Signs an 11 year old girl is struggling: What I learned worrying about my cousin
Last weekend, I stood in my aunt’s backyard swatting mosquitoes and holding a paper plate of over-vinegary potato salad, when I spotted Lila, my 11-year-old cousin, sitting alone on the back step. Three months ago, at Easter, she’d dragged all the younger cousins through the woods behind the house to hunt for salamanders, and talked my ear off for 45 minutes about the friendship bracelet business she wanted to start out of our grandma’s old craft bin. This weekend, she had her knees pulled to her chest, one hand picking at the frayed hole in her jeans, the other holding her phone so close to her face I could barely see her cheeks. When her 8-year-old brother begged her to play cornhole with him, she just shrugged and said “no.”
I’d brought the neon friendship bracelet kit I’d found at Target a week before, the one she’d texted me a photo of back in May saying she wanted it. When I handed it to her, she said “oh, thanks,” stuffed it into her hoodie pocket, and didn’t pull it out again for an hour. My aunt waved it off when I mentioned how quiet she was. “She’s just being 11,” she said, wiping burger grease off her hands. “All preteens are moody. She’s got good grades, she’s not getting into trouble, what do you want?”
I asked Lila if she wanted to come with me to the gas station down the road to get blue raspberry slushies, our thing when she was little and she wanted to get away from big family crowds. She nodded and grabbed her shoes, and the whole 10 minute drive there, we didn’t talk at first, just listened to the pop playlist she’d bluetooth-connected to my phone. When we pulled into the parking lot, she said, quiet enough I almost missed it, “Mia started sitting with the other girls at lunch now.” Mia was her best friend since second grade, the one she’d had sleepovers with every other weekend for as long as I can remember. “They make fun of my rainbow sneakers,” she said, pulling her foot up to show me. “Say they’re kid shoes. It’s whatever.”
I’ve worked as a paraeducator in a local middle school for four years, so I know how easy it is to write off small, quiet changes in 11-year-old girls as just preteen moodiness. Everyone expects preteens to pull away from family, to be glued to their phones, to be grumpy. Most of the time, if they’re still turning in homework and not getting sent to the office, we assume everything is fine. But the quiet withdrawal is often the first sign something is off. Kids this age don’t act out by throwing tantrums or skipping school the way older kids do, especially girls. They just stop doing the things they used to love. They stop bringing art projects home to show you. They stop asking to go get ice cream. They sit alone on steps scrolling their phones.
I didn’t jump in to fix it. I didn’t tell her to just make new friends, or that her sneakers were cool, or that those girls weren’t worth her time. All that does is make kids shut down, because it dismisses how they actually feel. Instead I just said, “It sucks when the thing you picked out because you loved it suddenly feels wrong just because other people say so.” She nodded, and by the time we got our slushies, she was talking more—about how her math teacher gives extra credit for creative projects, but she didn’t turn in her constellation poster because she was scared the other girls would see it and make fun of her messy drawings.
That conversation got me thinking about the small, concrete things any caregiver can do when you’re worried about an 11-year-old girl, that don’t require big family interventions or expensive appointments. First, stop asking “are you okay?” Nine times out of ten, you’ll get “fine” in response, because kids this age hate feeling like they’re being interviewed or pitied. Instead, ask small, specific, low-stakes questions. I text Lila once a week, not “how are things at school?” but “what’s the dumbest rule your school has that no one likes?” or “did you see that weird cat video I sent you?” Last week she replied with a 2-minute voice note complaining about how the school banned flavored water from the cafeteria, and that turned into her talking about how the girls who made fun of her sneakers got detention for bringing soda last week. No big forced heart to heart, just a casual chat.
Second, don’t call their problems “drama.” So many people write off preteen friend conflict as just drama, but for an 11-year-old, their friend group is their entire world. It’s not drama—it’s losing the person you thought would always be on your side. Just saying “that sounds really hurtful” is enough, you don’t have to solve it right away.
Third, give them an out when you need it. Lila gets overwhelmed by big family gatherings, where everyone asks her a million questions about school and friends. I told my aunt that next time Lila says she wants to sit in the car and watch a show or just be alone, she doesn’t have to force her to be “on” for the family. It’s a tiny change that doesn’t cost anything, and it takes a lot of pressure off.
It’s been three weeks since the BBQ. We’ve gone to the craft store after school twice, since I go there for classroom supplies anyway, and we get slushies after, and she can pick out one $5 craft thing for herself. She finished her constellation poster, turned it in, and got an A-. She still doesn’t open up about the girl group stuff every time we hang out. Sometimes we just drive and listen to music and don’t talk much. My aunt still teases her sometimes for being “such a preteen” and doesn’t always get why I make time to hang out with her. I still worry sometimes that it’s getting to her more than she’s letting on. But for now, it’s working. She knows there’s someone who’s not going to rush her to fix it, or tell her it’s not a big deal. That’s enough, for right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Signs an 11 year old girl is struggling: What I learned worrying about my cousin