What I Learned When I Discovered I Was Lied To About My Own Education (And What It Means For Your Kid)
The mothball smell hit me first when I pulled my stack of elementary report cards out of the cardboard box my mom dropped off last week. I’d just gotten home from my 8-year-old son’s parent-teacher conference, where his teacher leaned across the table and said, “He aces every math test, but he struggles with reading fluency, mixes up word order, and checks out when there’s too much text on a page. This runs in families, right? Have you ever noticed anything similar with you or your partner?”
I flipped through the frayed 1990s cardstock, and there it was, scrawled in looping blue pen on every report from third to sixth grade: “Very bright, but doesn’t apply herself. Distracted, lazy, rushes through work to go play.” I remembered that fourth grade conference, when I hid behind the hallway water fountain while my teacher told my mom I was just lazy. I walked out of that meeting believing it, too. For the next 30 years, I blamed every messy, half-illegible note, every time I had to read a paragraph three times to understand it, every last-minute paper crammed in the night before it was due on me being lazy, just like they said.
I sat on the laundry room floor that night, flipping through those old cards, and realized no one had ever told me that what I lived with was mild dyslexia. It was right there, in my family history: my grandma dropped out of high school because she “couldn’t make the words stick” and everyone called her not book smart. My dad still refuses to read anything longer than a grocery list, says he “just hates reading.” It never occurred to any of us that this wasn’t a character flaw, it was just how our brains work. That was the big lie I was taught about my education: that my struggles were my fault, that I could fix them if I just cared enough.
I’d been repeating that same pattern with my son, without even noticing. When he’d leave his reading homework half done, I’d say “Just finish it, you’re almost there.” When he’d act out instead of reading out loud, I’d get frustrated. After the conference, we got him tested, and sure enough, mild dyslexia, just like me. What followed wasn’t some big, dramatic overhaul. We started small, with tiny changes that made a huge difference.
First, we rewrote the 20-minute daily reading requirement. Instead of him reading the whole time out loud, we take turns: I read a page, he reads a page. That cuts his mental fatigue in half, and he doesn’t get so worn out from decoding that he acts out before he can finish. Second, we got the school to approve text-to-speech for all his assignments with long blocks of text. He can understand the Civil War just fine; the problem was decoding all the words on the page, not understanding the content. Why make decoding the barrier to him learning the content? Third, I started asking him a different question when he says he can’t do his homework. Instead of “Why didn’t you try harder?” I ask “What part of this is the hardest for you?” Last week he told me the words all run together when the whole page is covered in questions, so I got him a blank piece of paper to cover everything except the question he’s working on. That one 10-cent trick cut his homework time by 20 minutes that night.
It’s not just my kid, either. I’ve had to unlearn the lie for myself too. I always felt guilty for using text-to-speech for work, for writing grocery lists on my phone instead of on paper, for asking people to repeat street signs when I misread them. I thought it was me being lazy, that I should just work harder. Now I know it’s just an accommodation, like wearing glasses. No one calls you lazy for needing glasses to read, right? Why do we call it lazy for needing a little help with words?
For other parents who might recognize this pattern in their own family, there are a few small, concrete things that have worked for me. First, if your kid struggles with something and you remember struggling the exact same way when you were little, don’t just assume it’s laziness that runs in the family. Write down when the struggle happens for two weeks. Is it only reading? Only writing? Only when there’s a lot of text on a page? That’s way more useful for a teacher or doctor than just saying “they don’t try.” Bring that pattern up, ask for testing. Second, start with small changes before you commit to big, stressful overhauls. That blank piece of paper trick worked better for us than any expensive tutoring program did at first.
We still have hard days. Last week, my son got a bad grade on a reading quiz because he rushed through to get to recess, and I almost said “you just need to pay more attention” before I caught myself. I still forget that I can use text-to-speech for my own work sometimes, and I’ll spend an hour struggling through a long report before I remember I don’t have to. I never got an apology from my old teachers, and I’ll probably spend the rest of my life unlearning that little voice in my head that says I’m lazy. But last weekend, I found my son on the couch, reading a dinosaur graphic novel on his tablet, using text-to-speech to follow along, and he was laughing and pointing out all the cool T-Rex facts to me. He didn’t feel stupid. He didn’t feel lazy. That’s enough for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When I Discovered I Was Lied To About My Own Education (And What It Means For Your Kid)