What I Found In My Old Secondary School English Workbook Changed How I Support Fast, Messy Learners
I was clearing out my late mom’s garage last month when I tripped over a cardboard box marked “High School, 1998”. It was half-buried under a deflated kid’s trampoline and a stack of my brother’s old college basketball programs, so I dragged it out into the driveway to sort through. On top was my beat-up blue English workbook, cover cracked where I’d stuffed it into too-tight lockers a hundred times, edges stained with the cherry Slurpee I spilled on it before a midterm.
I flipped through it while I sat on the driveway step, letting the warm sun cut through the dust. Red pen covered almost every page, and I’d forgotten just how hard my teacher had come for me on things that didn’t really matter. Every essay was marked down first for messy handwriting, then for skipping the two-page pre-writing packet we were required to staple to the front. Comments like “Why can’t you slow down?” and “This is illegible – 15 points off” outnumbered any notes on what I’d actually written. I got a C- on my first To Kill a Mockingbird essay, but scribbled in the margin, between doodles of flowers and stick figures, I’d written that Atticus wasn’t some perfect hero – he was just a guy who was sad and tired and knew he couldn’t win but went anyway. It was a better observation than most 15-year-olds I teach now come up with, and it never got counted. It never even got acknowledged.
I’d forgotten that I’d convinced myself I was bad at English by 10th grade. I almost dropped the advanced level course because all I ever heard was that I was doing it wrong. I’m a 7th grade English teacher now, and until I found that workbook, I didn’t realize how often I do the same thing to kids like me.
Last semester, I had a student named Javi who turned in every assignment half-complete, with scrawled handwriting and no pre-writing packet attached. I gave him C after C, and marked him as a kid who didn’t try, until I flipped through my old workbook one night after grading and saw my own messy handwriting staring back. The next day, I pulled Javi’s essay aside and read it without looking at the missing packet or the smudged ink first. He wrote a response to The Giver about release, and connected it to his grandma, who has dementia and lives in a nursing home two hours away. His family doesn’t talk about her much anymore, he wrote, and it feels like she’s already been released. It was raw, honest, and the most thoughtful essay I read that entire month. It would have gotten a higher grade if I’d bothered to read it before penalizing him for the missing parts.
I called Javi over after class and we talked. He told me he processes fast, and by the time he gets out a graphic organizer and fills in all the boxes, he forgets what he wanted to say. His hand gets tired from writing all the little bullet points, and it just feels like a waste of time. I’d always assumed kids who skipped pre-writing were just lazy, but that’s what I thought about myself 25 years ago too.
We made a deal. Instead of filling out the full three-page graphic organizer for every essay, Javi can write three quick bullet points on the back of his prompt to show he has a plan. If he forgets, he just loses 5 points on the process part of his grade, not 20 points off his whole score. It’s a small change, and it’s one any parent or teacher can make without rewriting the whole curriculum. I’ve started doing three small things differently now, all from that old workbook. First, I always separate points for process skills (neatness, pre-writing, following formatting rules) from points for critical thinking and ideas. A kid doesn’t fail an entire assignment because they forgot the header, or don’t want to fill out a pre-write. Second, when I talk to a kid about their work at home or in class, I always ask one question about their idea before I mention anything that’s wrong or missing. Instead of starting with “Fix your handwriting”, I start with “You said the main character was wrong to lie – why do you think that?” Third, I ask kids what works for them, instead of making everyone follow the same set of rules. If you can plan an essay in your head and still turn in good work, you don’t have to write every step down on paper.
Javi’s average is a B+ now, and he volunteers to read his work out loud to the class every chance he gets. He never would have done that six months ago.
I keep my old workbook on my desk at school now, tucked between my lesson plan book and a stack of student essays. I still mess up sometimes – last week I caught myself writing “slow down” in the margin of a kid’s paper before I realized what I was doing. I crossed it out and wrote “cool point – expand on this” instead. It doesn’t fix every learning struggle, and it doesn’t work for every kid. Some kids really do need the structure of a full graphic organizer, and some need to work on their handwriting to make their work readable. But it’s a small shift that makes room for the kids who think faster than they can write, who care more about the idea than the presentation, who would get written off before anyone ever sees what they can do. I still wonder what would have changed for me if someone had done that for me 25 years ago.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Found In My Old Secondary School English Workbook Changed How I Support Fast, Messy Learners