What Happens When A Student Says They Don’t Have ID For Their Exam: A Teacher’s Perspective
It’s 8:15 a.m. on state midterm day, and the line of 10th graders stretches down the gym hallway. Fluorescent lights hum, exam booklets crinkle in proctors’ arms, and kids shift from foot to foot, scrolling last-minute study notes on their phones. When Mia gets to the front of my line, she unzips her backpack, zips it closed again, and digs through the frayed front pocket until her cheeks turn bright pink. “I don’t have my ID,” she says, quiet enough only I can hear it. “I can’t find it anywhere.”
The district memo we got last week is clear: no physical student ID, no testing. Kids have to take the make-up exam a week later, no exceptions. The retired teacher filling in as my extra proctor nods and says, “Sorry, kid, head to the office for a temp and come back next week.”
I’ve had Mia in my class for two semesters. She turned in a 10-page research paper on urban reforestation last week, stayed after class for 20 minutes to ask follow-up questions about citations, and told me once she studies for exams between customer orders at the coffee shop where she works 20 hours a week to help her mom pay rent. I step in and ask her to step into the hallway with me, so we aren’t holding up the line of antsy kids behind her.
She tells me she lost her phone on the bus ride in, and she’d taped her student ID to the back of the case. She checked lost and found, called the bus company, checked her locker twice, and turned up empty. She’d studied three hours every night after work for two weeks for this exam, which counts for 20% of her final grade. She’s not crying, just presses her thumbnail into the side of her hand over and over. “I know it’s my fault,” she says.
I call the office to ask how long a temp ID will take, and the secretary sighs and says there are 11 other kids already waiting for replacements. It’ll be at least an hour, by which point the exam will be halfway over. I pull up my digital class roster on my phone— I keep photos there for substitute teachers— and tap Mia’s student profile. It’s obviously her, same messy bun, same small scar above her eyebrow she got falling off her bike in middle school. I call the district test coordinator, explain the situation, and offer to sign a legal verification form confirming her identity, on my professional responsibility. They agree to let her test. She sits down, pulls out her pencils, and gets to work.
This isn’t the first time this has happened. Last semester, three different kids forgot or lost their IDs before midterms. My own 13-year-old son forgot his ID for his district science exam last month, and almost got a zero because his teacher wouldn’t budge on the rule. As a teacher and a parent, I’ve noticed we almost always default to framing this as a character issue: if they cared enough, they would have remembered. If they were organized, they wouldn’t lose it. They deserve the consequence, because it teaches them responsibility.
But that’s not what’s actually going on. The part of the brain that handles working memory and keeps track of small, rarely used items doesn’t finish maturing until our mid-20s. A 16-year-old can memorize 50 vocab words, keep track of their work schedule, and remember to pick up their little sibling from elementary school every day, but that one extra thing— an ID they only pull out twice a semester for exams— can slip right out of their active memory. Add that most teens carry everything in one overstuffed backpack, lose things constantly, and it’s not a failure of character. It’s just normal development.
Over the past couple of years, I’ve worked out small, concrete fixes that keep kids from getting punished for a common mistake, without breaking school rules. For teachers, keep a printed photo roster for your class at every exam check-in. It takes two minutes to print the night before, and lets you confirm a kid’s identity in 10 seconds when they lose their ID. If your office is backlogged, walk the kid down for a temp ID yourself instead of sending them alone; standing in a long line when you’re already panicked about missing your exam just adds unnecessary stress that ruins their performance before they even sit down. For parents, keep a spare student ID taped to the inside back panel of your kid’s main backpack. It doesn’t get pulled out when they’re grabbing books or lunch, and it’s always there if they lose the one they carry with them. The night before any big exam or field trip, do a 30-second verbal check: “Got your pencils? Your ticket? Your ID?” It’s not hovering. It’s building a routine that their still-developing brains haven’t learned to do automatically.
After the exam, Mia stopped by my classroom after school. She’d picked up her temporary ID from the office, and brought me a free chocolate chip cookie from the coffee shop where she works. She said she thought she got at least a B, which was what she was aiming for, and thanked me for not sending her away. I thought about that later: the consequence of missing the exam wouldn’t have taught her to be more responsible. It would have just wasted two weeks of hard work, and left her feeling like the system doesn’t care about anything but following rules.
I’m still working with our school admin to add a school-wide photo roster check for all official exam days next year. It’s a tiny change, no extra cost, no extra work really, but it would cut down on the number of kids punished for a simple mistake. Last week I forgot my own teacher ID when I came to work, and had to get a visitor sticker to get through the front door. It happens to all of us, even when we’re supposed to have it all together. Right now, that’s as far as I’ve gotten. Some rules bend, some don’t, but we can keep chipping away at the small stuff.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A Student Says They Don’t Have ID For Their Exam: A Teacher’s Perspective