What I Learned From Hiring The “Nightmare Babysitter” No One Else Would
The doorbell rang at 6:45 pm, 15 minutes before my husband and I were supposed to leave for our first anniversary dinner in three years, and I already knew I’d made a mistake. My original babysitter had texted an hour earlier saying she had a fever, and after panicking through three “can you do it?” texts to every other trusted sitter on my list, I’d caved and called Mia, the 16-year-old who lived two houses down. Every mom in the neighborhood Facebook group had called her a nightmare. She’d gotten in a fight at school, dyed her hair bubblegum pink, and once skipped a whole week of classes to go camping with her older brother. One woman even commented “that girl will corrupt your kid” when I mentioned I was desperate for a last-minute sitter.
When I opened the door, she was leaning against the porch rail with a skateboard slung over one shoulder, her nails chipped black, a sticker of a frog wearing a leather jacket on her water bottle. My 4-year-old Lila peeked out from behind my leg and immediately pointed at the sticker. “I like frogs,” she said. Mia grinned. “I got a whole pack of these in my bag. I’ll give you one if you promise not to tell my mom I bought them with my lunch money.”
We left 10 minutes later, and I spent half the dinner pulling out my phone to check the indoor camera I’d installed after a break-in down the street. The first thing I saw was Lila refusing to eat the mac and cheese I’d left out for her. I usually spend 20 minutes negotiating, end up caving and giving her a granola bar, and feel guilty for the rest of the night. Mia just leaned against the fridge and said, “Wanna cook something else? I’m hungry too. We got nuggets in the freezer, right?” Ten minutes later, Lila had poured panko breading all over the kitchen counter, and both of them had crumbs on their cheeks. Mia didn’t rush to wipe it up. She just took a blurry photo of Lila with her phone and moved on.
Half an hour later, Lila’s favorite stuffed rabbit, Mr. Floof, went missing. I’ve sat through 45-minute screaming meltdowns over this exact scenario. I tear the whole house apart, talk her through breathing exercises, and end up just as frazzled as she is. This time, Mia sat cross-legged on the floor and didn’t try to calm her down. She said, “What does Mr. Floof do when he’s hiding? Does he growl?” Lila stopped screaming long enough to say, “He growls at monsters.” Mia said, “Okay, let’s go hunt him. I’ll be the monster, you be the hunter.” They wandered room to room, Mia growling every time they opened a door, and found him wedged under the couch in three minutes flat. I stared at my phone in the middle of the restaurant, shocked.
When we got home, Lila ran to me covered in glitter, waving her new frog sticker, and yelled, “Can Mia come back tomorrow?” The living room had paper airplanes stuck to the ceiling, the counter was still covered in breading crumbs, and there was a popsicle stick on the coffee table. I expected to be annoyed, but I was just full of a weird, soft surprise. All the things other parents had called red flags about Mia didn’t look so bad when I saw her with my kid.
I started thinking about what we actually look for in caregivers, and how many of the boxes we check don’t matter that much. I’d always wanted an honor roll student with glowing references from other conservative families, someone who’d follow my every instruction and leave the house exactly how I left it. But what Lila needed was someone who didn’t panic when things got messy. Someone who’d play her game instead of jumping in to fix her mood.
I’ve adjusted how I talk to other parents about vetting sitters now, and there are a few concrete things I tell them to try. First, don’t write someone off just because they have a messy reputation on a neighborhood group. Next time you need help, ask them to stop by for 15 minutes so your kid can meet them first. Watch how they interact: do they talk to your kid, not just you? That matters more than a clean disciplinary record. Second, cut your list of rules way down. I used to leave a full page of instructions: no screens after 7pm, brush teeth at 7:30, bed at 8, no sugary snacks. Now I leave three: Lila is allergic to nuts, lock the front door if you go in the backyard, call me for anything big. Everything else is fine. I can wipe down a counter in two minutes the next morning. A 15-minute delay on bedtime isn’t going to ruin any kid’s life.
A couple weeks ago, Mia showed up to babysit upset. She’d just broken up with her first boyfriend, and she sat on our couch and cried a little while Lila dragged all her stuffed animals over to her. I used to think that was unprofessional, that a babysitter shouldn’t show their feelings to your kid. But Lila sat right next to her, patted her back, and said, “My mom cries when she burns the cookies. It’s okay.” That’s a lesson I can’t teach her with a talk. She had to see it to learn it.
The other day, Mrs. Henderson from down the street stopped me at the mailbox and shook her head. “I still can’t believe you let that girl watch your Lila,” she said. “She’s such a nightmare.” I just shrugged. Mia’s got a new part-time job at the coffee shop downtown now, so she can only babysit once every two weeks, and we’re looking for someone to fill the other spot. I won’t lie, I’m worried we won’t find someone as good. I still panic sometimes when I come home and find slime in the carpet or glitter in my bed. But last week, Lila told me she wanted to be a babysitter when she grows up, just like Mia. That’s when I knew it was all worth it. Some of the best people to take care of your kids don’t look like the sitters you think you’re supposed to hire. I don’t know what the future holds, but for now, I’ll take the so-called nightmare over a perfect sitter any day.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned From Hiring The “Nightmare Babysitter” No One Else Would