What Happens When Your District Wants to Close Your Public School to Cover Admin Building Overspending
It was 7:12 p.m. at last month’s PTA meeting, and I was perched on a cracked blue folding chair in Maplewood Elementary’s gym, my jeans still sticky from the cherry lollipop my second-grader Lila had pressed into my hand before I left the house. The air smelled like burnt popcorn and the lemon floor wax the custodian has used since I attended school here 30 years ago. The district’s chief financial officer clicked to his 17th budget slide, and the room went quiet: “Recommended FY25 cost-saving measure: permanent closure of Maplewood Elementary, effective end of the current school year.”
A dad who coaches my fourth-grader Javi’s rec soccer team raised his hand first. We passed an $18 million operating levy two years ago, he pointed out, specifically to keep neighborhood elementaries open and cap class sizes. Where was the $2.1 million annual gap coming from? The CFO mumbled something about unplanned capital cost overruns, and a grandmother who’s volunteered in the library for 12 years called from the back: “Unplanned my ass. That’s your $29 million admin building you couldn’t afford. You blew seven million extra on granite lobbies and a gated executive parking lot, and now our kids are paying for it.” The room erupted so loud the old referee whistle in storage clattered off its hook.
I walked the kids to school the next morning the same way I always do, up Oak Street past the bodega that gives out free apple slices before class. Mabel, our crossing guard of 19 years, handed Lila a unicorn sticker like she does every Friday, and I stopped by Javi’s special education classroom to touch base with his case manager, Ms. Lopez. She already had three parent emails in her inbox, all asking the same question: what happens to IEPs, small-group reading support, and the weekend food bags we send home with food-insecure kids if the school closes? The district’s presentation claimed all services would “transfer seamlessly” to the elementary 20 minutes across town, but that school already has three overflow portables and 28 kids per general ed class. No one could say for sure if aide positions would move, or if the before-school program would have space for our 120 participating kids.
A dozen of us lingered in the parking lot after the meeting, drinking gas station iced coffee while someone pulled public budget records up on their phone. The district voted to reallocate $7 million from elementary operating and facilities budgets to cover the admin building overruns two years prior, with no required public comment period. Enrollment at Maplewood is down 12 students in three years, out of 420 total, which the district uses to justify closure. It’s not about low enrollment, one PTA board member said. It’s about balancing the budget on schools that serve the highest share of low-income and neurodivergent kids, because they assume we won’t fight back.
What the budget slides never account for is all the small, unmeasurable stuff kids rely on, especially kids who don’t handle change well. Javi is autistic, and it took him 18 months of kindergarten to stop having 20-minute meltdowns before school every morning. He knows exactly what to expect here: the water fountain by the gym that’s always the coldest, the fidget bin by Ms. Lopez’s door he can dig through without asking, the scuffed wooden bench by the office where he sits for five minutes when the lunchroom gets too loud. His occupational therapist told us once that kids who struggle with flexibility don’t learn to roll with change by being forced into big, sudden shifts. They build comfort with small new experiences because they have one stable, predictable place to come back to. That place, for Javi, is this school.
I’ve talked to half a dozen parents who went through west side school closures two years ago, and the most common first mistake they made was dumping all their adult stress on kids before anything was even decided. I almost did it myself, the night of the meeting: I was ready to sit both kids down for a big serious talk about budgets and unfair choices, until a friend who teaches kindergarten talked me out of it. Kids don’t need the whole picture, she said. They only need answers to the questions they actually ask.
Lila ended up overhearing me on the phone a couple days later, and asked straight out if her school was going away. I didn’t lie and say it was impossible, and I didn’t rant about admin overspending to a seven-year-old. I just said, “Some people are talking about that right now. A bunch of us are working really hard to keep the school open, and if anything does change, we’ll go visit your new classroom and meet your new teacher together before you ever have to go.” That was all she needed. She ran off to color a dinosaur picture 30 seconds later.
Javi found out from a kid on the bus, and came home quiet that afternoon, shutting his bedroom door instead of dumping his backpack on the couch like usual. I didn’t knock and force a big conversation about feelings. I grabbed his favorite cheese puffs and a blue Gatorade, brought them to his desk, and sat on the floor sorting his Lego bin while he built a spaceship for 40 minutes before he spoke. What he worried about wasn’t new friends or a longer bus ride. It was whether Ms. Lopez would still be there to help him with long division. We pulled out a spiral notebook that night, wrote every worry he could name one per line, and mapped out what we could control. We emailed Ms. Lopez together from my phone after dinner, and she wrote back 10 minutes later saying she’s already put in for a transfer to the receiving school if closure goes through, and she’ll track him down the first day of class no matter what. That one specific answer calmed him more than any generic “it’ll all work out” ever could have.
One thing that’s surprised me is how much keeping our normal routine matters, even with all the extra meetings and late nights going over budget documents. A mom I know whose daughter’s school closed in 2022 stopped volunteering in class, picked up takeout four nights a week, and spent most after-school time on advocacy calls for months leading up to the move. Her first-grader started having potty accidents and hitting peers at recess, and their pediatrician said it wasn’t the closure itself causing stress yet—it was that all the small, predictable parts of daily life had already disappeared, before anyone cast a final vote. So I take all my advocacy calls in the car after dropoff, fold petition flyers after the kids go to bed, and keep every small ritual we’ve always had: the Wednesday donut hole from the PTA bake sale, the walk to school, stopping to see the class hamster every morning. Nothing changes for them until it actually has to.
We’re not rolling over, of course. We have more than 1,300 signatures on our petition to pause the closure, three local news outlets have covered the admin building overspending, and parent lawyers found the district violated state open meetings rules when they reallocated the money without public notice. The school board vote is in three weeks, and we’re packing the room. But that’s adult work. It doesn’t need to take over the kids’ days, or turn the school they love into a source of stress before we even know the outcome.
Last Thursday, I volunteered for reading groups, and one of Lila’s classmates asked if the class hamster would have to move too if the school closed. His teacher didn’t brush him off or tell him not to worry about grown-up stuff. She said, “If we move, the hamster gets a bigger new cage, and I still take him home with me every holiday, just like I do now. He’ll never be on his own.” That feels like the right approach: fight hard for the place that matters, but don’t forget to answer the small, real questions kids actually have.
Some days I drive past that shiny new admin building, all glass and half-empty parking spots, and I’m convinced the board will vote to close us no matter what we show them. Other days I stand in the hallway before school, watching kids high-five the custodian and trade stickers with Mabel and run to their classrooms like they own the place, and I think we can win. For now, the water fountain by the gym still runs cold. The weekend food bags still get packed every Friday. Javi still knows exactly where to find the fidget bin when he needs it. That’s enough for today.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Your District Wants to Close Your Public School to Cover Admin Building Overspending