Teacher Shares: How To Help Quiet Struggling Students In China Who Won’t Speak Up
The fluorescent lights above my third-grade classroom were half off at 4:20 p.m. last October, and the only smell left was chalk dust and the orange peel a kid had stuffed under a radiator that morning. Most kids had bolted for after-school care, where their parents would pick them up after work, but I looked up from grading quizzes to see Xiao Ming twisting the strap of his scuffed Transformers backpack by my desk, his shoes scuffing the edge of the tile. He’d been hovering for five minutes, too quiet to get my attention. I waved him over, and he pushed a crumpled third-grade math worksheet across my desk, the paper dotted with more red crosses than his own ink. “My mom works night shift at the garment factory,” he mumbled, staring at his sneakers. “My dad can’t do division. Can you help me?”
I’d been volunteering at this public school in a small manufacturing city outside Hangzhou for six months, and most of the kids here are children of migrant workers from other provinces. Xiao Ming had joined mid-semester, after missing two months of school when his grandma had a stroke back in their village in Anhui. His parents had found him a spot at the school as soon as they could arrange it, but no one had thought to ask if he needed extra help catching up, and he never volunteered the information. His homeroom teacher had marked him as “unmotivated” on his midterm report, because he never turned in homework, never raised his hand, and never acted out enough to draw extra attention. That’s the thing about quiet kids who are struggling: they don’t make noise, so they don’t get noticed.
I sat down with him that first day, and quickly realized he didn’t just struggle with division. He had never learned the multiplication basics the rest of the class had covered before he joined, because he was still back in the village waiting for his grandma to be released from the hospital. His parents worked 12-hour shifts, couldn’t afford the private after-school tutoring that most local local kids relied on, and neither of them had finished middle school, so they couldn’t work through the problems even if they had time. I went to meet his mom a week later at her snack stall outside the factory gate, and she wiped her hands on her stained apron when I came over, and immediately apologized. “I came here to work so he can have a better life than me,” she said, folding a stack of paper napkins while we talked. “But I can’t even help him with his third-grade homework. I’m letting him down.”
I hear a lot of people talk about “helping kids in China” like it’s a big project that needs large donations or sweeping policy changes, and those things matter, of course. But the kids who need help most right now are the quiet ones slipping through the cracks in plain sight, and there are small, concrete things any teacher or caregiver can do that don’t cost any money.
The first change is simple: swap the question you ask when a kid doesn’t turn in work. Instead of “Why didn’t you do this?” which makes kids defensive and shuts them down, try “Is something getting in the way of finishing this at home?” When I asked Xiao Ming that the first time I pulled him aside, he immediately told me about his parents’ shifts and his little sister he has to watch some nights when both parents are working overtime. He never would have shared that if I’d yelled at him for late homework.
Second, don’t pile on all the missed work at once. A lot of schools expect kids to make up months of missed content in a week, which is impossible for a kid who’s already playing catch-up. Instead, I started meeting Xiao Ming for 10 minutes after school three days a week, right before after-school care starts. We only cover one small concept each session, no more. If we’re working on the 3-times multiplication table, we just practice that one set that day, and that’s it. I don’t assign extra homework after that, just ask him to recite it to himself a few times when he has five minutes free. It’s low stress, fits into everyone’s already packed schedule, and avoids the shame of falling further behind when you can’t keep up with extra work.
Third, if a kid’s parents can’t help with homework, don’t punish the kid for it. I made small check slips for Xiao Ming to stick in his homework book: just two boxes, “I can do this alone” and “I need help with this”. He ticks one every night, no signatures required, no long notes for his busy parents to write. If he ticks the second box, we work on it in our next 10-minute session. I talked his homeroom teacher into stopping marking his homework late if he brings it to me to do at school, so he doesn’t get zeroes that tank his grade for things out of his control.
It’s been four months now. Xiao Ming got a C+ on his last math test, which is a big jump from the F he got when I first met him. Some weeks, we have to skip our sessions because I have parent-teacher meetings or he has to leave early to pick up his sister from daycare. He still forgets to tick his check slip sometimes, and still hovers by my desk for a minute before he works up the nerve to ask for help. There’s still a lot he needs to catch up on, and I know that next year when I stop volunteering here, he’ll need someone else to keep showing up for those 10-minute sessions. But the thing I’ve learned is that helping doesn’t have to be big. It doesn’t have to fix everything at once. It just has to be consistent, small, and willing to meet the kid where they are. Most of the time, they’re already standing right by your desk, waiting for someone to ask what they need.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Teacher Shares: How To Help Quiet Struggling Students In China Who Won’t Speak Up