What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down By Facebook Outrage: A Teacher’s Perspective
Last month, I was standing by the copy machine in my Virginia middle school hallway, grading 7th grade exit tickets after school, when Mia, one of my straight-A students who usually walks out with her soccer bag slung over one shoulder, stopped and leaned against the wall next to me. Her eyes were red at the corners, like she’d been crying in the bathroom before coming to find me. She held out her phone, screen open to the local parent Facebook group, and scrolled through 300+ angry comments. “They shut it down,” she said. “Before we even had our first meeting.”
PRISM, the LGBTQ+ student alliance the 7th and 8th graders had spent three months working to get approved, was gone. The kids had written proposals, presented to the PTA, followed every single rule the school board laid out for new clubs. The stated purpose was simple: provide a safe space for queer students and their allies to hang out, plan low-key school events like Ally Week, and talk about issues that come up for them that don’t get space in regular class. No curriculum, no formal politics, just after-school time once a week. Admin signed off in mid-March, and the kids were already hand-drawing posters to hang in the hallway.
Then a local parent who runs a conservative advocacy page shared the school board’s approval notice out of context. The post got shared hundreds of times, and I quickly noticed most of the commenters didn’t even have kids in our district. I clicked through a handful of profiles: a retired cop from Florida, a stay-at-home mom from Richmond 45 minutes away, a small business owner who went to high school here 30 years ago but hasn’t had kids in the system in decades. The comments were all the same: it’s grooming, it’s pushing a liberal agenda on kids, we need to pull our kids out if this stays. Within a week, the superintendent put out a statement reversing the approval, saying the club “needed further review” that would stretch into the next school year, effectively killing it for this year.
Mia told me she’d signed up because her best friend, J, is trans, and J gets called names in the cafeteria almost every day. J hasn’t come out to his dad yet, so he can’t talk about it at home. “We just wanted somewhere we didn’t have to whisper,” Mia said. That line stuck with me.
I’ve taught middle school for 12 years, and the thing most adults miss about middle school clubs is that almost none of them are about pushing an agenda. The baking club doesn’t force kids to become pastry chefs. The environmental club doesn’t yell at parents for driving SUVs. This club was just a space for kids who don’t fit the default to stop hiding. When it got shut down, I started thinking about what I could do that didn’t require going through a whole new approval fight that would take months.
Turns out, most school districts allow teachers to host informal lunch groups for social connection, no formal club approval needed. That’s the first concrete step I tell other teachers who ask what to do in this situation: don’t fight for a formal club right away if it’s already been shut down. Start small. I emailed my principal the week after PRISM got shut down and said I wanted to start a weekly social lunch bunch for kids who want to connect outside their regular friend groups. He said fine, no extra paperwork needed. We meet every Wednesday in my room, I move three extra desks together to make a big table, I grab a box of cheddar goldfish from the dollar store and leave out extra phone chargers. I don’t lead discussions unless the kids ask me to. Most weeks, they just hang out, play Uno, share TikToks, and complain about homework. That’s all they want.
For parents, the concrete step I suggest is simple too: if you’re a supportive parent with space, offer to host a low-key monthly meetup. Mia’s mom started a monthly game night at their house for the 12 kids who signed up for PRISM. They play board games, get pizza, and don’t have to worry about who’s listening. You don’t need to plan big activities or have all the answers about gender and sexuality. You just need a space where kids don’t have to whisper.
I ran into a dad at the grocery store two weeks ago who’d commented on that original Facebook post against the club. He has a 7th grader at my school, and we talked for a minute while we waited in the checkout line. He said he saw the headline “LGBTQ+ club approved for middle school” and got mad, because he thought it was going to be a sex education class pushing things he didn’t agree with. He never clicked through to the link to the club charter the school posted. “I just reacted to what I saw on my feed,” he said. That’s the core of what happened here: Facebook outrage doesn’t reward nuance, or reading past the headline. Most people don’t mean to hurt kids, they just don’t take the two minutes to check the facts before they comment.
The other thing I tell people is that shutting down the club doesn’t make the need for it go away. I still have kids coming to my class before school asking to change their pronouns on my roll sheet. I still have kids telling me they get harassed in the locker room for being gay or trans. Shutting down PRISM didn’t change any of that, it just made those kids hide it more. Which leads to more anxiety, more absences, lower grades—all the things those same parents say they want to avoid.
Last week at lunch bunch, we had eight kids show up. Mia brought chocolate chip cookies she baked, and they spent the whole period arguing about the ending of the new Heartstopper season. At one point, J joked about his dad not letting him get a pride flag for his room, and nobody stared or whispered. They just nodded and made fun of his dad’s terrible taste in TV, like normal kids do.
There’s already a new thread on that Facebook group talking about our “secret unapproved club” and demanding I get disciplined. I don’t know if we’ll get to keep doing this next semester. I don’t know when PRISM will ever get approved again. Right now, though, we have 45 minutes a week where eight kids don’t have to hide. That’s more than they had before. And that’s enough for today.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens When A Middle School LGBTQ+ Club Gets Shut Down By Facebook Outrage: A Teacher’s Perspective