What Happens If You Don’t Take a Regents After Failing a Class: A High School Teacher Explains
The copy machine by my classroom door was still humming from the last batch of finals when Mia slunk into my room after school last May, backpack slipping off one shoulder, transcript crumpled in her fist. She’d failed 10th grade biology that semester, missed three weeks with a bad case of mono that turned into pneumonia, and couldn’t catch up on 15 labs and four unit tests even with extra credit. The Regents exam for biology was scheduled for the following Tuesday, and she’d come to ask the question I get at least three times every exam cycle: does it even matter if I don’t take it?
I brushed a half-eaten Goldfish cracker off my desk and gestured for her to sit. I’ve been teaching high school in upstate New York for 11 years, so this question isn’t new. Every semester, at least one kid and one panicky parent email me the same thing, convinced that skipping this one exam is going to tank graduation chances and college admission before they even get there. It’s never as simple as yes or no, but I always think of Javi, who asked me the same question back in 2019, to remind me that consequences are real, but they’re almost never the catastrophic ones people imagine.
Javi failed 9th grade algebra first semester, was juggling after-school work to help his mom pay rent, and just couldn’t keep up. He decided skipping the Regents was a no-brainer: he already knew he failed the class, what was the point of wasting a Saturday morning sitting through a four-hour exam he was going to fail anyway? What he didn’t know was our district had a quiet rule I’d forgotten to spell out for him: you have to attempt the Regents after your first course attempt to be eligible to sign up for summer credit recovery. By the time he realized that, the summer course registration deadline was a week away, and he had to fill out a three-page appeal, get my signature, meet with the principal, and almost ended up having to wait until fall to re-take the class. That would have put him a full semester behind on graduation requirements, and would have made him ineligible for JV soccer the next year. It all got sorted out with the appeal, but it was a week of stress that could have been avoided if he’d just checked the rule first.
That’s the thing most people miss: whether it matters or not almost always comes down to two specific things, your district’s policy and your own graduation timeline. I’ve had other kids who skipped the Regents after failing a class and faced zero consequences. Two years ago, Lila failed 11th grade chemistry by 25 points, had already passed all five of the Regents she needed for her advanced Regents diploma, and her district didn’t require her to attempt the exam for credit recovery. She skipped the exam, re-took chemistry in summer school, passed, and graduated on time. Colleges never asked about the skipped exam, and it didn’t even show up anywhere on her final transcript.
When parents ask me what to do, I don’t give them vague “be supportive” advice. I tell them to do three specific, 10-minute tasks before making a decision, that’s it. First, log into your student’s parent portal and pull up the official graduation progress check. Almost every district posts this online now, and it will tell you exactly how many Regents your student has already passed, how many they still need, and whether this exam moves the needle at all for graduation. Second, send your guidance counselor one short, direct email: “My child failed [subject] this semester. If they don’t take the upcoming Regents, will that make them ineligible for summer or fall credit recovery?” No long backstory needed, most counselors can answer that in two sentences, no meeting required. Third, if there’s no rule forcing them to take it, ask one simple question: do they have a realistic shot at passing the Regents, even after failing the class? If they failed the class by less than five points, study a little over a long weekend, and have always done well on standardized tests, go for it. Some schools will allow you to count a passing Regents for course credit even if you failed the semester, which means you don’t have to re-take the class at all. If they failed by 20 points, missed weeks of class, haven’t touched the material since finals, skip it. Four hours of stress and a bad score won’t help anyone, and they can take the Regents when they re-take the class anyway.
As for college applications? I tell parents not to worry about this part. Colleges don’t care that you skipped a Regents after failing a class. They look at your final transcript, which shows you re-took the class and passed. The only time it comes up is for SUNY or CUNY schools that require specific Regents scores for admission, but they care about the passing score you eventually get, not whether you skipped your first attempt.
Mia checked with her guidance counselor that afternoon, and found out our district did require her to take the Regents to get into summer school. She showed up, got a 56, which was still a failing score, but that was all she needed to sign up for summer biology. She passed the class and the Regents in July, and this year she’s a junior taking AP Environmental Science. Last week she stopped by my room to borrow a pencil for her AP exam, laughed when I reminded her about the bio Regents, and said she’d forgotten all about it.
It’s easy to work yourself up over small, high-stakes sounding decisions like this, convinced that one wrong step will mess up everything. Most of the time, though, it’s just a small hoop. If you have to jump it, you jump it. If you don’t, you spend that four hours doing something more useful. Rarely is it the life-ruining mistake everyone worries it will be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens If You Don’t Take a Regents After Failing a Class: A High School Teacher Explains