What Gifted and Talented Elementary Teachers Wish Parents Knew About Bright Kids
The coffee ring on my conference table blurred the edge of Mia’s 3rd grade reading test score, the one that put her two full grade levels above where she’s supposed to be. Her mom leaned forward, voice tight, and said what I hear at least three times a semester: “I thought if she was gifted and talented, she’d know how to behave in class. Why is she always getting in trouble for talking?”
I’ve taught GT elementary for seven years, so I didn’t jump to fix the problem right away. I pulled out Mia’s work folder and flipped to the back, where she’d taped a drawing of a dragon breathing fire over a row of math problems. “She finishes every assignment in 10 minutes or less,” I said. “Then she has 20 minutes left to fill before the rest of the class is done. What would you do?”
Most people assume my job is just to give bright kids harder worksheets and prep them for advanced middle school classes. The reality is, I spend most of my time untangling the messy gap between how fast a kid’s brain works and what a typical elementary classroom can give them. A lot of that work is helping parents reframe what they’re seeing at home, too. Last year, I sat across from Javi’s dad, who was furious that Javi had a C in homework. Javi reads at a high school level and can do algebra in his head, but he refused to turn in more than half his assigned work. “He’s just lazy,” his dad said. “I’ve taken away his Xbox, I’ve grounded him, nothing works.”
I pulled out Javi’s math notebook, the one he hid from other teachers. Half the pages didn’t have any of the assigned problems on them. Instead, Javi had filled them with a 32-page guide to dinosaur weights, complete with his own calculations of how much a T-Rex would weigh if it were alive today, and graphs comparing that to the weight of a school bus. He wasn’t being lazy. He was bored. He already got the concept of graphing, so repeating 15 practice problems felt like a waste of time to him.
We worked out a simple deal that changed everything. Javi only has to do one third of his homework problems if he can show me he understands the skill. If he can nail the hardest problem on the page, he’s done. The extra time he would have spent on repetitive work goes to whatever project he’s interested in that week. That semester, his homework grade jumped to a B+, and he stopped hiding his notebook during silent reading.
That’s the first thing I tell parents, and it’s the simplest to test at home. Boredom almost always looks like misbehavior or laziness first. If your kid flies through their work and then starts messing around, don’t reach for punishment first. Try a small, low-effort adjustment: at school, I keep a challenge bin by my desk, full of dollar-store puzzles, blank comic books, pattern blocks, and nature scavenger hunt lists. Any kid who finishes early can grab something from it instead of sitting and waiting. At home, you can do the exact same thing: keep a small box of low-prep activities your kid cares about that they can only pull out when they finish their school work early. It doesn’t have to be fancy – mine has stickers and old magazines for collaging, too. And if they say the work is boring, ask them to prove they get the concept first. If they can do that, they don’t have to finish every single problem. That extra 15 minutes of curiosity is worth more than 15 extra repetitive math questions.
The second thing most parents don’t expect is that giftedness doesn’t mean your kid is good at everything. I had a parent last semester who came in upset because her GT 2nd grade daughter still struggled with messy handwriting and tying her shoes. “If she’s so smart, why can’t she do this?” she asked. The answer is simple: being ahead in abstract reasoning or reading doesn’t mean your kid’s fine motor skills develop any faster than anyone else’s. Just like any kid, they can have uneven skills. The concrete fix here is small: if your kid can tell you the answer out loud, don’t make them write it three times for practice. Let them type it, or draw it, if that’s easier. You don’t have to force perfection in every skill just because your kid is advanced in one.
I also see a lot of parents surprised by how early perfectionism shows up in gifted kids. Last month, Lila, a 2nd grader in my class, refused to turn in her volcano project because the baking soda didn’t flow right the first time she tested it. She crumpled up her whole paper and hid it in her desk, saying it was “bad” and she didn’t want anyone to see it. Her mom thought she was being dramatic, but gifted kids often get used to understanding things on the first try. When they hit something that takes practice, it’s the first time they’ve felt “not good at something,” and they don’t know how to handle it. The trick I use at school and at home with my own kids is simple: I don’t say “it’s good enough.” I just share my own messy mistakes out loud. Last week, I messed up a science demonstration in front of the whole class, and I said “see that? I got the measurements wrong, that’s okay, let’s fix it together.” At home, I’ll say “I burned the toast again, that’s two times this week, let’s try again tomorrow.” It normalizes messing up before they start to think any mistake means they’re failing.
A month after that first conference with Mia’s mom, Mia still gets in trouble sometimes. Last week, she drew a dragon on the bottom of my whiteboard because she finished her spelling test five minutes early, and all the puzzle books she likes were already checked out of the challenge bin. But she hasn’t been sent to the office in four weeks. Her mom started keeping a dragon comic drawing kit on a shelf in their kitchen, for when Mia finishes her homework 20 minutes early. Mia brought the first issue she made in to show me last week. It’s about a dragon who goes to 3rd grade, and gets in trouble for being bored. It’s not perfect, but it’s hers. And that’s the point, really. We don’t need to fix bright kids to fit into regular classrooms. We just need to give them a little extra room to be who they are.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Gifted and Talented Elementary Teachers Wish Parents Knew About Bright Kids