Parenting Young Adult College Students: What I Learned When I Stopped Fixing Everything
My phone buzzed at 2:07 a.m. mid-way through Lila’s first college semester, and I was out of bed before I even opened my eyes. The chipped blue ceramic coffee mug I’ve carried to every school event since 8th grade soccer was still on the kitchen counter from that morning, and I grabbed it while I answered, already reaching for my laptop on the dining table. Lila was crying so hard I could barely understand her: she’d forgotten to register for her required pre-nursing lab, all the open spots were full, and she was convinced she’d have to drop out of the program before it even really started. I pulled up the biology department’s website already typing the advisor’s email address in a new tab, telling her I’d get this sorted by 9 a.m. when offices opened. That’s when she stopped crying long enough to say, “Mom. Just stop. I don’t need you to fix it. I just need you to let me panic for a little bit.”
I froze. I’d spent 18 years fixing things: the ripped prom dress the night before, the college application essay that needed a last-minute edit, the fight with her best friend that I mediated over coffee. Fixing was my love language, I guess. I didn’t know how to do anything else. I closed my laptop, sat back down on the couch, and said, “Okay. I’m here. That sounds awful.” Then I just listened. For 22 minutes, I sat there petting our old beagle who’d come to join me, and let her talk. She told me she’d already emailed the advisor that afternoon, she was third on the waitlist, she’d talked to a senior in the program who was dropping the lab to do study abroad and might give up her spot. She just needed to get the panic out before she problem-solved more in the morning. By the end of the call, she’d already calmed down, said goodnight, and hung up. I sat there for another half hour, wide awake, realizing I’d been doing this wrong this whole time.
I started talking to other parents of college kids at my book club, and almost every one of them said the same thing: we’re all stuck between wanting our kids to be independent and panicking that they’ll mess up their lives if we don’t step in. Over the past two years, I’ve picked up a few small things that work way better than jumping in to fix every problem. None of them are big, fancy changes, just small shifts in how I talk and react.
For example, I stopped asking “How’s college?” when we talk. That question always gets a one-word answer: “Fine.” Instead, I ask “What’s the most annoying thing that happened this week?” It’s specific enough that it doesn’t feel like a generic check-in, and it gets them talking about the small stuff that adds up to their whole experience. Last week, Lila ranted for 15 minutes about her roommate who keeps stealing her oat milk and leaving dirty mugs under the bed. That’s how I found out she’s already looking for a different apartment for next year, and she’s lined up a roommate from her nursing cohort that she likes way better. I never would have gotten that out of “How’s college?”
Another small shift: when they tell you about a problem, wait 10 full seconds before you say anything. I count silently in my head now. Most of the time, the silence makes them keep talking, and they’ll lay out what they already plan to do, before you ever offer a solution. Before I started doing this, I’d jump in with my fix within two seconds, and Lila would shut down, because I’d just taken over her problem. Now, that 10 seconds gives her space to lead.
And if they do ask for help, I always ask one question first: “Do you want me to fix this for you, or do you want me to help you fix it yourself?” It’s such a simple question, but it clears up all the confusion. Last semester, her car broke down two hours from campus, and she called me stressed out because she couldn’t pay the tow truck fee right away. She answered that she just needed me to cover the cost, and she’d pay me back from her barista paycheck the next week. That’s all she needed. I didn’t have to call the mechanic, argue about the price, or drive up to get her. I just sent the money, and she handled the rest. If she’d wanted me to fix it, I would have, but 9 times out of 10, she just wants a little support, not a full takeover.
It doesn’t always work. I still slip up sometimes. Last month, I texted her to ask if she’d finished her FAFSA renewal yet, three days after she told me she was doing it that weekend. She didn’t text back for 14 hours, which is her very polite way of telling me I overstepped. I apologized, said I was just curious, not nagging, and she texted back a screenshot of the confirmation page with an eye-roll emoji. We moved on.
Some days I still lie awake worrying that she’ll make a mistake I could have prevented. But the lab incident? She got the spot a week later, she emailed the department head herself, she adjusted her schedule to make sure she stayed on track for graduation. She texted me a screenshot of her new schedule with confetti emojis, and I just texted back “Nice work.” I didn’t add anything cheesy about knowing she could do it. Just nice work. That was enough.
We’re still figuring this out. Parenting a kid who’s technically an adult but still needs you sometimes isn’t a thing you get right once and check off a list. Some weeks I do better than others. But so far, stopping myself from fixing everything has worked a whole lot better than the old way.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Parenting Young Adult College Students: What I Learned When I Stopped Fixing Everything