Tab S10 Fe vs iPad 11 (A16): What I Learned Testing Both for Online Teaching Videos
The blueberry muffin I’d grabbed for breakfast was still warm on my desk when my 10-year-old tablet died mid-recording. I was 20 minutes into a pre-recorded fractions review for the three 4th grade tutoring students who’d missed class that week, and there was no way to restart and finish before their quiz the next day. By the time I borrowed a neighbor’s laptop and re-recorded half the lesson, the muffin was cold and I was questioning whether I needed to bite the bullet and buy a new tablet specifically for making online teaching videos. I ended up testing two of the most popular options out there right now, the Samsung Tab S10 Fe and the 11-inch iPad with the A16 chip, over a month of Saturday morning recording sessions. Here’s what actually matters for teachers and parents making online learning videos.
I borrowed the Tab from a homeschool teacher friend who got it for her co-op classes, and my cousin, a full-time high school biology teacher, let me use her new iPad 11 for two weeks. I tested both the same way: same Wi-Fi, same recording app, same lesson lengths, same spots (my indoor desk, the front porch for outdoor science lessons, early morning sessions when the house is quiet but the lights are still low). The first thing that hit me was the upfront cost, which matters more for most of us buying our own gear than any fancy feature. I was shopping on a $500 budget, pulled from my tutoring income, not a school department. The Tab S10 Fe rings in right at $449, and the S Pen stylus you need for writing on worksheets is included. The iPad 11 with A16 is $499 for just the tablet, and the compatible Apple Pencil adds another $79. That’s a $129 difference, which is enough to buy a full set of math manipulatives or a three-month reading subscription for your class or kids. It’s not a small gap for most household education budgets.
Next, I tested the writing and display, which is the core of what you need for teaching videos. I pull up a student PDF worksheet for almost every lesson, writing step-by-step explanations as I talk, so smooth, readable writing on playback matters. The Tab has a 90Hz refresh rate, which means the screen updates faster than the iPad’s 60Hz. When I watched back recordings, the lines I drew on the Tab looked far more natural, just like writing on paper, even when I was talking and rushing through a problem. The iPad had tiny little skips I didn’t notice while recording, but that popped out clearly on playback. It’s not bad enough that kids can’t read it, but it feels less polished. Palm rejection (the feature that ignores your palm when you rest it on the screen while writing) was also more consistent on the Tab. I rest my whole palm on the screen when I write, and I only got one accidental stray mark in a month of recording. On the iPad, I got at least one or two accidental marks every other video, which meant I had to go back and edit them out, adding 5 or 10 extra minutes to every recording session.
Camera quality and battery life were next. Since I record early in the morning before my other jobs start, my room is usually pretty dim when I start. I keep a small overlay of my face in the corner of most videos, so the front camera matters. The Tab’s front camera gets noticeably grainy in low light. The iPad’s front camera handles dim light far better, and the image stays clear even when I only have my desk lamp on. Battery life went the other way: I recorded three 30-minute videos back to back on the same full charge, with the same screen brightness and Wi-Fi. The Tab ended at 41% charge, while the iPad dropped to 27%. The Tab’s extra battery life is a big win if you record a whole week of lessons in one sitting.
Workflow was the last big difference I noticed. I upload all my videos straight to Google Drive for students to access, and I usually switch to prepping my next lesson while uploads run in the background. On the Tab, a 1GB 4K video took 4 minutes to upload, and it kept running even when I switched apps to check my lesson plan. On the iPad, the same video took 6 minutes, and iOS often pauses background uploads when you switch apps, so I had to wait for it to finish before I could move on. That adds up over a month of recording. The A16 chip in the iPad does pull ahead if you edit video directly on your tablet, though. When I trimmed 10 clips together for an end-of-unit review video, the iPad never stuttered, even when I added text overlays and transitions. The Tab lagged a little during edits and crashed once halfway through.
I talk to so many new homeschool parents and first-year teachers who stress about having the best possible tech for their online videos, like if their gear isn’t top of the line, their kids won’t learn. But the truth is, most of the differences between these two tablets don’t affect student learning at all. They just affect how much time and money you put into your setup. If you’re on a tight budget, record mostly 15-30 minute lessons, and do your editing on a laptop anyway, go with the Tab S10 Fe. Grab a $15 clip-on ring light for your tablet if you record in low light, that fixes the grainy camera issue completely, and you’ll still spend less than you would on the iPad alone. If you already own other Apple devices, edit all your videos directly on your tablet, and you can swing the extra cost for the pencil, the iPad 11 A16 is worth it. If you do get the iPad, pick up a $10 third-party palm rejection glove for your writing hand, that cuts down on accidental marks way more than the default settings.
I ended up buying the Tab S10 Fe for my tutoring work. The ring light fixed the only big issue I had, and I do all my editing on my old laptop anyway, so the slower editing speed doesn’t bother me. My cousin still swears by her iPad 11 for her full-time high school lectures, since she edits 45-minute videos on her prep period directly on the tablet. Last week I recorded a whole set of multiplication lessons on it, and none of my students mentioned anything off about the video. They got their practice in, aced their quiz, and that’s the part that actually matters. I’m still testing different small setups to save time, but for right now, this works.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Tab S10 Fe vs iPad 11 (A16): What I Learned Testing Both for Online Teaching Videos