just push them enough, they’ll turn into outgoing kids who love being the center of attention. But what I’ve found is that small, supported steps work way better than any amount of pushing. The concrete things that worked for us are things any parent can try, they don’t take a lot of time or money. First, always have a clear exit plan. Don’t make your kid feel like they’re trapped doing something they hate once they start. Telling them they can leave anytime takes away the biggest fear: the fear of being stuck and embarrassed in front of everyone. Second, break big scary things into tiny, low-stakes practice steps. Two minutes a day at home is way less overwhelming than a full rehearsal in front of a bunch of strangers a week before the event. Third, adjust the small discomforts before they become big problems. A scratchy dress doesn’t sound like a big deal, but for a kid with sensitive skin, that constant irritation can make an already scary situation feel impossible. It takes 10 minutes to add a layer of soft fabric, or bring a favorite small toy, or swap a too-big basket, and it makes all the difference. Fourth, don’t make a big deal out of the end result. I didn’t gush for 10 minutes about how brave she was for standing in front of everyone, or how perfect she did. I just said “I’m so proud of you for trying it your way” and let her go run and play. Putting too much praise on the outcome makes it feel like a test they had to pass, instead of a choice they got to make.
After the reception, we drove home, and Lila fell asleep in the backseat with dried rose petals in her hair and a half-eaten chocolate cupcake in her lap. Last week, her preschool teacher told me about the upcoming holiday sing-along, and when we got home Lila told me she doesn’t want to stand on the stage and sing. I told her that’s fine. We already talked about it: she can stand at the back with me, or sit in back and color, whatever she wants. She hasn’t turned into a confident public speaker overnight, and that’s okay. Some days she tries new things, some days she doesn’t. The flower girl thing wasn’t about turning her into someone she’s not. It was about letting her stretch a little, on her own terms, and that’s more than enough for me.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When My Shy 5-Year-Old Agreed To Be A Flower Girl: Parenting Tips For Anxious Kids