What Happens When Marching Band Counts For Full PE Credit: A Florida Teacher And Parent’s View
The grass crunches under my sneakers as I lean against the chain link fence outside the high school football stadium, waiting for my daughter Lila to finish packing up her sousaphone after Friday night’s game. It’s mid-September, and the air still holds that sticky Florida humidity that leaves your shirt sticking to your back an hour after the sun goes down. When she finally emerges, her uniform jacket is tied around her waist, her socks are smudged with mud, and there’s a new blister the size of a quarter peeking out over the top of her right boot. She drops the 25-pound instrument case at my feet and groans, “Today we ran through the entire halftime show four times. I’m pretty sure I walked seven miles today.” This year, for the first time, that seven miles counts for more than just a first-place trophy at this weekend’s competition: it counts for her full high school PE credit.
Before the new rule passed, marching band only counted for half a PE credit in our district. That meant Lila, a junior, had to add an extra online PE course on top of three AP classes, 20 hours a week of band rehearsals, and her part-time shift at the local coffee shop. The online class required a 20-minute logged physical activity every day, signed off by a parent. More nights than I can count, she’d get home at 6:30, eat dinner, crank out three hours of homework, then remember at 10 p.m. she hadn’t filled out her log. She’d trudge around the block by herself just to check the box, even though she’d already spent three hours on her feet at rehearsal that day.
I saw how physically demanding band was first hand this past summer at band camp. I dropped her off at 8 a.m. every day for two weeks, when the heat index hit 105 by noon most days. The director builds in water breaks every 20 minutes, but the kids are on their feet moving the entire day. I picked her up one afternoon and she was asleep in the backseat before we hit the first stop light. After the first week, she told me she couldn’t walk up the stairs to her bedroom without stopping halfway to catch her breath, her quads were so sore. She gained three pounds of muscle by the end of the two weeks, and she didn’t touch a weight machine once.
I’ve heard the pushback from other parents and teachers around the state, since the rule passed. Some say PE is meant to teach a range of fitness skills, and that marching band is just an extracurricular, not a replacement for a structured class. As a middle school PE teacher myself, I get where that concern comes from. But I also know what actually happens in most large high school PE classes. I’ve taught 9th grade PE with 35 kids in a gym, and when we run a basketball unit, at least 15 kids are standing on the sideline waiting for a turn for most of the period. On average, most kids get less than 10 minutes of actual moderate to vigorous activity in a 50-minute class. Lila gets two to three hours of moving every single day in band. That’s way more consistent activity than she’d ever get in a standard semester PE.
I was talking to another dad at the game last week, Mike, whose son plays trombone. He told me he always bought into the idea that band was “just standing around playing music” until he came to parent preview day at band camp. He marched one 8-count set holding his son’s trombone, and was winded after five minutes. “I walk 18 holes of golf every weekend,” he told me. “That was harder than a full round.” It’s hard to argue with that. The new rule’s lead sponsor put it plainly when the bill passed: marching band is as physical as some sports, and it’s past time we counted it that way.
For parents and teachers in other states who are interested in a similar change, there are concrete small steps you can take, not just going to a school board meeting empty handed. Most districts already have a policy that allows PE credit substitution for approved extracurricular activities; most people just never think to apply it to band. Ask your band director to pull together a simple one-page breakdown that lists weekly activity hours, the physical demands of holding instruments, moving through formations, and the conditioning they already do at the start of every rehearsal. Most directors already have this information for recruiting and fundraising, so it just takes a little rearranging to present to your district. For parents of band kids, regardless of credit rules, there’s a simple adjustment you can make right now: treat the physical strain like any other sport. Buy them a pair of supportive, properly fitted marching shoes instead of letting them wear worn-out casual sneakers. Remind them to stretch their shoulders and calves before rehearsal, same as you’d remind a soccer player. If they complain about consistent shin pain or back soreness, take them to get it checked out instead of writing it off as just part of being in band. Overuse injuries are just as common in marching band as they are in cross country or soccer.
The rule is still new in Florida, and no one’s sorted out all the kinks yet. Smaller schools with smaller marching programs that don’t require 20 hours a week of rehearsal are still figuring out how it works for them, and there are questions about how it applies to kids who do band and another varsity sport. It’s not a perfect solution, and it won’t work for every district.
For our family, though, the change is small but noticeable. Lila dropped that unnecessary online PE class this semester and swapped it for a pottery class she’s been wanting to take for two years. Last week, she got home at 6:30, ate dinner, finished her AP Bio homework, and instead of tramping around the block to log a walk, she sat on the back porch with her little sister and ate popsicles while they watched the fireflies. It’s just 20 extra minutes a day, but it’s one less box for an overloaded kid to check. We’ll see how the rule shakes out over the next few years, if other states pick up the idea, if any of the kinks get ironed out. For now, I’m just happy I don’t have to sign a weekly stack of walking logs anymore, and my kid gets a little more time to do the things that don’t count for any credit at all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When Marching Band Counts For Full PE Credit: A Florida Teacher And Parent’s View