What I Learned When I Decided Not to Redshirt My Youngest-in-Class Son
I’m perched on a too-small plastic kindergarten chair in October, my sneakers sticky from the apple juice box I spilled in the parking lot, staring at a crumpled piece of construction paper. My son Jax’s name is scribbled across the bottom in lopsided blue crayon, and the rest of the page is covered in stick-figure race cars. His teacher, Ms. Henderson, leans forward and says exactly what I’ve been dreading hearing: “You know, a lot of parents in Jax’s position would have redshirted him.” I glance through the classroom window to the playground, where Jax is currently clinging to the top of the 10-foot jungle gym, cackling as a group of first graders dare him to jump off. He’s the smallest kid out there by a full head, but he’s holding his own.
Jax is my second boy, born August 28, just three days before our state’s September 1 kindergarten cut-off. He squeaked in by a hair, and we’d debated holding him back for 10 months before that first day. My oldest, Ethan, born mid-August five years earlier, we’d redshirted. Back then, his pediatrician pointed out his speech was a little behind, and every parent we knew told us holding back a boy gave him a leg up socially and athletically. So we did it, and it felt like the right call at the time. But with Jax, everything felt different. He’d spent his whole life tagging after Ethan and his friends, climbing into their board games, copying their homework, fighting them over the remote. He never acted like the youngest. He acted like one of the guys.
I drove home that day with Ms. Henderson’s comment bouncing around my head, and I pulled out the short note I’d written in my phone a year earlier when we were first debating. I’d written down three specific questions to answer, instead of just listening to all the unsolicited advice from neighbors and social media accounts. First: Can he do the daily stuff kindergarten actually requires? Jax could tie his own shoes, open his juice box, zip his winter coat, and use the bathroom without help. He could follow two-step directions (“put your toys away and wash your hands for dinner”) without getting distracted halfway. The only gaps Ms. Henderson pointed out were that he got wiggly five minutes earlier than most kids during circle time, and his fine motor skills were a little behind—he couldn’t hold a pencil correctly long enough to write his whole name neatly. That felt fixable. Second: Does he actually want to be in kindergarten? Jax had asked every single day for six months when it was his turn to go to big boy school like Ethan. He hated staying home with me while Ethan was gone, and he’d already memorized most of the kindergarten sight words from quizzing Ethan every night. Third: What’s the trade-off if we hold him back? We already knew this one from Ethan: when Ethan hit middle school, he was a full year older than all his friends. He was the last one to get a phone, the last one to get his learner’s permit, and he’s complained more than once that he feels like he’s stuck waiting for everyone else to catch up. That’s a trade-off no one talks about when they’re telling you to redshirt for sports.
We talked to Ms. Henderson and worked out small adjustments instead of holding Jax back. She let him keep a cheap fidget cube in his desk to squeeze during circle time, which cut his wiggly episodes by more than half. I started doing five minutes of fine motor practice every night after dinner, nothing fancy—just tearing construction paper for collages, stringing cereal onto yarn for necklaces, drawing race cars. No tutors, no fancy workbooks, just five minutes a day while I waited for the pasta to boil.
That was two and a half years ago. Jax is in second grade now. He’s still the shortest kid in his class, and he still can’t reach the water fountain by the cafeteria without standing on his tiptoes. His handwriting is still messy, and he comes home most Fridays too tired to do anything but sit on the couch and watch cartoons. But his reading test scores are above grade level, he’s the first one to help a new kid find their classroom, and he remembers every single one of his teammates’ birthdays on his soccer team. He’s not the star player—he’s a year smaller than most of the other boys, so he doesn’t score as many goals—but he never misses a practice, and he’s the one who picks everyone up when they fumble a pass.
When other parents ask me if I’d recommend redshirting their youngest-in-class son, I don’t give them a yes or no. I tell them to skip the viral polls and the cousin’s story about her kid who became a state football champion after redshirting. Write down the small, daily skills your kid actually needs, not the milestones some website says they should hit by age 5. If the gaps are small, like wiggly attention or messy handwriting, fix those small gaps instead of holding them back a whole year. Don’t do it just for sports. The odds your kid is going to play college ball are tiny, and the social awkwardness of being a year older than all your friends in high school is way more noticeable than the advantage of being bigger in third grade soccer. If you’re on the fence, ask your kid’s preschool teacher for specific observations, not a general recommendation. Have they seen your kid play with older kids? Can he keep up?
Last week, Jax came home from school complaining that he couldn’t reach the good slide at recess because the big fifth graders were standing in front of it, and he was too short to squeeze past. I asked him if he wished we’d held him back a year so he’d be tall enough to push past them. He rolled his eyes, grabbed a granola bar off the counter, and said “No way. If I did that I wouldn’t be in Mr. Torres’ class, and we’re going to the zoo next week. That’s stupid.”
Right now, that’s good enough for me. There’s no way to know for sure if we made the right call. In 10 years, he might tell me he always felt behind, or he might tell me he’s glad he gets to graduate high school a year earlier. For now, he’s happy, he’s learning, and he hasn’t stopped climbing to the top of the jungle gym. That’s all we can really ask for.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned When I Decided Not to Redshirt My Youngest-in-Class Son