Teacher Tested: Tab S10 Fe vs iPad 11 (A16) for Recording Online Teaching Videos
Last August, I stood in my chipped-desk spare bedroom studio, staring at the black screen of my 6-year-old tablet that’d just died mid-recording a 4th grade fractions lesson. I had 12 kids out that week with strep throat, all waiting on the flipped video to catch up, and my annual teacher supply stipend had just hit my account. I needed a new tablet specifically for recording online teaching videos, and a friend offered to lend me her new Samsung Tab S10 Fe while my cousin let me borrow her 2024 iPad 11 with the A16 chip for a two-week test run. My half-finished peppermint tea sat sweating on the corner of my desk, my ring light was clipped to the edge, and I got to work testing the things that actually matter for someone who records lessons every week, not just a tech reviewer looking for specs to bicker about.
The first difference that jumped out at me was the stylus. The Tab S10 Fe came with the S Pen tucked right in the box, no extra cost. When I unboxed my last tablet a few years back, I remember staring at the checkout screen and realizing I’d have to drop an extra hundred dollars just to get a working stylus to write on the screen. The 128GB iPad 11 A16 is priced the same as the 128GB Tab S10 Fe on the surface — both around $450 — but the working stylus for the iPad adds $99 to that total. That’s not a small gap for a teacher spending their own stipend, or a homeschool parent working with a tight annual budget. That’s almost an entire set of classroom novels or a month of science experiment supplies for my room.
I recorded the same 20-minute fractions lesson on both, same settings, same lighting, same script. I write fast when I’m explaining concepts, and I rest my palm heavy on the screen while I work. Stylus performance was almost identical on both. There was zero lag on the Tab’s S Pen, palm rejection worked perfectly, and I never had to wait for the screen to catch up to my hand. The same went for the iPad with the Apple Pencil. If I’d paid extra for the stylus, the performance was just as smooth. The only real difference here was the cost.
Next I checked camera and audio, two things that make a big difference for kids watching. I keep a small face cam in the corner of my videos so kids can see my face, just like they do in class. The front cameras on both were sharp enough. The iPad’s Center Stage feature automatically kept me centered when I leaned in to point at a problem, which was a nice little bonus, but I almost never move around while recording, so it didn’t change the final product at all. The iPad’s video came out a little sharper and cooler in tone, while the Tab’s was a little warmer, but when I watched both back on a student chromebook (the device 90% of my kids use), I couldn’t tell the difference. No kid is going to complain about color temperature when they’re just trying to learn how to divide fractions.
Audio was the first place I noticed a meaningful gap. My window AC unit was running that day — it was 88 degrees outside, so I couldn’t turn it off. The iPad’s built-in mics filtered out far more of the low AC hum than the Tab’s did. I could hear a faint background whoosh on the Tab’s recording that wasn’t there on the iPad’s. But that gap disappeared completely when I clipped on my $22 Bluetooth lapel mic, the one I keep in my desk drawer for quick recordings anyway. For $20, you get far better audio than any built-in tablet mic, so that’s an easy fix if you go with the Tab.
That weekend I tested battery and heat by batch recording five lessons for the upcoming week, each 15 to 20 minutes, back to back. I started both tablets at 100% charge, brightness at 50%, same wifi connection. When I finished, the Tab was at 42% and the iPad was at 31%. The back of the iPad got noticeably warm after the third video, not enough to shut down or anything, just uncomfortable to hold when I was moving it to adjust the worksheet. The Tab stayed cool the entire time. That’s a big plus for anyone who records all their weekly videos in one sitting, like I do. Exporting and uploading to Google Classroom was fast on both; the iPad was a minute faster, but both finished uploading a 20-minute 1080p video in under five minutes, so it didn’t change my day at all.
I ended up buying the Tab S10 Fe, and it’s worked perfectly for me for the last three months. I stayed under my $450 stipend budget, I don’t do any heavy video editing on the tablet itself (I do that on my old laptop), and the battery lasts all morning of batch recording. If I already owned an Apple Pencil from an older iPad, or if I used a Mac and iPhone for all my lesson planning and wanted everything to sync seamlessly, I’d have gone with the iPad 11 A16. It’s a solid, smooth device, and the built-in mic is great if you don’t want to bother with an extra lapel mic.
A first-year teacher at my school asked me which one to buy for her tutoring videos earlier this week, and I told her what I tell everyone: count your total budget first, including the stylus, check what other devices you already own that you need to sync with, and don’t overthink it. Both make perfectly good teaching videos, and your kids aren’t going to notice the tiny spec differences. Right now, I’m happy with my Tab, but I don’t lose sleep over the choice. It’s just a tool to get lessons to kids, and both do the job well enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Teacher Tested: Tab S10 Fe vs iPad 11 (A16) for Recording Online Teaching Videos