Parenting Tips: How to Teach Kids What a Fair Financial Split Really Looks Like
The beep of the Target checkout scanner cut off our argument mid-sentence. Lila, my 12-year-old, had her hand clamped around the side of the $60 Lego Harry Potter Hogwarts set she’d been begging for for three months. Jax, my 9-year-old, peered up at me holding his crumpled allowance envelope, like I was supposed to pull the perfect answer out of my coupon binder. “It’s simple,” Lila said, shifting her weight. “We’re splitting it 50/50. We both play with it equally, so that’s fair.” Jax pulled out his bills and counted them out loud: 12 dollars. “I don’t have 30. That’s not fair. I’m only gonna use it half the time, but I can pay what I can. Why do I have to miss out just ‘cause I don’t get as much money?”
I told the cashier we’d hold the set for an hour, herded the kids back to the car, and texted my mom group chat right then. I didn’t have a ready answer, so I was seeking any and all opinions. What would you do? Two kids, shared toy, can’t do 50/50.
The replies rolled in fast, as they always do. My friend Sarah, who has two teen boys close in age, said 50/50 is the only fair rule. If Jax can’t pay his half, he doesn’t get to share. It teaches him to plan ahead and save for what he wants, she said. Another friend, Mia, said she splits proportional to allowance. Her kids get $1 more per year of age, so if my 12-year-old gets $12 a week and 9-year-old gets $9, a $60 set becomes $34 and $26, that makes sense. Another mom said she’d just buy the whole thing and call it a day, why waste a Saturday afternoon fighting over 18 bucks? A teacher friend of mine said she makes her students split costs for shared classroom supplies based on how much each person uses, if one person’s gonna take it home at the end, they pay more.
We got a pepperoni pizza on the way home, the kitchen table was sticky with soda and grease by the time we sat down to talk it through. I’d spent the drive thinking about all the opinions, and I realized I’d always defaulted to 50/50 with my kids for shared stuff, just because it felt easy. It’s what I grew up with, right? Equal shares mean fair. But that never accounted for the fact that Lila now babysits twice a month and pulls in an extra $40 or so on top of her allowance, while Jax only gets $8 a week for doing his chores. Equal dollar amounts don’t mean equal sacrifice. $30 to Lila is a night of babysitting. $30 to Jax is almost a month of allowance. That’s not the same thing, no matter how you slice it.
I didn’t tell the kids what to do. Instead, I wrote the numbers on a napkin, just like we do for their homework. First, I wrote down how much each of them had saved total: Lila had $82 from babysitting, Jax had $12 from birthdays and allowance. Then I said, what if we split this based on how much of your total savings each of you would be paying? If we do that, Lila would pay $52, Jax would pay $8. That adds up to $60, and it means both of you are giving up about 63% of your current savings to get this set. That’s equal, right?
Lila frowned for a minute, did the math in her head (she’s good at that), and said, “Wait, if I was buying this by myself I’d pay all $60 anyway. That’s less than I’d pay alone, and Jax gets to play. That works for me.” Jax counted out his 8 one-dollar bills right there on the sticky napkin and nodded so hard his glasses slipped down his nose. We went back, bought the set, and they built it together on the living room floor that night, no yelling about who got to place the roof bricks.
I’ve been thinking about all this for a few weeks now, and I’ve found that the default 50/50 rule I grew up with doesn’t really work when your kids have different amounts of money, different needs, and different uses for the thing they’re buying. The practical thing I’ve started doing that works for us is pretty simple: first, never step in with your answer right away. Ask each kid what they think fair is first, that way you get to hear how they’re reasoning through it, which is the whole point of teaching them about money anyway. Second, write down the numbers where they can see them. Kids don’t abstractly get what “fair” means, but they can see that 10% of your money is 10% of your money, no matter if that’s $5 or $50. You can use that exact line with them, too: “Equal amounts of money aren’t the same as equal sacrifice. This split means both of you give up the same share of what you have.” Third, it’s okay to ask other people what they do. There’s no one right rule that works for every family, every kid, or every shared purchase.
Last weekend, they asked about splitting the cost of a $25 ticket to a local comic con for kids. Lila wants to go to sell her handmade friendship bracelets, Jax just wants to go play the indie game truck. They started arguing about the split again before I even said anything. I just pulled out a napkin and pushed it across the table, and they started writing down numbers themselves. We haven’t bought the tickets yet, and I still don’t know if the split they land on will feel fair to both of them a week from now. I’m still asking friends what they think when I get stuck. That’s okay, I think. Teaching kids about money and fairness isn’t about getting every split right the first time. It’s about practicing, one sticky napkin at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Parenting Tips: How to Teach Kids What a Fair Financial Split Really Looks Like