What Happens When Your Rule-Following Child Grows Up: A Parent’s Story and Tips
I’m sitting in a scuffed plastic folding chair outside my 10th grader’s biology classroom, the air smelling like lemon floor wax and the popcorn the PTA sold at last night’s game, when her teacher pulls out her grade book and says something that stops me cold. “Lila won’t deviate from what she thinks is the ‘right’ way to do an assignment, even when she’s clearly smarter than the unwritten rule we’re working with here.”
I think back immediately to when Lila was little. At four, she was the kid who’d turn down a cookie at playgroup because the host said “one after snack” and it was only 10 a.m. In kindergarten, she refused to take her art project home because she’d colored outside the lines once, and she was sure the teacher would mark it wrong. My husband and I bragged about her, honestly. We’d tell friends “We never have to remind her to do her homework, she never talks back to teachers, she always holds the door like she’s supposed to.” We thought we’d hit the parenting jackpot: a rule-following kid meant no late nights, no tense parent-teacher calls, no stress. What we didn’t see was that the same habit that made our lives easy was starting to trap her.
The first crack was seventh grade, with a group project on climate change. She came home from school, threw her backpack on the kitchen floor, and cried for 20 minutes. The other two kids in her group hadn’t done any of the work they’d promised. Lila wouldn’t email the teacher to tell her, because the rule was “group work means every member does their part” and she decided it was her fault for not making them follow through. She ended up doing the whole project herself, staying up until 11 p.m. to finish it, and still got a B because she rushed the conclusion. When I asked her why she didn’t say something, she just shrugged and said “What if the teacher thinks I’m a bad group member?”
That’s when I started connecting the dots. When kids are little, school and home are full of clear, non-negotiable rules: hold my hand in the parking lot, don’t run in the hall, follow the lines on the worksheet. Rule-following kids get praised nonstop for that behavior, so it becomes their default way of moving through the world. But as they get older, the rules get fuzzy. Assignments ask for your opinion instead of a textbook answer. Group projects require navigating other people who don’t care as much about the rules as you do. Plans change last minute, and there’s no written guide for what to do next. A kid who’s spent their whole life being rewarded for following every rule exactly doesn’t know how to handle that fuzziness.
We started making small, low-effort changes, nothing dramatic. First, we built low-stakes rule breaks into our monthly routine. Nothing dangerous, just silly, small stuff. One Sunday a month, we eat dessert first before dinner. When we play board games now, we take turns making up a new rule that no one’s ever used before, and we play a full round with it. If it’s bad, we change it again. It sounds trivial, but it got Lila used to the idea that changing a rule doesn’t mean the whole thing falls apart. At first she hated it, she’d say “that’s not how you play Codenames” and cross her arms. Now she’s the one who suggests the silly new rules half the time.
Second, when she comes to me stuck because a rule isn’t working for her, I don’t just say “it’s okay to bend the rule.” I ask her to write down three bad things that will actually happen if she does it the way she’s scared to. After that first disastrous group project, the next time she had a similar problem, we did this exercise. She wrote down “teacher will be mad, my friends will hate me, I’ll fail the class.” We went through each one point by point: how many times has a teacher gotten mad at you for asking for help? Never. Is it more likely your friends just don’t care about the grade as much as you, not that they’ll hate you forever? Yeah. What’s the actual lowest grade you can get here, even if it goes bad? A C, which you’ve gotten before and it didn’t ruin your transcript. Then we role played what she’d say to the teacher before she sent the email, so it didn’t feel like a big, scary unknown. That works far better than just telling her to speak up.
After the 10th grade parent-teacher conference, we talked about the midterm question over tacos that night. She’d gotten five points off because the question asked for her conclusion on her lab experiment, and she’d just copied the textbook’s definition of the concept. When I asked her what she really thought, she said she’d known the sample they used was contaminated, which was exactly what the teacher wanted to see. I didn’t tell her she should have ignored the textbook entirely. I just said “Next time, write the textbook answer first, like you’re supposed to, then add your thought at the end. That way you follow the rule you think you have to follow, and the teacher still sees what you figured out. It’s not breaking any rules, it’s just adding something extra.” That small middle ground made it way less scary for her than saying “just do it your way.”
Lila is 16 now, and she’s still the most rule-following kid I know. She still gets mad when people cut in line at the coffee shop, she still lays out her outfit for school the night before, and she reminds her 10-year-old cousin to hold my hand when we cross the street. That’s not a flaw. We never wanted to fix her, just give her more tools. Last month, she planned a group hike for PE, made a three-page itinerary with water stops and emergency contacts, and when half the group wanted to take a different scenic trail, she didn’t throw the itinerary away or shut down. She flipped to the back, added the new route, and everyone had a good time.
It’s still a work in progress. She’ll still get stressed when a test has a question that doesn’t have a clear right answer, and she’ll still knock on my bedroom door after dinner to work through it. But she’s getting better at seeing that most rules are guides, not cages. That’s enough for us, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Your Rule-Following Child Grows Up: A Parent’s Story and Tips