What I Learned About AI in Schools As a Journalist and Parent
I was leaning against the rusted bike rack outside my son’s 7th grade middle school last month, kicking at crumpled fallen maple leaves, when he pulled out his Chromebook and waved me over. “Check what Ms. Carter let us do for our Civil War project,” he said, tapping the screen to pull up his outline. Half the bullet points had a little [AI brainstorm] tag at the end. I blinked. “Your teacher lets you use ChatGPT for homework?” He rolled his eyes, the way 12-year-olds do when their parent asks a stupid question. “Yeah? It’s just a brainstorm. I still have to write all the actual paragraphs and add my own sources. It’s like a calculator for writing. You don’t yell at me for using a calculator for algebra, do you?”
That line stuck with me, because I’ve spent the last six months reporting on AI in education across eight local school districts, and that’s the most honest take I’ve heard yet. Before I started this work, I was just like most parents: I skimmed the headlines about AI cheating, assumed all schools would ban the tool, and worried my kid would grow up letting a robot do all his thinking. After sitting in on classes, listening to PTA fights, and talking to dozens of teachers and parents, I’ve got a far messier, more useful takeaway than any headline gives you.
A few weeks back, I sat in on a district-wide PTA meeting about AI policy, and the room split right down the middle. Half the parents were furious that any school allowed student access, saying it would kill critical thinking and that kids would never learn to write a proper sentence. One mom pulled out her 10th grader’s suspension notice, got tearful, and said he’d used AI to write a book report and now had a permanent zero on his transcript. The other half argued banning it was pointless, that kids would use it anyway, and they needed to learn it for college and work. Everyone yelled over each other, and almost no one asked what AI actually looks like when it’s used well inside a classroom.
A week later, I sat in the back of an 11th grade English class at the local public high school to see for myself. The teacher, Ms. Henderson, has been teaching for 22 years, and she rewrote her entire curriculum this year to integrate AI. The assignment that day was drafting arguments for an essay on whether schools should ban student cell phones. I walked up and down the rows to see what kids were working on. One girl had ChatGPT pulled up, it had generated three different opening paragraphs, and she was crossing out whole lines, rewriting the stiff generic bits to sound like her. A boy in the back used AI to break down a 12-page CDC study on teen distractedness that he couldn’t get through because of all the academic jargon, so he could pull the data he needed for his own argument. Ms. Henderson told me she changed her grading system this year: 70% of the grade is process, 30% is the final essay. Kids have to turn in all their drafts, any chat logs with AI, and a 3-sentence note explaining what AI gave them and what they changed. Cheating has actually gone down, she said, because it’s way harder to turn in a full AI-generated essay when you have to show all your work.
That’s when I started thinking about what this means for parents, what we can actually do at home that’s not just panic or ignore the whole thing. The biggest shift I’ve made in my own house is ditching the question “Did you use AI?” for something far more useful. Instead of sneaking onto my kid’s computer to run his essay through an AI detector (which are wrong half the time anyway, for what it’s worth), I just say, “Walk me through how you put this together. Show me what AI helped with, and why you changed what it gave you.” If he can explain his own argument and his own choices, I don’t care if he used AI to get past writer’s block. If he can’t explain it, that’s when we sit down and work through it together, same as if he copied a friend’s homework or didn’t understand the assignment to begin with.
Another concrete tip I picked up from a middle school math teacher: if your kid struggles with math homework, don’t let AI do all the work for them, but don’t ban it entirely. Let them use it to check their answers, or to explain a tricky step they can’t wrap their head around, then make them do three similar problems on their own to prove they get the concept. It cuts down on the hours parents spend arguing about homework, and it makes sure kids still practice the basics they need for tests.
Of course, it’s not all positive. I talked to a principal at a low-income elementary school who said her staff has gotten zero training on AI, so most teachers just ban it entirely because they don’t have time or support to figure out how to use it well. That’s a real, growing gap: kids in wealthy districts are learning how to use a tool that will be required for most jobs in the next decade, while kids in underfunded districts aren’t getting that practice at all. I also talked to a college counselor who said she sees 10 to 15 kids a year get rejected from colleges because they turned in full AI-written personal essays, that don’t sound anything like a real teen. That mistake is almost always because no one ever taught them that AI is a helper, not a ghostwriter.
I still don’t have all the answers. Last night, I caught my 12-year-old using AI to write a silly poem for his friend’s birthday, and I almost snapped at him to write it himself, before I stopped. He just wanted a quick draft to base his dumb jokes off of, and he ended up changing almost every line anyway. We’re all figuring this out as we go, teachers and parents both. There’s no one perfect rule that works for every kid or every class. What I do know is that panicking and banning it entirely isn’t working, and treating it like a magic fix for all of education’s problems isn’t working either. It’s just a new tool, and the job still is what it always was: teaching kids how to think for themselves, no matter what tools they have at their fingertips.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned About AI in Schools As a Journalist and Parent