What I Changed About My Classes This Year (And Small Shifts That Cut Classroom Disruptions)
8:15 a.m. on the first day of school, my coffee mug with the chip in the rim and a permanent coffee stain on the side is sweating in my hand, I’m greeting kids by the door when Milo trips over the edge of the reading rug. His backpack unzips before he can catch it, and seven bright blue rubber band cars go rolling every which way, under desks, past my feet, stopping right by the class snake plant. The whole room goes quiet. Last year, I would have smiled tight, told Milo to hurry and pick them up, reminded him toys stay in cubbies on school days, and the moment would have ended with him red-faced, slumping into his seat for the next hour. This year, I knelt down, grabbed the closest car, and twirled the wheel between my fingers. “Whoa, these look way faster than the ones I had when I was your age,” I said. “Milo, can you leave one out to show everyone at recess after morning meeting, and we’ll get the rest picked up quick?” He stared at me for a second, then grinned and started grabbing them.
This year’s classes look nothing like I planned when I started teaching third grade seven years ago. Last year, I followed the district’s block schedule to the minute: 90 uninterrupted minutes of reading, 60 minutes of math, 15 minutes of recess, 25 minutes of social studies, no in-between. I assigned seats to keep talkers separated and fidgeters up front where I could see them. I had a strict no-toys rule, no getting up without permission, and by October I was sending an average of four kids a week to the office for disrupting class. I went home every night with a throbbing headache, wondering why I couldn’t get my class under control like the other teachers down the hall. Over the summer, I sat with Ms. Rita, our school counselor who’s been here longer than I’ve been alive, and I complained about it. She didn’t give me any fancy new curriculum or a 20-step behavior plan. She just stirred her iced tea and said, “Most of the time when kids act out, they’re not trying to make your life hard. Their brains are just asking for something you aren’t giving ‘em.” That stuck with me, so I made three small, free changes to my classes this year, and six weeks in, things are already different.
First, I added 10-minute unstructured movement checks every 45 minutes, instead of only letting kids move once before lunch. I don’t make them do jumping jacks or follow a yoga video, I just dim the lights and tell ‘em they can do whatever they want as long as no one’s getting bothered. They can walk around the room, get a drink of water, doodle at their desk, spin in their chair, even play with a small toy if they brought one. I was worried this would eat into instructional time, but I’ve noticed we waste far less time now than we did before, when I’d have to stop three or four times a block to remind someone to sit still and stop tapping their pencil. After that first day, Milo keeps one rubber band car in his desk, and he pulls it out during movement checks to race with Javi across the front table, then puts it away when we start again. He’s only been sent to the office once so far this year, for accidentally knocking over the water fountain, and that was nothing.
Second, I got rid of assigned seats for most of the day. Last year, I thought assigned seats were the only way to keep order. All it did was make the talkers pass notes under the table and fidgeters slump lower and lower in their chairs, counting down the minutes until recess. Now, at the start of every work block, kids pick their spot: a regular desk, a bean bag in the reading corner, or a standing table by the window. If they can’t focus where they are, they get up and move. I only step in if three people end up together and all they do is giggle. The first week, all the boys crowded the standing table and messed around so much none of them finished their math worksheet. I almost took the table away. Instead, I just said, “Tomorrow, if you can’t get your work done here, you have to try a different spot.” Two of them moved to bean bags the next day, one stayed and finished his work on time. Now, the kids who can’t sit still stand the whole block, the kids who like to curl up with a chapter book pile into the bean bags, and the kids who prefer a hard surface sit at their desks. It’s quieter most days than my assigned-seat room was last year.
Third, I put out a no-questions-asked calm down bin by the door. I didn’t fill it with fancy therapy tools, just stuff I had around my house: three stress balls, a few pop-its, colored pencils and scrap paper, and a tattered picture book about pugs that my own kid outgrew. Any time a kid feels their brain is too loud, they can get up, grab something from the bin, and sit on the small bench by the door for up to three minutes, no explanation needed. Before, if a kid got upset mid-lesson, I’d stop everything to talk to them, or send them all the way down to the counselor’s office, which made the whole class lose their focus and the kid feel embarrassed. Last week, Lila came in from recess crying because she messed up her spelling test and thought she’d never get a good grade. She just went to the bench, colored a big pink flower, came back three minutes later, and asked to do her retake. She didn’t want a big talk, she just needed a minute to breathe.
These shifts work just as well at home as they do in the classroom, if you have a kid who fights homework or gets frustrated easily. You don’t have to rearrange your whole house or buy new gear to try them. Next time your kid is wiggling through 45 minutes of homework, let them get up and walk around the block or shoot a couple baskets in the driveway before coming back. If they hate sitting at the dining table, let them do their reading on the couch or work standing at the kitchen counter. If they’re upset and won’t open up, don’t push them to talk right away—give them three minutes with a fidget or a piece of paper to draw on before you check in.
It’s not perfect. Some days are still chaotic. Last week, the principal came in for an observation, and during movement check-in someone stuck a neon sticky note that said “I LOVE DOGS” on her back when she wasn’t looking. I still have to remind kids to move spots if they’re just messing around, and I still get home tired some nights. I don’t have this all figured out, and some kids still struggle more than others—we’re just taking it week by week. But this year, the noise in my room is different. It’s not the jittery, tense noise that made my jaw hurt at the end of the day last year. It’s kids talking about their books, laughing, moving when they need to. Last Friday, Milo stayed after to help me tape up new labels for the book shelf, and he told me this is the first class he’s ever liked where he didn’t feel like he was in trouble all the time. That’s enough for me, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Changed About My Classes This Year (And Small Shifts That Cut Classroom Disruptions)