What Happens When Your Always Rule-Following Kid Grows Up: Practical Parenting Tips
I turned off the car in our driveway last fall and turned to find my 13-year-old Lila hunched over her phone, shoulders shaking so hard her sparkly dance top slipped off one shoulder. She’d left her first middle school dance 45 minutes early, and when I asked what happened, she blurted out that her best friend had snuck a vape into the bathroom. When the vice principal stopped them and asked who’d brought it, Lila told the truth. Now everyone in their friend group was calling her a snitch, and no one would text her back.
That’s just how Lila has always been. When she was 5, she refused to color outside the lines in her preschool art project because the teacher said stay inside the lines. At 8, she turned a $2 bill she found on the playground in to the office, even when her friend at the time suggested they split it for gummy bears. For years, I counted this as a win. I’d listen to other parents complain about their kids lying about homework, sneaking candy into the movie theater, or cutting class, and I’d breathe a quiet sigh of relief that I had the easy kid: the rule follower, the one who never caused trouble.
I didn’t stop to think about what that tendency would look like once she outgrew elementary school, where every rule is written clearly on a poster board and adults reward you every time you follow it. By middle school, most kids start testing boundaries, pushing back against adult rules to figure out who they are. But for Lila, breaking a rule—even a silly unwritten social one—still feels like a failure. After the dance, she kept repeating “I did what I was supposed to do. Why is this my fault?” and I realized I’d spent years reinforcing the idea that following the rules is always the right choice, never teaching her how to handle the messy gray areas that come with being a teenager.
A couple of weeks after the dance, we had another example: her math teacher graded a unit test and accidentally gave Lila three extra points, pushing her score to an A- that would qualify her for advanced math next semester. Lila noticed the mistake after class, pointed it out, and left with a B+ that kept her off the advanced list. She came home upset, kicking the front door, and said she knew she did the right thing but couldn’t stop feeling like an idiot for saying something. That’s when I knew I needed to stop just patting her on the back and start doing something different.
First, I stopped opening with “you did the right thing” every time she came to me with a sticky situation. Instead, I started asking one specific question first: “What are all the options you could have chosen here, not just the one you picked?” After the math test, that question led her to say she could have waited until the semester ended to say something, or talked to the teacher privately and asked if she could still keep her spot because she knew the material anyway. She’d never even considered those options, because her default was “the rule says grades have to be accurate, so you have to say something immediately.” Asking that question doesn’t push her to choose one way or the other—it just helps her see there are more than two options most of the time.
I also started bringing up low-stakes ambiguous situations at dinner once a week, just to practice. Nothing big, just small stuff that comes up for middle schoolers: “If your friend forgot their lunch ticket, and the cafeteria rule says you can’t share yours, what would you do?” or “If your coach says everyone has to run two laps, but your friend twisted their ankle and doesn’t want to tell the coach because they don’t want to sit out, would you say something?” These conversations take five minutes, they don’t feel like a lecture, and they help her practice thinking through trade-offs before she’s caught in a high-pressure moment with her friends.
I also changed how I praise her. For years, I’d automatically say “I’m so proud of you for being such a good kid who follows the rules.” Now, I name the specific value I’m proud of, instead of tying it to rule-following. When she stayed after school to help her friend study for a quiz, I said “I really love how you showed up for her when she was stressed” instead of praising her for being good. When she does the right thing that breaks a small rule, I acknowledge that too—last month she snuck an extra cookie from our neighbor’s holiday cookie platter and gave it to the little kid next door who was upset after falling off his bike, and I told her that was a kind choice, even if it broke the “one per person” rule.
It’s not a fixed thing yet. Just last week, she got upset because our neighbor brought her tiny therapy dog to the playground, even though the city sign says no dogs allowed, and Lila kept hovering like she needed to go tell the park ranger. Her default is still to reach for the clearest rule first. But last month, she handled a group project where her teammates slacked off by talking to them directly instead of going straight to the teacher to report them. She came home and told me she wasn’t sure if she did the right thing, but it felt better than getting them in trouble right away.
That’s enough for me right now. She’s still learning, and I’m still learning with her. Rule-following isn’t a flaw, it’s a trait that will serve her well in a lot of ways. But it’s our job to help them see that the world doesn’t fit into a neat list of rules forever, no matter how much we wish it did.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Your Always Rule-Following Kid Grows Up: Practical Parenting Tips