Traveling With a Toddler: Is Business Class Worth the Extra Cost?
My 2-year-old Leo is wedged between my husband and me, his socked feet propped on the armrest, chewing a neon orange cheese puff that’s leaving crumbs all over the cream leather seat of our cross-country business class flight, and I’m staring at the extra $1200 we dropped on these tickets wondering if I just lost my mind. A year ago, we’d have never even considered this. We’re the couple that used to pack our own snacks to avoid airport coffee prices, and we still bicker about who spent $15 on a bad burrito last summer. But our last economy trip with Leo cured us of the “we just tough it out” mindset.
That flight was four hours to see my mom, and I still remember every minute of it. Leo was 18 months old, wiggly, obsessed with exploring. His economy seat had less leg room than his high chair at home. Forty-five minutes in, he refused to sit, screamed when we tried to strap him in, and spent the next hour twisting between our laps, kicking the back of the seat in front of us over and over. The man in that seat turned around every ten minutes to sigh and glare at us. I apologized so many times I lost count. I couldn’t stand up to stretch without bumping the guy next to me, and I couldn’t set my water bottle down anywhere without Leo swatting it onto the floor. When we landed, my legs were numb, my nerves were frayed, and I’d cried in the bathroom halfway through the trip because a flight attendant made a comment about needing to control our child. I was more tired after that flight than I’d been after pulling an all-nighter for work before Leo was born.
So this trip, when we got the check-in notification that we could upgrade both tickets to business for $600 extra each, we sat there for five minutes staring at the screen, then clicked confirm. We’d saved a little for the trip, and we both just agreed we couldn’t go through that again.
It wasn’t the magical peaceful flight Instagram makes business class out to be. Leo still had a 10-minute meltdown because his favorite fruit snack pack had strawberry instead of grape. He spilled half a cup of apple juice on my jeans. He climbed over the armrest three times to bother the nice lady sitting alone in the row ahead of us, and I still had to apologize more than once. But the difference was night and day. The extra leg room meant he could stand up, turn around, and jump a little without bumping the seat in front of us. When he got wiggly and wanted to walk, the aisle was half empty, so he could wander up and down without dodging drink carts and stepping on people’s feet. When he had that meltdown over the fruit snacks, we were able to step back to the small open area by the front galley to calm him down, instead of blocking the entire economy aisle for 20 people waiting to use the bathroom. When he finally napped an hour into the flight, the seat folded flat enough that he could lay down fully, instead of slumped over my shoulder with his feet digging into my ribs. I got to drink an entire cup of coffee while it was still hot. That alone almost made the $1200 worth it.
I’ve thought a lot about this since the trip, because so many parents online argue about this like it’s a black and white question, either you’re a spoiled parent who wastes money or you’re a terrible parent who subjects everyone to your kid. The thing no one talks about is that this isn’t about luxury for you. It’s about meeting your toddler where they are developmentally. Toddlers don’t have the self-control to sit crammed in a tiny seat for hours, no matter how many snacks or sticker books you bring. They need to move. That’s not bad behavior, that’s how their bodies and brains work right now. When you cram them into a space that doesn’t let them move, you’re setting yourself, your kid, and the people around you up for a bad time. Business class fixes that, mostly, by giving them the room they need.
But it’s not the only fix, and it’s not worth it for every trip. Let me break down what I’ve found works after two cross-country trips with a toddler: If your flight is under two hours, save your money. Even a wiggly toddler can make it that long with a new coloring book and extra goldfish. For flights over three hours, especially if you’re traveling alone with the toddler, it’s absolutely worth it if you can get it for a discounted price. Full price business class? Never. I’d never pay that. But almost all airlines offer last minute upgrades at check in for half off or less, and you can bid for upgrades for as low as $100 a ticket. If you can’t swing business at all, book a bulkhead seat in economy – you get the same extra leg room for a fraction of the price, that’s a great hack. If you’re traveling with two adults, one trick I’ve heard from other parents is to just upgrade one seat, then take turns watching the toddler in the extra space. That cuts the cost in half, and still gives you a break.
It’s not perfect. I still spent most of the flight chasing Leo around the front of the plane, not sipping champagne and watching a movie like I thought I might. But what I didn’t have was that constant, low-level anxiety that every little wiggle was going to upset someone, that I was a bad parent for having a wiggly kid. When you’re not stressed out about what other people think, you’re way calmer when your kid has a meltdown, which makes the meltdown shorter and easier for everyone.
We’re planning another trip this fall, six hours to see my husband’s family. We put in a low bid for two business class upgrades already. If we get it, great. If not, I’ll book the bulkhead economy seats, pack twice as many cheese puffs, and bring a new set of bath stickers to keep him occupied. It’ll work out either way. But I’m not gonna pretend I don’t hope our bid gets accepted. Some extra space for a wiggly toddler is worth every extra penny we can afford to spend.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Traveling With a Toddler: Is Business Class Worth the Extra Cost