The Biggest Problem in Today’s Education System (And What You Can Do At Home To Help)
Last Tuesday, I leaned against a rusted bike rail outside my daughter’s elementary school, sipping a lukewarm coffee, when Lila trundled over, one strap of her overstuffed backpack slipping down her arm, a crumpled math test clutched in her fist. She’d studied for three straight nights, making index cards for equivalent fractions and quizzing herself while we waited for her brother’s soccer practice to end. The grade at the top was a B minus. “I knew all the answers,” she said, kicking a loose piece of gravel. “I just ran out of time. Mrs. Henderson couldn’t wait, the whole class had to move on to reading.”
That wasn’t the first time this had happened. A month before, she’d turned in a book report on Because of Winn-Dixie where she wrote three whole paragraphs about how Gloria Dump’s foggy memory reminded her of my mom, who’s been living with Alzheimer’s for three years. She lost 20 points because she didn’t stick to the required five-paragraph introduction-body-conclusion format. The teacher wrote a note in the margin saying it was “nice personal reflection” but “didn’t meet assignment guidelines.”
I sub at this same school one day a week, so I don’t blame Mrs. Henderson or Lila’s English teacher. I’ve been in their shoes. Last month, I covered a third grade class and had to grade a reading response where one boy answered the question “Why did the squirrel hide his acorns?” with “Because he missed his mom who went to live in another tree and he wanted something that smelled like her to keep.” The state-approved answer key said “To save food for winter.” I had to mark it wrong. We have 12 standards to get through every week, assessment data to submit by Friday, and state test prep to fit in before spring break. There’s no time to sit with the weird, wonderful, slow answers that don’t fit the box. That’s the biggest problem, when you strip everything else away: our current system is built for fast, uniform output, not slow, personal, deep thinking. And we’re training kids to think their best work doesn’t matter if it doesn’t fit the timeline or the template.
It would be nice if the system changed tomorrow, but that’s not happening any time soon. So I’ve started making small shifts at home that don’t take extra money or a ton of time, just a little reordering of priorities.
First, we have one slow night a week, no exceptions. No soccer practice, no tutoring, no homework marathons. Whatever Lila and my son want to do that night, they can take as long as they want to do it. Two weeks ago, Lila spent an hour pulling apart pinecones in the backyard and sorting the scales by size, just because she wanted to see if all pinecones had the same number of scales. I didn’t rush her to come in for dinner, I didn’t tell her we needed to move on to reading practice. That hour of messy, unplanned curiosity is worth more than any 10-question timed worksheet.
Second, I changed the question I ask when they sit down to do homework. I used to say “Let’s get this done fast so you can have screen time.” Now I say “Show me the part of this assignment you liked working on the most.” It’s a tiny phrase change, but it shifts the focus from finishing fast to caring about what you’re doing. Last week, my son was working on a social studies worksheet about maps, and he drew a giant dinosaur on the back of his map of our town, where the dinosaur lives in the park. The teacher wasn’t going to look at the back, but we talked for 10 minutes about what the dinosaur eats and what he named it, instead of rushing to pack up the worksheet.
Third, when they bring home a bad grade or a paper with a lot of points deducted, we talk about what they’re proud of first, before we talk about what went wrong. After Lila brought home that B minus math test, we pulled it out at the kitchen table, and the first thing I asked was “Show me what you got right that you worked hard on.” She flipped it over, and there was a big hand-drawn diagram of a pizza cut into eight slices, showing how 4/8 is the same as 1/2, with little pepperoni slices drawn on each piece. She spent 10 minutes explaining how she thought of the pizza idea because we make pizza every Friday, and that’s how she remembers fractions. The teacher never even saw it, because it wasn’t on the front of the test where the answers were supposed to be. But we hung it on the fridge anyway, next to her A+ art projects.
It doesn’t fix everything. Lila still gets stomach aches on test days, she still comes home upset when she loses points for not following the rules. I still have to mark wrong answers off on worksheets when I’m subbing, because that’s what the system requires. But these small shifts make space for the kind of thinking that the system doesn’t have room for right now. Lila still writes the personal stories that don’t fit the required format, and she still takes her time working through math problems even if it makes her finish last. I don’t know if the system will change in time for her to benefit from a broader overhaul, but I know that at home, she gets to keep the part of her that thinks slow and thinks deep. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » The Biggest Problem in Today’s Education System (And What You Can Do At Home To Help)