What I Learned Helping My Kid Look For A Good LSAT Practice Textbook
The kitchen table was stacked with crumpled granola bar wrappers, a half-empty mug of cold coffee, and seven different LSAT prep book listings pulled up on my laptop last January, when my oldest son sat across from me, rubbing his eyes, and said he had no clue which one to buy. He’s a junior pre-law, works 20 hours a week at the campus coffee shop, couldn’t swing the $1,200 commercial prep course most of his classmates were taking, so he was set on self-studying for the June exam. He’d already watched a dozen YouTube breakdowns of the test, knew he struggled most with logic games, but when it came to buying a practice textbook, every review contradicted the last. One Reddit thread said the big-name blue book was the only thing that worked, the next said it was full of bad questions and lazy explanations. I told him I’d help him sort it out; I figured it’d take an hour, tops, then we could order one and move on. It ended up taking three weeks of flipping through library copies, testing out sections, and returning two duds before we found what worked.
We bought the big best-selling one from the campus bookstore first, because it was 20% off and had 10 full practice tests, which looked like a great deal. After two weeks of studying, he came over for Sunday dinner and spread his work out on the table, pointing to a logic game question he’d gotten wrong. The explanation in the book just said “Choice D is incorrect because it contradicts the third rule, so C is correct.” He’d already figured out he got it wrong; what he needed was someone to walk through how to set up the diagram to see the contradiction in the first place. That book had all the practice questions anyone could want, but it might as well have been written for people who already know how to get every question right. It was useless for someone still learning the steps.
A friend lent him an older Kaplan book to try next, and that one was the opposite problem. Half the pages were general strategy like “how to study for the LSAT” and “what to do the night before the test” that he’d already read for free on LSAT’s official website. It only had three full practice tests, and all the questions were written by the publisher, not taken from past official exams. He took a full practice test on a Saturday morning and scored 165, which was 5 points higher than his target, so he was thrilled. A week later, he took an official past test from a free PDF online and scored a 159. The third-party questions were easier, and they threw off his entire sense of where he actually stood. That’s when we started to figure out what actually makes a good LSAT practice textbook, no matter what the marketing says.
First, you don’t need one big, expensive all-in-one book. Most people self-studying need two types of books at most: a strategy book that focuses on the section your kid actually struggles with, and a separate book of real, past LSAT practice tests. No third-party practice questions beat the real thing, because the test makers write questions a very specific way, and off-brand questions don’t prepare you for the rhythm or difficulty of test day. Second, explanations matter more than the number of questions. A book with 5 real tests and clear, step-by-step explanations is way more useful than a book with 20 tests that just tell you if you’re right or wrong.
He already had a good handle on logical reasoning and reading comp from his political science classes, so he only bought the PowerScore Logic Games Bible, used, from a senior who’d taken the test the year before, for $15. That book walks through every type of logic game step by step, shows different diagram methods, and explains why every wrong answer is wrong, not just that it’s wrong. Then we bought the official LSAC book of 10 recent practice tests, brand new for $35, because those are all real past tests, straight from the test maker. We didn’t need anything else. We looked into buying the whole three-book PowerScore set, but that would’ve cost $150, and he didn’t need the other two books, so we skipped it. A little tip we found: almost any LSAT book less than 10 years old is still totally usable, because the test structure hasn’t changed, so buying used saves a ton of money and doesn’t hurt your prep at all. Most campuses have pre-law book swaps, or you can find them on Facebook Marketplace for a fraction of the retail price.
He took the test in June, got a 164, which is exactly what he needed for the in-state law program he’s been wanting to go to, so we got lucky. I know every kid studies differently, and some people would benefit from a different set of books, or a prep course if they can afford it. But for kids working part-time, self-studying on a budget, the whole process of looking for a good LSAT practice textbook doesn’t have to be as overwhelming as it feels at first. The books are still sitting on the shelf in his old bedroom, and he’s already got a freshman lined up to buy them from him for $25 total, so the cycle will keep going. I don’t think there’s one perfect book for everyone, but if you skip the fancy marketing, prioritize real questions and clear explanations, and only buy what you actually need, you’ll end up in good shape. That’s what worked for us, anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned Helping My Kid Look For A Good LSAT Practice Textbook