What Abused Children Need That Most Caregivers Miss: Lessons From A Yunnan Rescue Case
The first time I met 7-year-old Xiao Mi, she was stacking broken crayons in the corner of the activity room at the Kunming temporary care home. I’d volunteered to teach basic literacy there once a week, and the social worker had warned me she wouldn’t speak, probably wouldn’t interact. When a blue crayon rolled off the edge of her crate table, I bent to pick it up and reached toward her. She flinched so hard she knocked the whole stack over, then curled into a ball against the wall and didn’t move for 20 minutes. The room smelled like fermented bamboo shoots from the lunch the cook had left on the stove, and a leaky window by the door let in a cool October wind. I just picked up the other crayons, put them in a pile by her feet, and went to work with the other kids.
Xiao Mi is from a small village in southern Yunnan. Her parents died in a motorcycle crash two years before, and she went to live with her paternal uncle, who already had three kids of his own to feed. Neighbors called the child protection hotline after three months of hearing her crying through the walls of the locked attic he kept her in most days. She’d never been to school, never had her own pair of properly fitting shoes, and when she was rescued she was 10 pounds underweight for her age. A lot of the new volunteers would cry when they heard her story, or hover around her trying to give her hugs and new stuffed toys. It never worked. She’d just hide under the bed until they left.
I grew up in a small town not too far from her village, so I know how the winter tangerines taste there – sweet and a little tart, the kind you peel with your hands and the juice gets all over your wrists. The second week I came, I stuffed three ripe ones in my bag, and didn’t say anything about them. I set one on the edge of her crate table, sat down on the other side of the room to mark the kids’ writing worksheets, and didn’t look her way. Half an hour later, I heard a soft crack of peeling skin. When I glanced up, she was eating the tangerine, juice running down her chin, and she mumbled so quiet I almost missed it: “Sweet.” That was the first word any of us heard her say.
That’s when I realized how wrong almost all of us were getting it. We’d all been so focused on “fixing” her – getting her to talk, getting her caught up on schoolwork, helping her “heal” – that we missed the most basic thing she needed: safety from demand. Most of us don’t think about it, but any question, any request for interaction, even a kind one, feels like a threat to a kid who’s learned that any attention from an adult can lead to hurt.
The practical thing I started doing, that other volunteers started copying after, was just being around without asking anything. If I was there, I’d just do my work near her, leave a snack or a new crayon within reach, and never push for eye contact or a reaction. I never said things like “can you say hi to me?” or “don’t be scared.” We also started naming every move we made before we did it, because she flinched at any sudden movement. If I needed to walk past her to get to the door, I’d say “I’m going to walk past you now to get the trash, okay?” If I reached for a book next to her, I’d say “I’m grabbing the picture book here, I’m not going to touch you.” It sounds small, but it cut her flinching episodes by more than half in two weeks.
A few months in, when she started joining our literacy group, the local public school that was going to enroll her tested her and said she was “severely delayed” and might need long-term special education. I sat in on the test, and I saw what was actually happening: every time the tester leaned in to ask her a question, she’d freeze, she couldn’t remember anything she’d already learned a week before. It wasn’t that she couldn’t learn – it was that having an adult leaning over her, waiting for her to perform, triggered that old fear from the attic.
For teachers who get a kid like this in their class, the small adjustments make all the difference, and none of them cost extra time or money. Let them sit at the back of the room where they can see every door and every adult coming in, instead of the front row where their back is to the entrance. Let them get up to get a drink or stretch whenever they need to, don’t make them ask for permission. Don’t call on them to answer questions in front of the whole class until they volunteer. These aren’t special favors – they’re just basic adjustments that let a hurt kid’s brain relax enough to stop scanning for danger and start learning.
Last week, I went to the care home, and Xiao Mi met me at the door. She pulled my hand – she initiates touch now, sometimes – and led me to her bed, where she’d taped three crumpled drawings of tangerine trees on the wall. She’s moving to her new adoptive home in two weeks, a couple in Kunming who already have two teen kids and have cared for traumatized kids before. Last week, when the PE teacher clapped loudly to get everyone’s attention during outdoor play, she crawled into the storage closet and wouldn’t come out for 45 minutes. Some days she still won’t speak at all. She still can’t count past 20. No one knows what kind of long-term impact those three years in the attic will leave.
I gave her the bag of tangerines I brought this time, from a farm run by a friend of mine up the road from her old village. She peeled one, and handed me a slice. It was sweet, just like she said that first day. We sat on the steps outside for 15 minutes, eating tangerines, not talking. That’s enough, for right now. It has to be.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Abused Children Need That Most Caregivers Miss: Lessons From A Yunnan Rescue Case