What Happens When Your Always Rule-Following Child Grows Up: A Parent’s Perspective and Realistic Tips
Last Tuesday, I stood in the high school main office waiting while my 17-year-old Lila talked herself into a panic over a missing late pass. She’d biked in through a sudden rainstorm, got a flat tire two blocks from school, and was 8 minutes late to first period. She’d left the extra printed late pass I made her taped to her bike helmet, back by the rack where she locked up. The office admin smiled and told her a dozen times it was fine, just sign the late sheet and head to class. But Lila kept leaning against the counter, twisting her rain-soaked sleeve, and repeating that the student handbook explicitly requires a pass for unplanned lateness, and she didn’t have one, and what if she got marked down on her attendance record that colleges look at?
I’ve seen this panic before, going all the way back to when she was 5 in preschool. She’d stop mid-snack to correct the boy who was coloring on the table instead of his paper, and tell the teacher he’d broken the rule. At 8, she refused to leave three blank math problems on her homework even when she had a 101 degree fever and I told her I’d write a note excusing her. Every teacher adored her. I’d leave parent-teacher conferences glowing, hearing over and over what a joy she is, how I must be such a lucky mom to have such a compliant kid. I bought it, for a long time. I thought rule-following was just a good kid trait, something to be grateful for.
It clicked when she was 12. She came home from art class, locked herself in her bathroom, and cried for an hour. The assignment said “color within the lines to create a landscape” and she’d accidentally slipped and colored a stripe of blue outside the tree line. Her teacher told her it was fine, even said the stripe looked like a river and made the piece more interesting. But Lila wouldn’t be consoled. She’d broken the directions. I talked to her elementary school counselor after that, and she said it’s super common for kids who are naturally rule-following, or who’ve been praised for compliance their whole lives, to struggle with uncertainty as they get older. No one warns you that the trait everyone celebrates can turn into a barrier when they hit middle and high school, when all of a sudden they’re expected to make choices that don’t have clear right or wrong answers.
Last year, she had to pick a final project for AP Biology. The options were a traditional lab report with a clear 10-point rubric, or a self-directed documentary on invasive species in our local wetland. She talked for weeks about the documentary—how she wanted to wade through the cattails and film the phragmites that are pushing out the native plants, interview the park ranger she’d met on a hike last summer. But in the end, she picked the lab report. “The rules are clear,” she said. “I know exactly what I need to do to get an A.” She got the A, but she moped for three days after she turned it in, said she didn’t even care about the enzyme question she’d spent a month testing.
I started making small changes, nothing big, because I didn’t want to push her into something that would make her anxiety worse. The first thing I did was start adding tiny, low-stakes rule breaks into our everyday routine, to help her practice bending the rules without real risk. When we go to the grocery store, I’ll grab two grapes off the bunch and hand her one before we pay. At first, she’d hand it back, wide-eyed, saying you can’t do that. Now she laughs and eats it, and teases me for being a criminal. When we go to the movie theater, I’ll suggest we sneak in a pack of her favorite sour gum from the gas station, even though the door sign says no outside food. These are all tiny, no-harm rules that don’t hurt anyone, just arbitrary stuff most people follow out of habit. It gives her a safe space to practice that the world doesn’t end when you don’t follow every little unwritten rule.
Another small shift I made: I stopped asking her “what do you think they want you to do” when she’s facing a choice, and started asking “what do you want to do first.” Before that, her first answer was always whatever the rules or other people expected. Now, she pauses, and actually thinks about it. After the late pass incident last week, when we walked out of the office, I didn’t just tell her it was fine. I asked her “what do you want to do right now? The admin said you can go straight to class. You can also stay here and fill out another pass if that makes you feel better. What do you want?” She stared at me for a second, then said “I want to go get a chocolate milk from the cafeteria before first period.” That was a win, small as it was.
I also stopped praising her for being “good” or “following the rules.” Now I name it when she takes a risk, even if it doesn’t work out. Last semester, she tried out for the school play even though she’d never acted before, and she didn’t get a part. When she came home, I didn’t just brush it off. I said “I thought it was really cool that you signed up when none of your friends were trying out. That took a lot more guts than getting a perfect score on a test.”
It’s not like this has fixed everything. She still won’t take a free pastry on her shift at the local coffee shop, even though her manager explicitly posts that all staff get one per shift. She still says it feels like stealing, and I don’t push her. She still defaults to the safest, most rule-following option more often than not, and that’s okay. A lot of that is just her personality, and there are good parts to it—she’s reliable, people trust her, she’ll never do something reckless just to fit in.
I don’t think we’re ever going to get to a point where she’s a total risk-taker who throws all the rules out the window, and that’s fine. The point isn’t to turn a rule-following kid into a rebel. It’s just to help them feel safe enough to make their own choices, even when there’s no clear rule telling them what to do. Right now, that’s enough for us. We’re still working on it, one stolen grocery store grape at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Your Always Rule-Following Child Grows Up: A Parent’s Perspective and Realistic Tips