What I Learned When My 7-Year-Old Kept Playing With The Girl I Worry About
It’s 3:15 on a Tuesday, I’m leaning against the scuffed brick wall of the elementary school, half scrolling my grocery list, when I see my 7-year-old Lila round the corner holding hands with Mia. Mia’s gray hoodie has a permanent coffee stain on the cuff from her dad’s morning drive-through, she’s got the same hole in the knee of her jeans that’s been there for three weeks, and she yells twice as loud as most kids on the playground. I’ve heard the other parents mutter about her by the pickup line: she’s rough, she doesn’t share, her family’s messy. I’ve had my own moments of worry too.
Last month, Lila came home with a scraped elbow that needed three stitches, breathless and crying, saying Mia had pushed her off the swing mid-race. I was furious, my first instinct was to tell her she couldn’t play with Mia anymore. I even listed off the other girls in her class, the ones who bring homemade cookies to bake sales and always remember to say please and thank you, the ones whose parents I chat with over coffee after school. Lila just crossed her arms, dug her heels into our entryway rug, and said, “But Mia lets me dig for worms in her backyard and no one else does. She makes up the best dragon games.”
I agreed to let the friendship continue, but only if Mia came over for a playdate at our house first, so I could keep an eye on things. I tidied the playroom, put away my good fine-tip markers because I’d heard Mia draws on walls, and stocked snacks that I knew wouldn’t cause a mess. Ten minutes in, I walked into the dining room to get a glass of water and found Mia standing on a chair, drawing a huge purple dinosaur on the unpainted back of our dining room set. I froze. She looked up at me, no shame, no apology, and just said, “My mom says drawing on furniture is fun. She lets me do it on our old fridge in the garage.” Lila was standing right beside her, holding a purple marker, grinning like she was next in line.
I used to think my job as a parent was to pick good friends for my kid. I thought that meant sticking to kids who followed the same rules we did, who had the same routines, who wouldn’t get her hurt or into trouble. But standing there that afternoon, I realized I’d been approaching it all wrong. If I banned Mia every time she did something that broke our rules, Lila would never get to practice figuring out how to handle people who don’t live by the same expectations she does.
I didn’t yell, I didn’t send Mia home, and I didn’t turn to Lila and say “see what I told you?” I just walked over, knelt down, and said, “That’s a really cool dinosaur. At our house, we only draw on paper, so let’s get this cleaned up together, okay?” We got the magic eraser from under the sink, scrubbed it off together, and then I taped a big sheet of butcher paper to the garage wall for them to draw whatever they wanted. It didn’t take more than ten minutes, and no one’s feelings got hurt. That’s the first small trick I’ve stuck with: state your house rules clearly, don’t shame the kid for following different rules at home, and fix mistakes together instead of punishing.
After the swing incident, I swapped out my generic “don’t play with her” for a habit of asking specific questions every day after school, instead of the vague “did you have fun?” or “was Mia nice to you?” I’d ask “What did you do when she took your sparkly pencil?” “How did that feel when she cut you in line for the slide?” “What did you do next?” The first week, she just said Mia didn’t listen, but after a few days, she told me she’d walked away and played on the monkey bars by herself until Mia said she was sorry. I didn’t tell her what to do. I just let her talk through it, and helped her brainstorm options if she asked. One time she asked if she could tell Mia to stop yelling when they play, and we practiced what she’d say in the mirror a few times before school. That’s the second thing: let your kid work through conflict on their own first, instead of stepping in to fix it for them.
I’ve also stopped pretending all households run the same way. I know Mia’s mom works two retail jobs and her dad’s on the road three days a week, so sometimes Mia forgets her after-school snack or doesn’t have a rain jacket when it’s pouring. I just keep an extra granola bar and a spare rain jacket in my car now. It’s no extra work, and it means no one goes hungry or cold while they play.
Last month, another mom pulled me aside by the pickup line and said she’d heard Mia got sent to the principal’s office for swearing at a recess aide, and wasn’t I worried she’d “ruin” Lila? I get the worry, I really do. But I’ve noticed Lila hasn’t started swearing. What she has started doing is climbing trees higher than she ever would when she played with her other friends, who only want to reenact the same princess movie over and over. She digs for worms after school, makes up silly songs that don’t have any words, and stands up for herself when she’s upset in a way she never did two years ago. Last week at the park, I watched Mia push a little first grader off the slide, and Lila walked right up to her, hands on her hips, and said “That’s not okay. He was waiting his turn. Go say sorry.” And Mia did. I sat on the bench the whole time, didn’t say a word.
Do I still worry sometimes? Yeah. Two weeks ago, Lila pulled a crumpled half-smoked cigarette butt out of her pocket that Mia found on the sidewalk and thought was a “candy cigarette.” We threw it away, washed her hands, and had a very clear talk about how you never pick up random things off the ground, no matter who you’re playing with. It’s not that Mia is bad, it’s that some things are unsafe, full stop. That rule doesn’t change for anyone.
It’s messy. It’s not the perfectly polished group of friendships I imagined for Lila when she was a toddler starting preschool. Other parents still side-eye me sometimes for letting Lila spend so much time with Mia. But I’d rather she learn how to navigate tricky, messy friendships now, when I’m close by to help her problem solve, than when she’s older and I’m not around to help. This friendship is hers, mess and all, and so far, it’s teaching her more than any perfectly polite playdate ever could.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When My 7-Year-Old Kept Playing With The Girl I Worry About