Structured Summer Camps vs. Free Unscheduled Time: What My Kids Taught Me Last Summer
Last June, I stood at my kitchen counter, sticky from the popsicle my 7-year-old Mia had dropped on the tile an hour earlier, and spread out a stack of summer camp brochures. My 10-year-old Leo leaned against the fridge, swinging a half-broken baseball bat he’d found at the park that morning, while I checked the dates against my work calendar. I was still full-time remote that year, so childcare was non-negotiable, and every mom I followed on Instagram was already posting their kids’ packed 10-week schedules: soccer one week, coding the next, STEM camp, art camp, a rotating cast of structured activities to keep them learning and out of trouble. When I pointed to the soccer camp Leo had enjoyed the year before, he kicked the base of the fridge softly and said, “Do I really have to go to something every week?”
I’d already convinced myself that empty weeks on the calendar meant I was failing. Idle summer days meant screen time marathons, forgotten math facts, wasted potential. So I signed Leo up for soccer anyway, and Mia for the week-long art camp she’d begged for, and crossed my fingers. After five days, Leo came home, dropped his mud-caked cleats by the door, and collapsed onto the living room couch. “We have to be there at 8:55 sharp,” he said. “We run laps for 20 minutes before we even play, and Coach yells if I stop to look at the bunnies in the field next to the pitch. I don’t want to go back next week. I just want to build my Lego spaceship and catch frogs in the creek behind the house.”
I panicked. I’d already paid the deposit for the next week’s coding camp. I had back-to-back meetings scheduled, no backup childcare. But I looked at him, red-faced from the heat, and I cancelled the camp. I ate the $150 deposit, shifted my meeting schedule around to work longer on the days Mia was at art camp, and gave Leo three full weeks of completely unscheduled time.
The first two days were exactly what I’d feared. He laid on the couch until 10 a.m., watched 90s cartoon compilations, ate three granola bars for lunch, and announced he was bored twice an hour. I bit my tongue every time, instead of suggesting an activity. I’d heard before that kids need to work through boredom to come up with their own ideas, so I just said, “That’s okay, you’ll find something to do,” and went back to my laptop. By the third day, he did. He dragged his old frog net out of the garage, pulled on his dirtiest shorts, and spent three hours down at the creek. He came back with two small green frogs in a mason jar, covered in mud, and asked to borrow my phone to look up what kind they were. For the next week, that was his whole project: he looked up their life cycles, drew pictures of them in an old notebook, and built a temporary habitat in a big plastic storage bin on the back porch. When Mia got home from art camp, the two of them added water plants and rocks, and spent an hour every evening watching them before releasing them back into the creek.
Leo finished his Lego spaceship, too – the one he’d started at Christmas and never had time for between homework and after-school practice. When he realized he was missing a specific 2×2 round brick in grey, he didn’t ask me to order it for him. He remembered the secondhand Lego store downtown, and we spent a Saturday afternoon browsing the bins, trading in some of his old unbuilt sets to get the piece he needed.
That’s when I started connecting what I was seeing to what I’d learned as a former elementary school aide. When every minute of a kid’s day is structured by adults, they never get to practice picking what matters to them. They get good at following directions, but they don’t get to figure out what holds their attention long enough to work through a problem, whether that’s missing a Lego piece or figuring out how to keep frog water clean enough for them to stay overnight. That doesn’t mean structured camps are bad, though. Mia came home every day from art camp buzzing about the new pottery techniques she was learning, and she still uses the mug she made there every morning for hot cocoa. She never would have tried hand-building on her own that summer, because she didn’t know it was something she could do.
The practical part that I’ve been sharing with my friends who ask is that it doesn’t have to be all or nothing. I used to think I had to pick one side: fill every minute or let it all go. Now I do a loose 50/50 split that works for my work schedule and the kids. If you need full-time childcare, you don’t have to do all camps – you can swap one full camp week for a half-day camp, and leave the afternoons open, or block out one or two weeks of unscheduled time between camps when a family member can watch the kids. If you’re worried about too much screen time, set a hard 2-hour daily limit, but let your kid choose when to use it, instead of banning it entirely or micromanaging what they watch. Leo ended up using more than half his screen time looking up frog facts and Lego building tutorials, not just scrolling short videos. The biggest change I made was asking the kids what they wanted before I booked anything, instead of just filling the calendar with what I thought they should do.
This year, we already have our schedule mapped out: two camp weeks for each kid, three weeks of unscheduled time, and a week-long family trip at the end. I still get that little twinge of guilt when I see other parents posting their full camp rosters. I still check occasionally to make sure Leo hasn’t forgotten how to multiply fractions over break. Last year, after all that unscheduled time, his fall reading assessment score was 10 percent higher than it was in spring, because he spent so much time reading about amphibians for fun. The house is messier during unscheduled weeks. There’s more crumbs on the couch, more mud on the porch, more days where we eat leftover pizza for dinner because I got wrapped up in work and Leo got wrapped up in his project. It’s not perfect. Some days it feels chaotic. But it fits us, and that’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Structured Summer Camps vs