Should We Go For a Third Kid? What I Learned Testing Our Capacity Before Deciding
Last Saturday, I was on my knees picking glitter slime out of the living room rug when my husband leaned against the doorframe, mug of lukewarm coffee in hand, and asked the question we’d both been dancing around for six months: “Do you think we should go for a third?” My first response was to throw a wad of paper towel at him. The slime had already seeped through the rug padding, 10 minutes earlier our 4-year-old had dumped his entire bowl of cereal on the couch, and right after that our 7-year-old yelled that I’d forgotten to pack her favorite granola bar for her soccer game. It felt like the worst possible time to ask, but I knew what he meant. We’d both had that little tug lately, the one that makes you look at newborns in the grocery store and feel a flicker of something that’s not just baby fever—it’s the quiet thought that maybe our little family isn’t done yet.
Everyone has an opinion on the question. My sister with three says it’s chaos but it’s the best kind she’s ever known. My best friend with two says she’s never been happier she stopped at two. All the articles online talk about college savings and losing sleep and whether you need a bigger car, but no one talked about the thing that kept me up at 2 a.m. turning it over: what does adding a third do to the two kids we already have?
A month before that Saturday, my oldest Lila’s teacher pulled me aside after school. She said Lila had been raising her hand for extra help more often, even with work she knows how to do, and she’d started picking fights with her table group during center time. I left that conference feeling guilty, because I knew why. Over the past year, as my youngest Jax got more active and needed more trips to the park and help with potty training, I’d started automatically saying “just a minute” to Lila when she asked me to watch her do a cartwheel or look at her new drawing. I told myself she was the big kid, she could wait. That’s when I started wondering: if I’m already struggling to show up for the two I have, what would a third do?
I came up with a silly little idea to test it out. We didn’t have a newborn to borrow, but we could fake the extra load. For two weeks, we added an extra three hours of daily responsibility to our plates, the same kind of time suck a third kid would bring. My husband took on an extra weekly work project that kept him at the office until 8 three nights a week. I signed up for a community ed class that meant I was out one evening a week and had an hour of homework to do after the kids went to bed each night. It wasn’t the same as a newborn who’d wake us up every two hours and need constant diapers and feeding, but it was enough to stretch our capacity the same way.
It only took three days for the cracks to show. Lila forgot to turn in her reading log two weeks in a row, because I never remembered to check her backpack after dinner when I was focused on my homework. Jax started biting again at preschool—something he’d stopped doing 18 months before. When I sat down with Jax’s teacher after he bit a kid during playtime, she said it was pretty clear he was craving more one-on-one attention. That hit me harder than any lecture could. I started tracking my one-on-one time each day, just jotting down how many minutes I spent with each kid without the other around, no phones, no work, no half-listening while I folded laundry. By the end of the two weeks, my average was 8 minutes a day for Lila, 11 for Jax. If we added a third, that number would drop by at least a third, probably more.
I talked to Lila about it, too, after that. I didn’t make it a big, formal talk, just asked her while we were folding socks one night what she thought about having a new baby. She didn’t hesitate. She said, “Would I still get to sit on your lap before bed?” I said of course, and she said, “But last week you fell asleep before I finished my story because you were tired.” That’s the thing no one tells you when you’re weighing the question. It’s not that you won’t love all three kids equally—everyone’s right that love expands. But time and emotional energy don’t expand the same way. You only have 24 hours in a day, and most of that’s already eaten up by work and meals and cleaning up slime.
After the trial, I started adjusting to free up more time. I cut out my 20 minutes of scrolling social media after the kids go to bed and wake up 15 minutes early each day, so I can have 10 minutes alone with each kid before Jax goes to preschool and Lila leaves for elementary school. That helped a lot, but it also meant I gave up the only quiet time I had for myself, which leaves me more drained by the end of the day.
We haven’t made a final decision yet, not really. We’re not trying right now, but we’re not closing the door forever. For other parents asking themselves the same question, I tell them to try the small stretch test first before they go back and forth for months. It’s way more helpful than debating car seat sizes or college tuition. Just add a little extra load to your week and see what slips. If the things that slip are just your own movie nights or coffee dates with friends, that’s one thing. If the things that slip are the small daily check-ins with your existing kids, that’s something worth sitting with. Also, just ask your kids. Even the little ones can tell you how they feel about sharing your time. It’s not their decision to make, but their input matters more than any influencer’s perfect family photo online.
Last night, Lila showed me a comic she drew about our family. It had her, Jax, me, my husband, and a tiny stick figure baby in the corner. I asked her who that was, and she said “that’s if we get a baby. I get to hold it first.” I don’t know if we’ll ever get there. Right now, we have enough slime and cereal spills and good nights and bad nights to fill every day we’ve got. We’ll check in again next year, when Jax is in full day kindergarten and Lila is in second grade. Maybe our capacity will be bigger then. Maybe it won’t. Either way, we’re not in a rush to find out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Should We Go For a Third Kid