Parenting Tips: What To Do When Your Middle Schooler Wants To Ask An Older Crush Out
I was unloading the dishwasher Tuesday afternoon when my 7th grade daughter Lila leaned against the kitchen counter, crumbs of cheddar goldfish sticking to the cuff of her hoodie, and twisted the drawstring so tight her knuckles went white. “Mom,” she said, not looking at me. “I need your advice. I want to ask Jaden out. He’s two grades above me.”
I almost dropped the cereal bowl I was holding. My first split-second thought was the same I bet a lot of parents have: Two grades? Isn’t that weird? Isn’t she too young for this anyway? But I paused, wiped my hand on my jeans, and remembered six months ago, when she was scared to try out for art club and told me she didn’t want me to just say it’d be okay, she just wanted me to listen. So I pulled out the chair across the counter from her and sat down.
“Okay,” I said. “Tell me about Jaden.”
That’s when it all came out. He’s a 9th grader, helps run the pottery wheel at the after-school art club she joined in September. Last week, he left the club early to walk a stray kitten hiding by the bike rack over to the animal shelter, and shared his last granola bar with the cat on the way. He remembers that Lila takes her hot chocolate with extra marshmallows from the club snack cart, and he never laughs when someone’s lopsided mug collapses in the kiln. She’d been thinking about asking him for a week, she said, but every time she got close her throat felt tight. All her friends said a two-grade gap is weird, that he’d think she was weird for asking, that he’d say no and tell all his 9th grade friends and she’d have to hide in the bathroom for the rest of the year.
I thought about my own 7th grade year, when I had a crush on a 9th grader who bagged groceries at the town market. I wrote my first name paired with his last on the back of my math notebook, practiced asking him to the spring dance for three weeks in front of my mirror. I never worked up the nerve to do it, and I still remember how that felt, like I’d lost a chance just because I was too scared to speak up.
The thing a lot of parents don’t talk about when it comes to middle school crushes is that this isn’t really about dating. Not really, anyway. It’s about your kid learning how to take a small social risk, how to name what they want, how to handle whatever answer comes back. When I see other parents shut this down immediately because of an age gap, or because they think their kid is too young, I get the instinct. But what that teaches them is that their feelings aren’t something they can bring to you, that you’ll judge them before you listen. I’d rather Lila try and get a no than never try at all, and never come to me with this kind of question again.
That said, a two-grade gap in middle school isn’t nothing. Social development jumps a lot between 7th and 9th grade, and there’s a difference between a nice kid who likes pottery and someone who’s going to make your kid feel pressured. I don’t do big, awkward talks about boundaries that just make everyone uncomfortable. Instead I asked her one concrete question: “When you hang out with him at art club, does he ever make you feel like you have to do something you don’t want to do, or hurry up to keep up with him, or act different than you are around your friends?” She thought about it for a second, then shook her head. Said he always waits for her to finish cleaning her pottery before he leaves, that he asks her about her favorite anime, that he never treats her like a little kid just because she’s younger. That was enough for me. If she’d said anything else, anything that made her feel off, we’d have talked through why that’s a sign to step back, and that’s that. But it wasn’t the case here.
Next, we talked through how she wants to ask him. She’d gone back and forth between texting him on the club group chat and asking him after art club when it’s just the two of them cleaning up. I didn’t tell her which one to pick. I just walked through the concrete pros and cons with her, like I would with a friend. If you ask in person, there’s no leaving you on read for 12 hours while you overthink every word, but you have to deal with the answer right away. If you text, you can go walk around the track or hide in your room after you send it, and he has time to think before he answers. She thought about it for a minute and said she wants to ask him in person, that it feels more brave.
I also told her my own rejection story, the real messy one, not the polished “everything works out for the best” version. I told her I was in 8th grade, I asked a 10th grader two grades above me to the homecoming dance, he said no in front of all his friends by the lockers, I cried in the bathroom for 20 minutes, then my best friend bought me a cherry slushie and we skipped the rest of the pep rally and watched bad movies at her house. It hurt for a week, I said, and then it didn’t. That’s way more useful than just saying “rejection isn’t the end of the world” because it’s real, it’s messy, and it lets her know it’s okay if it hurts.
Tomorrow’s Thursday, which is the day art club meets. I packed an extra granola bar in her backpack this morning, just in case. I told her whatever happens, we’ll stop at the ice cream place on the way home from school, and get her favorite mint chocolate chip. If it goes well, we’ll celebrate. If it doesn’t, we’ll get extra sprinkles and watch that terrible vampire show she loves on Netflix.
I don’t know how it’s going to go. Jaden might say yes, he might say no. Either way, Lila’s already done the hard part: she named what she wanted, she asked for advice, she’s getting ready to take the risk. That’s the thing that matters more than any answer, anyway. And if it doesn’t work out this time, she’ll know she can come back and talk to me about the next one.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Parenting Tips: What To Do When Your Middle Schooler Wants To Ask An Older Crush Out