What happens when a school runs amok: Why principals should answer parents at public town halls
I was leaning against a rusted guardrail outside my daughter’s middle school last October, holding a lukewarm lemonade I’d grabbed on the way from work, when Lila pushed through the crowd of 7th graders with her math notebook torn down the spine and a long frayed rip along the sleeve of her hoodie. A fight broke out between two girls in third period, she said. Ms. Henderson tried to pull them apart, yelled for admin over the intercom three times. No one showed up for almost 15 minutes. By the time a vice principal got there, the room was half turned over, and someone had slammed Lila’s notebook into a desk when they were rushing out.
That wasn’t the first incident. Two weeks before, Lila’s locker had been jammed with chewing gum, and the office said they’d get to it before spring. The month before that, her friend’s AirPods were stolen out of an unlocked locker during PE, and the office said they didn’t have time to pull camera footage because the front office was short-staffed. We went to the fall PTA meeting, sat through 25 minutes of the principal talking about the new pumpkin patch fundraiser, and when a mom stood up to ask about the increasing number of unsupervised hall incidents, the principal just smiled and said “We’re all doing the best we can with limited resources right now” and called for the next agenda item. No follow up, no chance to push.
I’m a former special ed para, I worked in elementary schools for 8 years, so I know where the buck stops. Teachers aren’t the problem. Almost every teacher at Lila’s school texts or emails back within 24 hours, they stay late to grade, they buy their own classroom supplies when the budget runs out. I’ve talked to three of them off the record this year, and they all say the same thing: admin doesn’t back them up when they enforce policies, admin doesn’t fill empty support positions, admin walks the halls once a semester for a photo op and that’s it.
That’s when the so-called hot take hit me, scrolling through our parent Facebook group where 20 people were all venting separately, no one pushing for anything more than sympathy. Why don’t we make the principal and district admin come to a public town hall and answer for this? A lot of people told me that was too aggressive, that we’d be labeled as troublemakers and that would just make things worse for our kids. But what’s the alternative? Letting our kids go to school every day where they can’t focus on learning because no one is keeping basic order?
We organized it. We collected 127 signatures from parents and teachers, sent a formal request to every member of the local school board, and they finally agreed to host it in the high school auditorium two weeks before Thanksgiving. The heat was turned up too high, the microphones crackled, people brought coffee in disposable cups and kids colored on the back row while we talked. The principal showed up with a printed sheet of talking points, and the first person to speak was an 8th grade math teacher who’d worked at the school for 12 years. She said she’d put in seven work orders for a broken classroom door that won’t lock over the past two months, and no one had come to fix it. She said she’s afraid one of her kids will get hurt during an active shooter drill because the door won’t latch.
Then a parent stood up and said his 6th grader with social anxiety has stayed home 12 days this semester because he keeps being cornered in the bathroom between classes, and every report he’s made has gone unanswered. By the end of the night, the principal didn’t have any good answers. She kept going back to staffing shortages, but one school board member pulled the district budget up on his laptop right there, and pointed out that the district had received a $1.2 million safety grant two years earlier that was supposed to go to extra support staff. No one could explain where the money went.
A lot of people ask why a public town hall instead of private meetings with the principal. I tell them, private meetings let admin brush you off one by one. When everyone hears the same questions and the same non-answers at the same time, you can’t ignore the pattern. If you’re a parent dealing with the same constant chaos at your kid’s school, here’s what I tell people to do, concrete stuff that works: First, collect specific, dated incidents before you ask for anything. Don’t just say “the school is out of control” — write down “10/12/23, fight in room 214, 14 minutes without admin response” “11/3/23, broken door work order submitted, no response after 30 days”. Concrete details are impossible to brush off as overreacting. Second, don’t just send your request to the principal. Copy every school board member, because they answer to voters, and most don’t want bad press right before election season. Third, let teachers speak anonymously if they’re worried about retaliation — we let people submit questions in advance that we read out loud, so teachers could share their experiences without putting their jobs at risk.
It’s not like our town hall fixed everything. We don’t have a brand new, perfectly run school now, and I never expected that. But the district reallocated part of that unused safety grant to add two extra hall monitors for the rest of the school year, they fixed all the pending work orders that had been sitting for months, they put a new rule in place that says stolen item camera checks have to be done within three business days. Last month, there was another fight in the hallway, and admin was there in three minutes. It’s progress, not perfection. We’re scheduling another town hall next month to check in, because accountability doesn’t end after one meeting.
I know a lot of people call this a hot take, that asking admins to answer publicly is too confrontational. But I don’t see it that way. Public schools are run by public money, and the people in charge owe the parents and kids who show up every day an explanation when things are going wrong. It doesn’t mean we want to fire anyone, or demand impossible things. We just want answers, and a plan to fix it. Right now, we’re still waiting for a full explanation of that unused safety grant. We’ll keep asking.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What happens when a school runs amok: Why principals should answer parents at public town halls